Lec 11: Health Care Costs And Cost Control Flashcards
What are some reason why health care cost is important?
Affects demand
Affects how we get paid
Biggest problem = COST
What are the three parts of kissick’s iron triangle?
Cost at top, quality at left, access at right
Key facts about cost: How much is spent on healthcare per person?
$9,990
Key facts about cost: What is the share of economic activity (GDP) devoted to health care?
17.8%
Key facts about cost: If growth rate is going up, then…
Something is driving this change
Key facts about cost: Where is spending the greatest?
In 2013… 10x more than it was in 1980
US per capita health care expenditures: Growth ______, remains in step with ___________
SLOWS
Overall economy
US health care expenditures as a % of the GDP: Growth trend line is going ____
UP
Distribution of national health expenditures, by type of service: _______ is the biggest piece of the pie in terms of where money is spent
HOSPITAL CARE (know this)
The US spends a lot more compared to other countries, T/F?
True
Explain the US health expenditure vs. life expectancy
We are spending way more than everyone else, but life expectancy is not that great
Impact of increasing health care costs (5)
Affordability of CARE Affordability of INSURANCE Burden on businesses Individuals not getting needed care Increased use of government programs
There is a burden on businesses (employee sponsored healthcare), because the cost of providing health insurance to their employees continues to go ___
UP
Why are health care costs so high?
There is a disagreement on drivers of rising health care costs
(What are the 4 reasons?)
Moral hazard
Demographic shift
Reduced consumer ownership
Unnecessary spending
What is moral hazard?
Once someone has insurance coverage that someone else is paying for, they will use more of it
What is a demographic shift?
People get older, they use more care.
More old people = it will cost more
What are some examples of unnecessary spending?
Fraud and abuse
What is the cost equation?
C= P x Q Cost = Price x Quantity
What are the two factors driving increased cost?
Prices
Volume & Intensity
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Prices:
Concentration of _______ ______
______ and _______
If you are living in the city where you only have a few hospitals, prices will go ___
Market power
Supply and demand
UP
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Prices:
__________ ____: working in practice and all these rules you need to follow, you need to hire someone to do this for you.
Administrative costs
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
Fee for ______
Service
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
_________ care and care systems - we do not have a coordinated system where the work has already been done follows us around; different specialists do their own test
FRAGMENTED
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
Medical ______
Technology
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
_________ liability
Malpractice
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
Increased prevalence of _______ conditions
Chronic
Factors Driving Increased Cost: Volume&Intensity:
Changing ________
Demographics
Two types of “Painful” cost control: Reimbursement
- Price controls
- Utilization controls
Price controls: (2)
- Mandated uniform fee schedule
2. May result in cost shifting to other payers, increased utilization; reduced quality of care/patient satisfaction
Utilization controls (3)
- Changing unit/methodology of payment
- Patient cost-sharing (deductibles, co-pays)
- Utilization management (controlling the volume of services provided)
Utilization is about ______. Movement from ________ to more _______ services
VOLUME
Fee for service
Bundled
CMS interprets the ______
Who decides what is appropriate under Medicare?
LAW
CONGRESS
Insurance companies have a certain ______ for making decisions
Algorithm
And they do not have to tell you what it is
If you spend more money, your outcomes will get _______, to a point, and then they will ______
Better
Level off
What does it mean by shifting the cost curve?
Health of population improves
We cannot keep throwing money at healthcare outcomes because it will level off at a certain level
Where are the efficiencies for the “curve C” of health care cost/outcome curve?
It is still the same curve, and it will still level off
But spending less to get better outcomes for the patient
(6) Painless cost control strategies
- Controlling FEES and provider INCOMES
- Cutting the PRICE of pharmaceuticals and other supplies
- Reducing admin WASTE
- Eliminating medical interventions of NO BENEFIT
- Substituting LESS costly technologies that are equally effective
- Increasing the provision of those preventive services that cost less than the illness they prevent
Managed care includes (2):
1) _______ _______ created, in part, to manage cost
2) Original intents also included improving ______ and ______
Insurance model
Quality and access
What is a managed health care plan?
An arrangement that integrates financing and management with the delivery of health care services to an enrolled population
A managed health care plan employs or contracts with what?
With an organized system of providers, which delivers services and frequently shares financial risk
The 3 basics of managed care include:
- _______ make up the plan’s network
- How much the plan pays depends on the ___________
- _______ plans generally cost less; more ______ plans cost more
- Providers
- Network’s rules
- Restrictive, flexible
What are the three TYPES of managed care plans?
HMO (Health Maintenance Org)
PPO (Preferred Provider Org)
POS (Point of Service)
HMO: usually only pay for care __________
Within the network
HMO: Who coordinates most of the care?
PCP
HMO:
_______ requirement for referrals
Only they decide when you can see someone _______ of that network, unless it is an emergency
_________ will not be covered under any circumstances
_____ cost
Strict
Outside
Out of network
Low
PPO: usually pay _____ if care occurs within the network, but they still pay a _______ for outside network care
More
Portion
PPO: Usually have a ____ if he/she refers you, then the plan will pay _____
PCP
More
PPO: if out of network, you will have to may ______ of the cost
MORE
POS: plans permit choice btw ___ and ____ each time care is needed
HMO and PPO
POS is a ______
Hybrid
POS: you have a _______ provider network and encourage you to have a _______, but do not require it
Contracted
Gatekeeper
POS: _____ co-pays and patient responsibility if you go ______ of network
Higher
Outside
POS: More _______
Flexible
Evolution of managed care cost control strategies: EARLY strategies include: (4)
- Selective provider networks
- Provider risk contracting
- Primary care gatekeeping
- Utilization review
In provider risk contracting, the ____ you spend on managing your patients, it is in your best financial interest
LESS
In provider risk contracting, you are rewarded as a provider for keeping ________ down
Utilization
In utilization review, someone within the HMO is…..
Looking at what was done
Evolution of Managed Care Cost Strategies: Increased investment in ______ and ______ management
Disease and case
Managed care concerns: Advantages of managed care perceived to employer, not consumer (________ cost)
Decreased
Managed care concerns: Issues of provider _______, ability to access provider panels
Autonomy
Managed care concerns: ____ relaxation of restrictions, _____ hospital market power due to consolidation
HMO
Increased
HMO peak enrollment in _____; began to _____
1999
Decline
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Continued cost ________ - renewed _________
Increases
Interest
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Reintroduction of prior _______ requirements
Authorization
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Increased concurrent ________ of care
REVIEW
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Disease management, targeting ______ risk patients
HIGH
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Tiered provider networks based on measures of _____ of care provided - track data based on what you bill, and they know who are the low and high utilizers
Cost
Managed care backlash/resurgence: ________ ______ incentives
Quality care
Managed care backlash/resurgence: Benefit design, cost ______
Sharing
Managed care backlash/resurgence: ______ directed plans
Consumer
General proposals to contain cost: (7) things
- Government regulation
- Adjusting provider compensation
- Investment in IT
- Improved quality and efficiency
- Prevention
- Increased consumer involvement in purchasing
- Altering tax preference for employer sponsored insurance
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: Unnecessary services — overuse, beyond _______ levels, unnecessary use of ______ cost services
Evidence based
High
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: Inefficiently delivered: Care fragmentation, unnecessary use of _____ cost providers, _______ inefficiencies at sites
HIGHER
Operational
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: Excess administrative costs: Insurance paperwork beyond benchmarks, administrative inefficiencies, ___________ requirements
Documentation
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: Prices that are too high: Service and product prices _______ benchmarks
BEYOND
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: Missed prevention opportunities: ______, ______, and _______ prevention
Primary
Secondary
Tertiary
Estimated sources of excess cost in healthcare: FRAUD: All sources including: _______, _____, _____
Payers, clinicians, patients
There is the most excess cost in: _________ _______
Unnecessary services
8 ways that we can improve efficiency to reduce cost?
- EMR/Health IT
- EBP
- ______ based payments
- ________ directed health care
- Prevention, ________ disease management
- Eliminating ______ and _______
- Management development and diffusion of new _______
- Comparative effectiveness
- Quality
- Consumer
- chronic
- fraud and abuse
- technologies
Choosing wisely aims to promote conversations between ______ and _______ by helping patients choose care that is:
- Supported by _______
- Not _______ of other tests or procedures already received
- Free from ______
- Truly _______
Physicians and patients
Evidence
Duplicative
Harm
Necessary
What does policy data say about PT?
Payer tracking MedPAC Government accounting office (GAO) Office of Inspector General (OIG) Part B National Summary Data File
What happened in the OIG August 2014 Report?
Review of Illinois’s PT Medicare Claims for Therapy Services Provided
Out of 100 claims that were reviewed, 99 of them contained more than one deficiency.
The therapist improperly received ALOT of money that did not comply with the Medicare requirements. So he had to refund that money back to the government
Spending ________ 2000-2004
DOUBLED
More beneficiaries used ______
Services
There is considerable _______ in spending per beneficiary
Variability
What are 3 limitations in claims data?
No outcomes data
Limited diagnosis data
Provider identifiers