Leasing/letting Flashcards
What is the ultimate objective when leasing a property?
To advise your client to marketing strategy to achieve their goals – usually this is the highest rent to the strongest covenant for the longest lease
What RICS document is there that relates to leasing/letting?
- RICS professional Standard: Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020)
- Mandatory
- Effective from 1st September 2020
- Objectives of new Code:
o To improve the quality and fairness of negotiations on lease terms
o Promote the use of a new set of comprehensive HOTs to make legal drafting of leases more efficient
What is the structure of RICS professional Standard: Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020)?
- Part 1: Introduction
- Part 2: Mandatory Requirements
o Negotiations must be approached in constructive and collaborative manner
o Party who isn’t represented must be advised by the other party/agent about the existence of the Code and must be advised to get professional advice
o HOT’s must include below as a minimum:
Identity and extent of premises (Land registry compliant lease plan)
Any special rights granted (e.g. car parking)
Length of lease
Inclusion/exclusion from 1954 LL&T Act
Break clause
Requirements for guarantor / rent deposit
Rent, frequency of payment
Whether exclusive of business rates
If VAT is charged on rent
Rent free periods / incentives
RR basis of review and frequency
Liability to pay SC and/or insurance premiums
Rights to assign/sub-let/share
Repairing obligations
Permitted use and whether changes of use are allowed
Alterations
Reinstatement obligations
Conditions - Subject to contract
- Subject to surveys
- Subject to board approval
- Subject to planning permission
o Lease renewal/extension, HOT’s must comply with above expert for any terms that are stated to follow the T’s existing lease subject to reasonable modernisation - Part 3: Lease negotiation best practice
o Includes specific advice on lease terms to include rent deposits, RR’s, SC, repairs and alienation clauses - Part 4: Appendices
o A: Model HoT’s
o B: Guidelines for LL&Ts
Detailed practical guidance for both parties on a range of lease terms and letting issues - Negotiation of HOT’s, rent deposit, SC etc.
- Checklist of payment for occupancy costs
What is the purpose of the RICS Professional Standard – Code for Leasing Business Premises (2020)?
- Leases should allow tenants to assign the whole of the premises with the LL’s consent NTBUWOD
o LL’s may set out circumstances for refusal (should be reasonable and appropriate)
o Requirement for AGA clause should be stated in lease - Leases should allow tenants to sublet the whole of the premises and may allow subleases of parts, if appropriate without security of tenure, with LL’s consent NTUWOD and at a rent not less than market rent
o Subleases should be required to be on terms consistent with the tenant’s own lease
What are the key lease terms that affect the value?
- Lease length / term certain
- Alienation – subletting/assignment
- Alterations
- Repairing
- Dilapidations
- Insurance
- User clause
- Break clause
- Rent review pattern and basis of valuation
- Security of tenure provisions
What types of alienation provisions can you have?
- Open – allowing alienation
- Qualified – subject to some conditions
- Absolute – not allowing a sub-letting or assignment
- Usual clause is that the LL’s consent is NTBUWOD
What is the difference between an assignment and a sub-letting?
- With an assignment, the new tenant (T2) has a direct relationship (privity of contract) with the landlord
- Whereas, with a sub-letting, the new sub tenant (T2) has a direct relationship with the tenant (T1) and pays them the rent, who then pays rent to the landlord
Why would you want to sub-let rather than assign?
- Requirement of the lease
- For part of the demise and not the whole
- If the market rent is higher than the passing rent which generates a profit rent
- If the tenant wants to re-occupy in the future
- The new party is of a lesser covenant strength
What would you do if you received an application for consent to assign/sub-let?
- Read lease
o Does it allow for sub-letting/assignment
o Are there any reasonable grounds for withholding consent - Is proposed rent the market rent and/or same as the passing rent?
- What will impact be on investment value?
- What is covenant strength of new tenant?
- LL’s remedies for illegal alienation: forfeiture, damages or an injunction
What is the LL&T Covenants Act 1995?
- Relates to assignment of leases
- Act abolishes privity of contract for new leases
- Pre 1995, all tenants had privacy of contracts which meant that they were responsible for the obligations under the lease even if they’d assigned or sublet
- LL&T Covenants Act gave landlords more scope for setting conditions regarding the approval of an assignee
- It introduced AGA’s for the most recent former tenant only to guarantee the lease obligations of the immediate assignee as a voluntary arrangement to be agreed between the LL&T
- Section 17 notice must be served upon a guarantor within 6 months of the tenant defaulting to require the former tenant who has entered an AGA to pay the arrears
- Can only be one AGA at a time
- AGA’s should be avoided if the new tenant is financially strong enough =, pays an appropriate rent deposit and/or provides a suitable guarantor
What is the current legal position of an AGA?
- G1 may guarantee T1’s obligations in an AGA (and so indirectly guarantee T2’s performance of covenants)
- G1 cannot direct guarantee the performance of T2’s obligations
- G1 cannot take an assignment from T1
How might a landlord protect their position/investment if a tenant wishes to assign to a weaker covenant?
- They can request an AGA as set out in the LL&T Covenants Act 1995
Does an AGA also affect sub-lettings?
- No because the landlord doesn’t have a contractual relationship with the sub-tenant
What are alterations?
- Alterations are carried out by a tenant during the lease
- They must usually be approved in writing by the landlord prior to undertaking the works
- They are usually subject to reinstatement at the end of the lease
- Some works such as demountable partitioning or other non-structural works may not require LL’s formal consent so always read lease
What document is required before the tenant makes alterations?
- License for alterations
- To be completed before the works commence
- Most licences require the tenant to reinstate the works at the end of the lease
- Licence must clearly document the works agreed
What is the purpose of the license for alterations?
To protect parties at rent review and dilapidations at the end of the lease
What do you do if you receive an application for consent for alterations?
- Read lease – do you need LL’s approval for changes/improvements to the demise (consent isn’t always required)
- Ask for full set of plans and specification
- All alterations need to be documented
- Check long term impact (if tenant defaults)
- Consider if reinstatement is required at the end of the lease
- Check equality act 2010 and CDM 2015 compliance
What are the main points of the LL&T Act 1927?
- If a lease doesn’t allow improvements being made to a property without LL’s consent, s.19 imposes a proviso that such consent cannot be UW
- If the s.19 procedures have been followed, the LL may be obliged to pay compensation for alterations that may constitute improvements
What’s an implied covenant?
- Relates to residential premises
- Contract interpretation to ensure that the parties’ reasonable expectations are fulfilled
- For business premises, if there are no express covenants, the tenant is required to use the premises in a tenant like manner
What’s an express covenant?
- A covenant where there is a specific order (e.g. keep in repair, leave in repair, put in repair, fair wear and tear)
- Most leases contain an express covenant stating “the tenant should not make any alterations or additions or improvements to the demised premises without the prior written consent of the landlord (NTBUW)”
On what grounds could the landlord refuse consent?
- Poor Covenant
- Poor or undesirable use
What could the landlord do if the tenant had a poor covenant strength?
- Refuse consent
- Request additional security such as a rent deposit or guarantee
What are the requirements of a rent deposit?
- Must be personal to the tenant
- Must be legally documented in a rent deposit deed
- Money held in separate bank account
- Interest to tenant
- Agreed terms for release of money
- Details of how the money will be released
- Can include top up mechanism for RR uplifts
- Rent deposit deed attached to lease is separate deed
What do you request from the tenant as a minimum to check their covenant strength?
- 3 years audited accounts
- Business plan
- Credit rating (D&B)
- Previous/existing LL reference
- Bank, accountant and 2 trade references
What are dilapidations?
- Always read lease and see if there is a SoC and any licenses for alterations
- Tenant is usually required to return the building to its original state, or otherwise stated in the lease
- These negotiations take place at the lease expiry to bring the property back to its condition at the start of the lease assuming that there is a repairing liability
- S.146 notice must be served (usually draft version informally first)
- Claim is limited to cost of works or in accordance with s.18 of LL&T Act 1927, the diminution in value of the reversionary interest
- If LL proposes to demolish/substantially refurbish, the value of the reversion could be nil
What are the two options that tenants have before the lease expiry date?
- Tenant can do the agreed works
- Tenant can pay a sum to the LL to undertake works
- Breach + loss + evidence = recovery