Learned helplessness and optimism Flashcards
Triadic experiments with dogs lead to the theory of
learned helplessness
3 group experiment is known as a
Triadic experiment
what are the 3 outcomes of uncontrollable circumstances
COGNITIVE deficit:
2. MOTIVATIONAL deficit: belief that outcomes are uncontrollable; lack of response initiation; and, if the outcomes are aversive
3. EMOTIONAL deficit: fear & eventually depression
- CRITICISMS OF ORIGINAL THEORY OF LEARNED HELPLESSNESS
- Goes beyond the experimental findings (effect in dogs exposed to electric shocks) 2. Fails to explain why a third of subjects show no effect
- explanation of depression: become helpless) (a) paradox of self-blame (b) fails to explain why not depressesssed
When organisms experience uncontrollable outcomes, they explain it in terms of 3 attributional dimensions:
INTERNAL - EXTERNAL DIMENSION: Determines personal or universal helplessness (& accordingly self-blame) STABLE - UNSTABLE DIMENSION: Determines ‘chronicity’ (persistence) GLOBAL - SPECIFIC DIMENSION: Determines generalisability to new situations
3 attributional dimensions:
You fail exam (negative outcome) “I’m stupid” is an example of:
internal, stable, global
3 attributional dimensions:
You fail exam (negative outcome) “The Exam was unfair” is an example of:
external, unstable, specific
3 attributional dimensions:
You come top in exam (positive outcome) you think “I’m brilliant” is an example of
(internal, stable, global)
3 attributional dimensions:
You come top in exam (positive outcome) you think “ I was lucky” is an example of
external, unstable, specific
The revised theory of learned helplessness (1978) assumes some people have a depressive (pessimistic) attributional style, and have a tendency to
- give ‘internal, stable, global’ attributions for bad outcomes
-give ‘external, unstable, specific’ attributions for good outcomes
According to Alloy and Abramson (1979) depressed college students were more
accurate (realistic) in making judgments about their performance in an experimental task
According to Alloy and Abramson (1979) non depressed college students were more
likely to over-rate their performance
Beck’s theory proposes three types of distortion: 1. negative distortions about 3 levels:
SELF
WORLD
OTHERS
Depressed people have negative ——— (sets of cognitions, beliefs, attitudes etc) about
Schemas
- SELF (I’m unlikeable)
- WORLD (nothing ever goes right)
- OTHERS (nobody cares whether I live or die)
Beck suggests ——- ——— is a major factor in maintaining depression
distorted thinking