law and justice Flashcards
what did plato say virtue of both individuals and societies
An overarching virtue of both individuals and societies, so that almost every issue he would classify as ethical comes under the notion of justice. Example, it is unjust for a person to steal from someone else, or not to give them money that they owe them.
distributive justice
concerned with the fair distribution of resources among different areas of society and relates to concepts such as equal pay, minimum wage and benefits
what is social justice
equal justice for all, not just in the courts, but in all aspects of society
what is procedural justice
concerned with the legal itself. Procedural justice requires a legal system to provide rules, principles and machinery for application of the law to everybody equally links to our work on access to justice
substantive justice
content of legal rules themselves. The rules are measured against principles of fairness and justice. Kinks to our work on evaluation of offences and defences
what is corrective justice
the way in which society deals with those who have broken the law- this links to sentencing and also to remedies in tort and contract law
what did Chaim Perelman concluded about justice
cannot be studied logically bc each person will define it according to their own subjective values
what did plato defined justice as
harmony
what type of justice did aristole apply
distributive and corrective
what did aristotle think about law
law was derived from nature. A just law was one which enabled people to fulfill themselves in society.
what is distributive justice in aristotle
just state will distribute its wealth based on Merit(VIRTUE).
so the worthiest, rather than the neediest, receive the greatest share. Aristotle argues that allocating resources based on people’s needs would be unjust, as it would reward the lazy at least as much as the hard-working
what is corrective justice in aristotle
where the legal system acts to correct attempts by individuals to distrust this fair distribution
what did thomas aquinas think abt law
derives from God and coincides with morality
what is fairness governed of aquinas concept of law
by ‘due proportion’: people receive what they are due in accordance with their merit, rank and need.
what is a merit - Aquinas
It would be wrong to pay workers an equal amount for an unequal amount for equal work.
what is a rank - Aquinas
People of higher social status will require a greater proportion of society’s benefits
what is need - Aquinas
There is a moral obligation to look after the poor. You can think about how this relates to benefits and to the minimum wage
what did marxist develop with justice
different model of distributive justice: “from each according to his abilities, to each according to his needs”
each person should maximise his contribution to the common wealth by making full use of his abilities.
what did Perelman think abt what justice is
that each person would define justice according to his or her own subjective values
what is social justice - Perelman
equal justice for all, not just in the courts, but in all aspects of society
what did Perelman identified and discuses different theories of justice
-To each according to his merits
-To each according to his needs
-To each according to his works
-To each equally
-To each according to his rank
-To each according to his legal entitlement
what did Rawls think abt justice
is about having rules that benefit everyone. A just society will allow enjoyment of wealth but will also ensure protection of the vulnerable, equality of opportunity and protection of basic rights.
what is the ability of social justice - Rawls
that people have to reach their potential in the society they live in.
People, from the poorest to the wealthiest should have equal rights and opportunities.
According to Rawls, justice is based on fairness.
what john rawls know for
‘veil of ignorance