Jurisdiction and Venue Flashcards
Obtain Subject Matter Jurisdiction THROUGH
Either
1) Diversity of Citizenship (2 elements); OR
2) Federal Question
Amounts in Controversy
- Must be in EXCESS of 75K
- Plaintiff’s good faith assertion is sufficient.
- Courts must have “legal certainty”
Can plaintiff add claims?
- Plaintiff can ADD claims if one exceeds $75K
- Single Plaintiff can ADD claims against Single defendant to reach $75K
If there are multiple plaintiffs, what is the amount in controversy rule?
- If single plaintiff meets $75K, then other plaintiffs can join
- If no one has a claim that exceeds $75K, cannot join
If there is a class action suit, what is the amount in controversy rule?
- only one member needs to meet $75K
Diversity Jurisdiction
1) case exceeds $75K AND
2) Complete diversity of citizenship
What is Diversity of Citizenship?
No plaintiff may be a citizen of the same state as any defendant
Citizenship means…
Where you are domiciled:
present location AND intent to stay
Foreign Citizens
US Citizen + Foreign Citizen = Diversity
Two Foreign Citizens = NO Diversity
Corporations domicile…
State of incorporation AND principal place of business (can have 2)
Joining Parties
Cannot improperly join a party just to obtain Diversity
Federal Question
1) Plaintiff’s claim must be based on federal law
2) Well-Pleaded Complaint Rule: Federal Issue must be OBVIOUS
Is Federal Issue as a defense a federal question?
NO
Federal Question Cases
- Admiralty
- Maritime
- Intellectual Property (copyright, trademark, patent)
Supplemental Jurisdiction
Court will add a case e, which by itself, would not have met subject matter jurisdiction if they arise from a “common nucleus of facts” in an existing case
In Supplemental Jurisdiction: Diversity cases:
New party cannot destroy diversity of citizenship
Supplemental Jurisdiction generally ALLOWED
1) compulsory counterclaim
2) joinder in compulsory counterclaim
3) cross-claim
4) impleader of 3rd party defendants
Supplemental Jurisdiction generally NOT ALLOWED
1) original plaintiff vs. 3rd party defendant
2) compulsory joinder
3) joinder of defendants
4) intervention
Generally, if [_____] is trying to add new party, is OK. If [_____] is trying to add new party, not OK.
Defendant; Plaintiff