judiciary branch Flashcards
What did Alexander Hamilton argue in Federalist No. 78?
that granting life tenure to judges of the federal courts enabled judges to issue opinions that were lawful and constitutional even when they were unpopular with the public/political classes
What is judicial activism?
a decision by a court (usually the Supreme Court) that strikes down a law passed by Congress/state legislature as unconstitutional without clear textual authority
What is judicial pacifism?
when a court allows a law passed by Congress/a state legislature to go into effect even if it seems to clearly violate the text of the Constitution
What is judicial restraint?
a choice by a court to allow Congress/a state legislature to pass a law that doesn’t clearly violate the text of the Constitution
What is a judicial precedent?
a firmly established legal principle that future courts are supposed to follow
What does “stare decisis” mean?
Let the decision stand.
What are the five factors to consider when overturning a precedent of the Supreme Court?
- The precedent prevents people from being able to settle the issue via voting for lawmakers to write laws to strike a balance between two sides of an issue.
- The precedent lacks ground in the text of the Constitution. It is neither directly addressed nor is anything closely analogous addressed.
- The precedent is unworkable. It hasn’t settled the issue and the courts have continued to struggle with how to apply the precedent to issues that arise in new lawsuits.
- The precedent is causing distortions in other parts of the law. If the same methods, reasoning, and approach were applied in other areas of the law it would lead to clearly illogical, unlawful, and/or unconstitutional results.
- Overruling the precedent would not upend concrete reliance interests of individuals. This means that people’s lives wouldn’t be significantly disturbed in the future by personal decisions they made in the past for their in reliance on the previous Supreme Court precedent being changed.
Where in the Constitution is the Judicial Branch established and outlined?
Article III
What does Article III of the Constitution do specifically?
It creates the Supreme Court and authorizes Congress to create inferior courts.
What did the Judiciary Act of 1789 create?
U.S. District Courts, United States Circuit Courts of Appeal, and the Supreme Court
Who represents the federal government in trial courts?
the United States Attorney
Which circuit court of appeal has subject matter jurisdiction?
the Federal Circuit
What does the Federal Circuit have jurisdiction over?
intellectual property and government benefits law
The appellate courts exercise what kind of review?
mandatory
What is an en banc appeal?
an appeal to the entire appellate court to reconsider a case
Who represents the federal government in appellate courts?
the Solicitor General
What does “en banc” mean?
the entire bench of a particular court
What does a party submit to ask the Supreme Court to review their case?
a petition for certiorari
When the Supreme Court grants review to a case, what do they issue?
a writ of certiorari
What is court packing?
an attempt by the president/Congress to shift Supreme Court rulings in their favor by adding judges to the court
In a criminal case, if the defendant is found to have broken the law, what are they declared?
guilty
In a civil case, if the defendant is found to have caused alleged harm to the plaintiff, what are they declared?
liable
What did the Supreme Court rule in Dred Scott v. Sandford and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Taney Court ruled that a slave wasn’t a citizen of the United States and therefore had no legal right to be a party in federal court. A slave owner’s constitutional right to due process and property prevented the government from declaring their slave free just because they had escaped to a state where slavery was not legal.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Plessy v. Ferguson and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Fuller Court ruled that it was constitutional for the government to segregate facilities by race as long as those facilities were equal.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Lochner v. New York and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Fuller Court ruled that the state of New York lacked the ability to restrict the number of hours that bakers could work because it interfered with the bakeries’ and bakers’ Fourteenth Amendment liberty interests to freely negotiate and agree to enter into an employment contract for the number of hours they would work. This ruling was later overturned because of the state’s Tenth Amendment reserved powers.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Grovey v. Townsend and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Hughes Court ruled that the Democratic Party of Texas could restrict African-Americans from voting in its primaries because it was a private organization and the Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection of the laws guarantees only applies to the government.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Smith v. Allwright and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Stone Court ruled that when a private organization is carrying out a government function (such as voting and police protection), the private organization has to provide the same Constitutional protections that the government would have to provide. This ruling overturned Grovey v. Townshend.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Brown v. Board of Education and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Warren Court ruled that separate was inherently unequal under the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause and forced public schools (and, by interference, other public/government institutions) to desegregate. This ruling overturned Plessy v. Ferguson.
What did the Supreme Court rule in Mapp v. Ohio and which court was the opinion issued by?
The Warren Court ruled that illegally obtained evidence is inadmissible in court.