Interrogation Law Deck #2 Flashcards
Custody
A suspect is in “custody” for Miranda purposes when they have been formally arrested or when their freedom of movement has been restrained to the extent associated with a formal arrest.
Custody Test
Would a reasonable person in the suspect’s position believe they were under arrest? Pennsylvania v. Bruder.
Custody Test for Juvenile
Would a reasonable juvenile of that age feel free to leave or believe they are arrested.
Seizure
When a reasonable person would not feel free to leave (stopping someone’s movement).
Amendment Protecting Seized Individuals
Fourth Amendment
Amendment Protecting Custody Individuals
Fifth Amendment
Voluntariness
Totality of the circumstances
State v. Jackson
The fact that officers lie to the suspect about the existence of evidence or witnesses against them does not mean the subsequent confession is automatically involuntary. Instead, the court will include the use of deception as one factor in the “totality of the circumstances” test.
Miranda v. Arizona
Custodial interrogation interpretation of the Fifth Amendment.
Interrogation related to Miranda v. Arizona
Statements or questions designed to elicit an incriminating response; “questioning initiated by law enforcement officers after a person has been taken into custody or otherwise deprived of their freedom of action in any significant way.”
Traffic Stop and Miranda
Stops for traffic violations are not normally considered custodial for Miranda.
Exceptions to Miranda Requirement
- Routine Booking Questions,
- Public Safety Exception,
- Spontaneous, volunteered statements that are not the result of custodial interrogation,
- Custodial or noncustodial questioning by non-law enforcement persons who are not acting as agents of the police or by undercover officers.
Routine Booking Questions
Questions designed to further the arrest process are, by definition, not designed to incriminate the suspect (e.g., height, weight, eye color).
Public Safety Exception
Even if custodial interrogation occurs, questions involving the location of a dangerous weapon or instrumentality that threatens public safety may be permitted under the public safety exception.
Spontaneous, Volunteered Statements
Statements that are not the result of custodial interrogation do not require Miranda warnings.
Custodial or Non-Custodial Questioning by Non-Law Enforcement
Noncustodial questioning by non-law enforcement persons or undercover officers does not require Miranda warnings.
Juvenile Miranda Warnings
- That the juvenile has a right to remain silent,
- that any statement the juvenile makes can be used against the juvenile,
- that the juvenile has a right to have a parent, guardian, or custodian present during questioning,
- and that the juvenile has a right to consult with an attorney.
Minimum Age for Juvenile Waiver of Right to Have Parent Present
16 years old.
Waiving of Rights
- knowing,
- voluntary, and
- intelligent waiver from the suspect.
Valid Waiver of Miranda
The suspect must make the decision to waive (not the attorney). If the suspect’s waiver of rights is ambiguous, the officer is allowed to ask questions to clarify.
Invocation of Right to Silence Only
Officers may approach again if the suspect invoked the right to silence only after a substantial amount of time has passed or if the suspect initiates the conversation. Miranda warnings must be re-read.
Noncustodial Interview Techniques
Noncustodial interviews do not require Miranda warnings and do not involve custody or arrest.
Techniques include:
* informing the suspect they are not under arrest,
* not surrounding the suspect with officers,
* not displaying weapons,
* allowing the suspect to make phone calls or have a cigarette.
Fifth Amendment Rights during Interrogation
The Fifth Amendment rights protect suspects from self-incrimination during interrogation by law enforcement officers.
Sixth Amendment Rights during Interrogation
The Sixth Amendment rights protect suspects by ensuring the right to counsel during interrogation and other critical stages of prosecution.
Inculpatory Statement
Statements that incriminate someone in a criminal act.
Exculpatory Statement
Statements that exonerate someone from a criminal act.
Difference between Seizure and Custody
Seizure under the Fourth Amendment involves restraint of a person’s freedom of movement, while custody under the Fifth Amendment involves formal arrest or significant restriction of freedom equivalent to arrest.
When are Miranda Warnings Required?
Miranda warnings are required when both custody and interrogation are present.