Integrating Criminological Theories/Life Course (Quiz 5) Flashcards
Theory Competition
The logical, conceptual, or empirical comparison of two or more theories to determine which offers the better or best explanation of crime
Theory Integration
identify commonalities in two or more theories to produce a synthesis that is superior to any one theory individually
Example of theory integration
Institutional-Anomie Theory: Merton’s Classic Anomie Theory+Marxist Theory
Types of theory integration
conceptual, propositional, within level, cross level
Conceptual (theory) integration
concepts from one theory overlap in meaning with concepts from another
Propositional integration
using propositions about a variable from one theory to explain the variation in variables from another theory
Within level integration
focusing solely on micro or macro level explanations
Cross level integration
using macro level theories to frame micro level theories
Examples of theoretical competitions
Free will vs. positivism, nature vs. nurture, innate human nature (noble savage vs. hedonistic calculator vs. tabula rasa), definition of crime (classical vs. consensus vs. conflict), and focus of criminology (causes of law breaking vs. process of law making)
Each of these integrated theories must be
compatible with one another but also conceptually distinct
Two of the most popular theory integrations have come from
Developmental/Life Course Criminology
Developmental/Life Course theories focus on the link between
juvenile delinquency and adult offending
What is the key assumption of developmental/life course theories/criminology?
the genesis of adult crime begins in adolescence (or earlier)
Developmental/Life Course theories claim that anti-social behavior begins in childhood and
persists into adulthood
Desistance
to stop
DLC criminology also attempts to explain
desistance of crime
Age crime curve
Crime is most prevalent during mid to late adolescence. The incidence of crime increases until ages 16-20. The incidence of crime then decreases with age in adulthood.
What percent of juvenile delinquents stop committing crime?
85%
What percent of juvenile delinquents continue to commit crime?
15%
Big questions in the DLC theory
Why does juvenile delinquency start and end? Why does some juvenile delinquency grow into adult criminality and other juvenile delinquency doesn’t?