* Hot topics Flashcards
Alfie Evans
WHAT
* Alfie Evans was an infant suffering from an undiagnosed neurodegenerative disease.
* He was placed on life support at Alder Hey hospital, who by 2017 discussed switching off life support, since it was deemed to be “unkind and inhumane”.
* The parents did not agree and so a legal battle ensued. The hospital won and the ventilator was turned off.
ISSUES
* Taking up ward space and equipment
* Parental autonomy -> Should the parents be allowed to demand treatment?
* When are experimental treatments for the good of the patient?
* Is prolonging life at all costs a good thing?
* How could the situation be mediated to reach a solution when parents and doctors don’t agree?
MMR vaccine and 2013 measles epidemic
surgeon Andrew Wakefield published a researcher paper showing that there was a link between the administration of the Measles
called for th suspension of MMR until further research could be done
suggested parents opt for single jabs agains measles mumps e.t.c separated by gaps of one year
manyh parents around the world became worried about their child developing autism as a result of the MMR vaccination and decided against giving the vaccine to their child
0 resulted in more cases of measles being reported in 2008 than any year since 1997
more than 90% of those infected had not been vaccinated
Charlie Guard
WHAT
* Charlie Gard was a child born with a condition that inhibited the function of his mitochondria
* He was taken to GOSH and placed on a ventilator
* The condition has no cure, but experimental therapies are happening in USA
* After the boy suffered seizures, GOSH determined that his condition was very poor, with brain damage and a lack of feeling and awareness. They discussed and recommended switching to treatment.
* However, the parents did not agree and wanted to take the boy to USA for treatment, which they raised funds for.
* A legal battle ensued, which resulted in the courts deciding that the boy should not receive the treatment since the damage to his brain was irreversible and any success would likely only prolong his suffering.
ISSUES
* Taking up ward space and equipment
* Parental autonomy -> Should the parents be allowed to demand treatment?
* When are experimental treatments for the good of the patient?
* Is prolonging life at all costs a good thing?
* How could the situation be mediated to reach a solution when parents and doctors don’t agree?
Euthanasia / Assisted suicide
Both euthanasia and assisted suicide are illegal in the UK. Euthanasia is punishable by life imprisonment, while assisted suicide is illegal under the 1961 Suicide Act and punishable by up to 14 years in prison.
It’s important to understand the difference between passive euthanasia and withdrawing treatment in a person’s best interests. Passive euthanasia is illegal in the UK. However, the NHS states that withdrawing life-sustaining care when in a patient’s best interests can form part of good palliative care (and should not be confused with ‘passive euthanasia’).
There have been a number of legal challenges on this topic:
2015. A bill was brought forward that aimed to let terminally ill patients in the last six months of their lives be prescribed medication to administer themselves, which would end their lives. Their mental health would need to have been verified by two Doctors, one of which would be independent. The House of Commons rejected the bill by 330 to 118.
2018. The UK Supreme Court ruled that legal permission is no longer needed to withdraw treatment from patients in a permanent vegetative state. The British Medical Association (BMA) and Royal College of Physicians (RCP) subsequently published guidance for healthcare professionals on when they are allowed to withdraw care.
May 2019. Paul Lamb, who lives with chronic pain following a car crash, renewed a bid for the right to die after losing a Supreme Court case in 2014. Since this time, three other bills were introduced to Parliament with the hope of legalising assisted suicide. All three failed and, importantly, were regarding patients with terminal illness expected to die within six months. Mr Lamb’s case is different from these because he is not terminally ill and could live for many years.
September 2019. 80-year-old Mavis Eccleston was cleared of murder and manslaughter after getting her husband the prescription medication he needed to overdose. Mr Eccleston was a cancer patient, and his wife Mavis was respecting his wishes, according to daughter Joy. Not wanting to live without her husband, Mavis also took an overdose and recovered in hospital after being found unconscious.
November 2019. 49-year-old Paul Newby lost his High Court case that was challenging assisted dying. Mr Newby proposed that Judges should thoroughly examine a large amount of evidence before deciding if assisted dying is incompatible with his human rights.
August 2020. Relatives of people who had previously brought legal cases for assisted dying came together to make a joint inquiry into the current law.
September 2021. Members of the British Medical Association (BMA) voted to adopt a neutral stance on assisted dying, with 49% in favour, 48% opposed and 3% abstaining. Before this, the BMA had opposed assisting dying, so the new stance could potentially pave the way towards a future change in the law.
Obesity + public health
WHAT
* 1 in 4 UK adults is obese
most deaths in the uk are caused by non-communicable diseases. In particular, cardiovascular diseases cause more than a quarter of all deaths in the UK.
- due to lifestyle choices - smoking, alcohol and obesity
two-thirds of adults and 1 in 5 children leaving primary school living with obesity.
Jeremy hunt highlighted diabetes type 2 as a priority as it links to obesity
Through the introduction of the sugar tax in 2018 and the drive to educate children on the dangers of binge drinking,
As of May 2018, the Scottish Government established a Minimum Unit Price (MUP) of 50p per unit of alcohol, and Wales introduced a similar MUP in March 2020. Research shows that these policies have reduced consumption in the heaviest drinking households - no plans for England to do the same, should be a way to reduce?
The government said the income generated from the sugar tax would be invested in school sports and breakfast clubs – but that’s not actually the case because the money hasn’t been ringfenced.
The sugar tax does seem to have been successful in raising awareness of the health impacts of excess sugar intake. Manufacturers have started reformulating carbonated drinks, and most soft drinks now fall below the sugar tax threshold. Over 50% of manufacturers reduced the sugar content of their drinks.
A study of UK households showed that in the year after the sugar tax was introduced, purchasing of soft drinks remained the same, but the amount of sugar in those drinks fell by around 10%.
in 2018/19 that 22.6% of children aged 4 to 5 in England were overweight (an increase of 0.2% from the previous year). This rises to a third of 10 to 11-year olds (consistent with the previous year’s data).
The NHS is extremely concerned by childhood obesity, because of the concern that this is likely to cause major healthcare problems in the future. Key concerns include:
Obese children are more likely to become obese adults.
They have an increased risk of developing Type 2 diabetes – a condition that 745 children and young people under 25 were treated for in England and Wales in 2017/18.
The number of children with Type 2 diabetes has increased by 47% in the last five years.
Local Council Trials - June 2019, it was announced that five local councils would be given £100,000 a year over a three-year period to help test and redefine ideas for addressing childhood obesity and health inequalities.
For example, Bradford would partner with local mosques to help South Asian children (who are at an increased risk of obesity) by giving them places and fun ways to exercise.
June 2019 - chool Sport and Activity Action Plan. - 60m every day, money for pe teachers, for sport during holiday and weekend and 400 new after school areas in disadvantaged areas
Leeds has become the first UK city to see a drop, likely due to many different actions taken by the council as part of a child-obesity strategy made a decade ago. For example, staff who work with pre-school children and healthcare professionals were all trained to encourage healthy eating.
Also, through the charity Henry, parents were offered an eight-week programme involving lessons on healthy food options and cooking healthy meals from scratch. There was also a push to encourage families to reduce their sugar intake and to get children more active through dance.
Public health measures are one of the hot topics that you should know about for your Medical School interview. It could crop up in any number of interview questions, from depth of interest to empathy or ethics!
Public Health Context
In developed countries such as the UK, most deaths are now caused by non-communicable diseases such as ischaemic heart disease. In particular, cardiovascular diseases cause more than a quarter of all deaths in the UK.
There’s growing evidence that lifestyle choices such as smoking, alcohol and obesity increase the risk of acquiring these types of diseases. Increasingly, more money is being spent on the treatment of obesity and diabetes, with around two-thirds of adults and 1 in 5 children leaving primary school living with obesity.
Turn Interviews into Offers
Get the most popular interview prep, trusted by 1000s every year
INTERVIEW TUTORING
INTERVIEW COURSES
Successive governments have pursued health policies with an aim of curbing these costs, with the former Secretary of State for Health, Jeremy Hunt, stating obesity and diabetes (Type 2 diabetes is often linked to obesity) as top priorities. Through the introduction of the sugar tax in 2018 and the drive to educate children on the dangers of binge drinking, the government also seeks to change people’s behaviours and reduce the consumption of unhealthy products.
Whether a government implements a certain health policy depends on the benefits gained by preventing ill health or deaths against the human cost of infringing on personal freedoms.
As of May 2018, the Scottish Government established a Minimum Unit Price (MUP) of 50p per unit of alcohol, and Wales introduced a similar MUP in March 2020. Research shows that these policies have reduced consumption in the heaviest drinking households, so there are calls for England to follow suit although the government has no current plans to do so.
A report published in 2021 named the UK government’s failure to do more to stop Covid-19 spreading early in the pandemic (including decisions on lockdowns and social distancing) as one of the worst ever public health failures.
Public Health Measures: Sugar Tax
The sugar tax is one of the most high-profile recent public health solutions. Here’s what you need to know about the UK Soft Drinks Industry Levy:
It was introduced in April 2018.
Drinks with over 8g of sugar per 100ml have to pay a tax of 24p per litre.
Drinks with 5 to 8g of sugar per 100ml have to pay 18p per litre.
The government said the income generated from the sugar tax would be invested in school sports and breakfast clubs – but that’s not actually the case because the money hasn’t been ringfenced.
It is forecasted to raise £1.37bn over four years from 2020-24.
Has it worked?
The sugar tax does seem to have been successful in raising awareness of the health impacts of excess sugar intake. Manufacturers have started adapting and reformulating carbonated drinks, and most soft drinks now fall below the sugar tax threshold. Between 2016, when the sugar tax plans were announced, and 2018, when the tax came into effect, over 50% of manufacturers reduced the sugar content of their drinks – the equivalent of 45 million kg of sugar every year.
A study of UK households showed that in the year after the sugar tax was introduced, purchasing of soft drinks remained the same, but the amount of sugar in those drinks fell by around 10%.
Combating Childhood Obesity
Data from the National Child Measurement Programme estimated in 2018/19 that 22.6% of children aged 4 to 5 in England were overweight (an increase of 0.2% from the previous year). This rises to a third of 10 to 11-year olds (consistent with the previous year’s data).
Improvements to home entertainment, combined with increased junk food consumption, are some of the primary factors.
The NHS is extremely concerned by childhood obesity, because of the concern that this is likely to cause major healthcare problems in the future. Key concerns include:
Obese children are more likely to become obese adults.
They have an increased risk of developing Type 2 diabetes – a condition that 745 children and young people under 25 were treated for in England and Wales in 2017/18.
The number of children with Type 2 diabetes has increased by 47% in the last five years.
Public Health Measure: Local Council Trials
In 2017, the government published a plan for action on childhood obesity to try and significantly reduce it over the next ten years. As part of this plan, in June 2019, it was announced that five local councils would be given £100,000 a year over a three-year period to help test and redefine ideas for addressing childhood obesity and health inequalities.
The councils being trialled are Bradford, Blackburn with Darwen, Nottinghamshire, Lewisham and Birmingham. They would all try new programmes that may help shape future national policies. For example, Bradford would partner with local mosques to help South Asian children (who are at an increased risk of obesity) by giving them places and fun ways to exercise. Blackburn and Darwen would work with local restaurants to improve menus and include healthier options.
Public Health Measure: More Opportunities to Exercise
In July 2019, the government announced plans to ensure children have more opportunities to do 60 minutes of sport and physical activity every day, under the School Sport and Activity Action Plan. The Department of Education committed £2.5m in 2019/20 for more training for PE teachers and to enable schools to open their facilities during holidays and at weekends. Also, Sport England would give £2m to create 400 new after-school clubs in disadvantaged areas to encourage children to get active.
Public Health Measure: Leeds Example
In spite of a rising trend of childhood obesity nationally, Leeds has become the first UK city to see a drop, likely due to many different actions taken by the council as part of a child-obesity strategy made a decade ago. For example, staff who work with pre-school children and healthcare professionals were all trained to encourage healthy eating.
Also, through the charity Henry, parents were offered an eight-week programme involving lessons on healthy food options and cooking healthy meals from scratch. There was also a push to encourage families to reduce their sugar intake and to get children more active through dance.
Save 20% on Interview Prep
Combine Doctor-delivered strategy with MMI Circuits & more
INTERVIEW & MMI PACKAGES
Public Health Measure: Fat Tax
There’s been discussion around a ‘fat tax’ – but this is much more controversial than the sugar tax because of its connotations of punishment, judgement and blame.
Some support the idea of a fat tax because:
Obesity costs the government more than any other lifestyle factor.
It leads to health problems such as Type 2 diabetes, heart disease and cancer.
The money spent on these conditions could be better spent elsewhere.
It could reduce consumption and encourage people to choose healthier foods.
However, many oppose this because:
Many people are obese because of medical or mental health issues. For example, people experiencing depression have a 58% increased risk of becoming obese. Hormonal issues and some medication can also contribute to obesity.
The most disadvantaged people face the greatest obstacles to overcoming obesity, and inequalities in the numbers of people living with obesity have widened.
It’s hard to eat healthily when you’re stressed.
Price manipulation is seen as a form of control. Not only does it drive people to a certain decision, but it implies that people are not responsible for their actions.
It’s likely to affect those on a low income the most – but the least affluent socio-economic groups in the UK have a higher rate of obesity.
Denying autonomy may be a step backwards for a developed society such as the UK.
Many people would argue that the cost of implementing the tax could be better spent on improving treatments that don’t infringe on society’s freedoms.
Covid
A
I dop believe that the government did the best that they could in such a new situation considering this is the first pandemic in many peoples life times. However, there are still some very valid criticisms that should be considered when discussing how the government handled the covid situation
For example, the first lockdown occurred much later compared to other European countries. Amid calls for tough measures to get the COVID-19 outbreak under control, a senior U.K. government source briefed the media that the Italian government’s lockdown approach was based on “populist, non-science based measures that aren’t any use,” adding: “They’re who not to follow.”.
Even though if a lockdown in Britian had been stated much more earlier there would have been considerably less deaths.
That being said, the government did try to maintain a strong economy during this time despite many people not working. This is definitely something that the government did well. An example of this would be the “eat out to help out” Chancellor Rishi Sunak announced his “Eat Out to Help Out” scheme encouraging Britons to flock to restaurants to help the economy bounce back.
covid lockdown delayed - wanted to achieve herd immunity by infection, bcc news report - worst public health failures.
Nurses strikes
What is the nurses’ dispute about?
Pay. The RCN is calling for a rise of 5% above the RPI inflation rate - currently above 14%. No UK nation has offered a pay rise close to that.
NHS staff in England and Wales - including nurses - have been given an average increase of 4.75%. The lowest paid were guaranteed a rise of at least £1,400.
In Northern Ireland, nurses are yet to receive a pay award because there is no working government.
In Scotland, NHS staff were initially offered 5%, but that has been changed to a flat rate of just over £2,200. That is just over 8% for a newly qualified nurse. Fresh talks mean there will be no strike action for the time being.
The young NHS workers who are voting yes
Which workers are allowed to go on strike?
Why are so many workers going on strike?
The RCN says this year’s below-inflation pay award followed years of squeezes on nurses’ salaries. It says average pay for nurses fell by 6% between 2011 and 2021 - once inflation is taken into account - compared with a 4.6% drop across the whole UK workforce.
The RCN says this is compromising care, because it means the NHS is struggling to attract and retain nurses.
But the government in England pointed out this year’s award is in line with what the independent NHS Pay Review Body recommended. NHS staff were also awarded a 3% rise last year in recognition of their work during the pandemic, while the rest of the public sector had a pay freeze.
How much are nurses paid?
The starting salary for a nurse is England is just over £27,000 a year. This is the bottom of pay band five of the NHS contract, known as Agenda for Change.
Staff such as healthcare assistants, porters and cleaners are on lower pay bands.
Under the contract, staff are entitled to in-the-job salary increases within their pay band.
Under trade union laws life-preserving care has to be provided.
Therefore, all nursing staff would be expected to work in services such as intensive and emergency care.
Other services, such as cancer treatment or urgent testing, may be partially staffed.
Details will be negotiated by local service managers and union representatives.
It is also possible that nurses could be pulled off picket lines to work if there are safety concerns during a strike.
This happened during the 2019 walkout in Northern Ireland by RCN members - the only other time the union has been involved in strike action.
Routine services - including planned operations such as knee and hip replacements, community nursing services and health visiting - are expected to be badly affected.
State of NHS
Ambulances
The main measure of performance for ambulances is their response time from the point when someone has dialled the emergency services. The request for an ambulance is then sorted into one of four categories - Category 1: An immediate response to a life-threatening condition, such as cardiac or respiratory arrest. The average response time should be under 7 minutes and 90% of ambulances should arrive within 15 minutes.
Category 2: A serious condition, such as stroke or chest pain, which may require rapid assessment and/or urgent transport. The average response time should be under 18 minutes and 90% of ambulances should arrive within 40 minutes.
Category 3: An urgent problem, such as an uncomplicated diabetic issue, which requires treatment and transport to an acute setting. 90% of ambulances should arrive within 2 hours.
Category 4: A non-urgent problem, such as stable clinical cases, which requires transportation to a hospital ward or clinic. 90% of ambulances should arrive within 3 hours.
As of April/May 2022, while Category 1 calls see an average response time of 8:36 minutes (only 1:36 mins above the target average wait), Category 2 calls see an average wait of 40 minutes. This is far above the target average of 18 minutes. The same issue exists with Category 3 calls, with the average response time of an ambulance attending a Category 3 call being 2 hours 9 minutes. The target states that 90% of ambulances should have arrived within 2 hours.
Naturally, this has an impact on patient safety. It is also worth keeping in mind that even though responses to Category 1 calls were only 1:36 mins above the target, these are the most serious calls that the NHS receives, i.e. calls where minutes and seconds will really count. London saying of stoke, 70 min
Why ambulance response targets have been missed:
The ambulance service is seeing unprecedented levels of demand post-Covid. There were 860,000 calls to 999 made in England in April 2022, up 20% on the previous April.
Post-2010 cuts to community services have resulted in greater pressures on the emergency services, as people previously treated in the community are entering the health system later and therefore with more acute issues.
Shortage of paramedics. The GMB union has found that 1,000 ambulance workers have left the service since 2018 to seek a ‘better work-life balance’.
A&E waiting times. Emergency departments have become overcrowded, and this slows down ambulance crews. Ambulances are having to wait with patients until space in the emergency department becomes available. This slows their ability to respond to other call requests.
As a means of addressing this, the government has allocated £150 million to specifically address ambulance waiting times and has given NHS workers a 3% pay rise in order to incentivise retention. For context, the £150 million figure represents 0.1% of the overall NHS budget of around £150 billion.
is the A&E in crisis?
WHAT
* UK has only about 2.6 beds per 1000 capita, while Japan has over 13 per 1000
* Ageing and growing population means that beds can become overfilled and a backlog of filled beds can cause problems over the winter
* Non-urgent surgeries have to be postponed
PREVENTION
* Increasing funding and resources for the NHS
* Improving productivity -> Reducing unnecessary scans, marginally-helpful drugs, etc.
* Tackling general health -> Reducing obesity, etc.
GP Services
Practices are closing. In 2019, 99 GP practices were closed, affecting 350,000 people. In the past five years, 1.3 million patients have had to change their GP because of practice closures. The situation is set to worsen, as research suggests that 40% of GPs are planning on leaving the profession by 2023. Not only will appointments become harder to secure, but some people will simply be unable to reach GP surgeries.
Unsafe patient levels. A recent survey found one in ten GPs are seeing over 60 patients a day, double the number which is considered safe. Also, some GPs work an average 11-hour day, with patient consultations taking up eight hours of that time.
Long waits for appointments. In 2018, NHS figures revealed one in three patients had to wait over a week for a GP appointment, with 31.7% of people in 2019 finding it increasingly difficult to get through on the phone to their GP. See the latest results from the GP Patient Survey for more statistics.
Unnecessary appointments waste time. The average member of the public sees a GP six times per year. Some of these appointments are for things which don’t require a GP and could be dealt with by other healthcare professionals and services.
Public satisfaction is low. A 2019 study revealed that public satisfaction with general practice is lower now than it has ever been before. Check out the British Social Attitudes survey for more detail.
GP shortages. A 2018 survey found that 15.3% of GP posts were vacant.
Increasing demand. As life expectancies rise and the population ages, demand on GPs is increasing. According to the Nuffield Trust, the UK needs 3,4000 new GPs to keep up with population growth.
Recruitment issues. In 2015, the government pledged to hire 5,000 new GPs by 2020 – however the former Health Secretary, Matt Hancock, revealed in 2019 that this target would not be met. Despite this, in 2019, a total of 3,538 GP training places were accepted (the highest in the history of the NHS).
Medical Schools are trying to correct misconceptions about general practice and encouraging more students to think about the role.
The NHS has a £10m scheme to incentivise Foundation Year doctors to become GPs.
As of 2017, there is a scheme in which newly qualified GPs can receive a ‘golden hello’ one-off payment of £20,000 if they start their careers in certain areas that need more GPs (in particular rural and coastal areas). Since the introduction of this, the number of trainee GPs taking up posts in these hard-to-recruit areas has doubled.
International recruitment is a short-term solution. However, the NHS in England failed to reach their target of recruiting 2,000 overseas doctors by 2020 – the international GP recruitment programme had brought in just a fraction of this number (around 150).
A new five-year contract for general practice was announced by NHS England, which included an extra £4.5 billion investment by 2023/4. More solutions include:
Funding for 20,000 more staff including pharmacists, physiotherapists and paramedics to help GP practices work together as a local ‘primary care network’.
Digital solutions supporting capacity, access and appointment-retention in general practice (e.g. telephone triage models, video consultations and e-consultations).
Organ donation
People can donate certain organs while they are alive, such as a kidney, but most organ donations come from people who have died.
Challenges With Organ Donation
The demand for organs is significantly larger than the supply, which means there is a waiting list for organ transplants. There are currently around 7,000 people on the UK Transplant Waiting List. In 2020/21, over 470 patients died before they could receive a transplant.
Only a small proportion of deaths (e.g. death from stroke or brain injury) allow for organ donation, because many types of death (e.g. circulatory death in which the organs are starved of blood) do not leave viable organs for use. With improved road safety and vehicle manufacturing, fewer deaths are resulting from brain death nowadays, meaning there is a growing shortage of organs for donation. Demand also exceeds supply because matches need to be as close as possible to ensure a successful transplant.
An additional challenge is that the BAME community typically experience longer waiting times for organ transplant, because there is a lack of suitable organs from BAME donors. In 2020, when approached about organ donation in hospital, 39.5% of BAME families agreed to support donation going ahead, compared to 69% of white families. Many of the BAME families had not discussed organ donation with their relatives and/or had concerns about whether organ donation aligned with their religious beliefs.
Opt-in System
With an opt-in system, Doctors can only use a person’s organs after death if that person signed up to an organ donation register during their life.
One of the biggest problems with an opt-in system is that many potential donors either don’t register or are unaware that they have the option to register. When England had an opt-in system (pre-2020), research showed that 80% of people supported organ donation in principle but only 38% had opted in, so the support didn’t translate into a high number of potential donors.
Those in favour of an opt-in system argue that this type of consent (informed consent) is the most valid and ethical, because people have explicitly agreed to donating their organs and nothing is being assumed.
Opt-out System
With an opt-out system, if a person has not registered a decision to either become an organ donor (opted in) or not become an organ donor (opted out), they are considered to have no objection to being an organ donor after death. This is known as deemed/presumed consent.
In recent years, an opt-out system has been adopted by England, Wales and Scotland. The aim is to increase the number of people on the NHS Organ Donor Register, because it is expected that only people with strong views against organ donation will opt out. There are hopes that the opt-out system will lead to more lives being saved every year.
Those who oppose an opt-out system argue that deemed/presumed consent is less valid, because people could be unaware that they are automatically signed up to donate their organs.
Organ Donation in the UK
In December 2015, Wales became the first UK nation to move to a soft opt-out system of consent for organ donation. The system is ‘soft’ because the families of potential donors have the right to a final say.
Figures from NHS Blood and Transplant show that Wales now has the highest consent rate of all UK nations – 77% compared to 58% in 2015 when the new system was launched.
In spring 2020, England also adopted a soft opt-out system, in which people over the age of 18 are automatically added to the Organ Donor Register and must actively withdraw if they want to opt out of it. Families are still consulted before any organ donation goes ahead.
In spring 2021, Scotland also introduced a similar opt-out system. Northern Ireland currently has an opt-in system, but steps have been made towards changing to an opt-out system.
Arguments exist for both opt-in and opt-out systems. Get to know the ins and outs of the two different systems in preparation for your interview.
Abortion
WHAT
* 1 in 3 women will have an abortion
* Legal until 24th week of pregnancy, unless the mother’s life is at risk
* Issues about whether women should be allowed to take the abortion pill at home
Ageing population
WHAT
* 18% of the population are over 60
* 15 million people have a chronic disease
SOLUTION
* Social and residential care alongside primary and secondary care
* Preventative medicine
* Public health campaigns
Vaccinations
- how do they work
- herd immunity and mass protection - prevent 2/3 million deaths a year
Uptake of all 13 vaccines fell between 2018 and 2019.
Some conditions (e.g. mumps and rubella) require children to be given multiple vaccine doses over time.
Vaccines are also offered in schools. The HPV vaccine is offered to 12 and 13-year-olds to protect against some cancers that are commonly caused by high-risk types of HPV, such as cervical cancer.
Most vaccines provide long-term immunity. However, the flu vaccine only provides immunity for a short amount of time as the virus mutates each year. This means the strains in last year’s vaccines may not circulate in next year’s vaccines.
Those 65 and older can receive flu vaccines on the NHS, whilst primary school children can receive the vaccine in the form of a nasal spray.
COVID VACCINE:
4 million by end of December but only 768000
Anti-vaccination groups claim that vaccines are unnatural and toxic, with an emphasis on the alleged risks of vaccines. It’s an issue that dates back to the 1880s when ‘anti-vaxxers’ protested in Leicester about the smallpox vaccine.
Anti-vaccination social media pages had an increase of 7.7 million followers from the UK and US during the COVID-19 pandemic. An investigation revealed that hundreds of NHS staff were members of an anti-vaxxer Facebook group that compared the COVID-19 vaccination to poison and are opposed to wearing masks.
It’s become such a big issue that Labour proposed a new law to tackle the spread of fake anti-vaccination news during the pandemic - asked social media firms to remove fake new about vaccines.
in August 2019 the UK lost its measle-free status.
Why are vaccinations failing:
- 2/5 parents exposed to false news
- epidemics such s measles snd maps, were so long ago many don’t consider it a serious issue anymore
- availability of appointments
How Does The NHS Plan to Tackle This?
The NHS Long Term Plan includes various measures that will be used to increase the uptake of both MMR doses. This includes improving local coordination and support to improve immunisation conversation in low uptake areas. They’re also adding an MMR check for children aged 10 and 11 with GPs, and trying to ‘catch up’ young adults who missed the MMR vaccinations as children.
AI in medicine
- AI is the ability of a machine to make decisions on its own
HOW IT IS BEING USED - Diagnosis -> From scans, etc.
- Virtual nursing -> Such as wearable tech to remind people to take medication
- Robotic surgery -> Routine procedures -> Shown to reduce complications by up to 5 times
POTENTIAL USES - Predicting which individuals or groups of individuals are most at risk of illness, so treatment can be targeted
- Processing long-term changes in conditions, which could be missed by a human
Francis Report
Robert Francis QC is a Barrister specialising in medical law, including clinical negligence claims. With this expertise, he led a public inquiry into the poor care at Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust between 2005 and 2009.
The investigation looked into why organisations responsible for regulating and managing the trust did not spot problems before they were brought to light by the campaign group ‘Cure the NHS’.
Recurring problems emerged, such as:
Call bells going unanswered
Patients left lying in their own urine or excrement
Food and drink left out of reach of patients
Patient falls being concealed from relatives
Too few consultants and nurses
Poor communication between staff and relatives of the patients
What Recommendations Were Made?
The report made over 200 recommendations in relation to:
Staffing levels and skill mix
Protection of whistleblowers
Eradication of the blame culture and bullying
Training and regulation of healthcare assistants
Recruitment, training and standards of registered nurses.
Response To The Report
GMC. The GMC responded to their progress following these recommendations in October 2013 – this included an insight into education, safety in the practice environment and information sharing.
Government. At the end of 2013, the government also responded to the recommendations of the report. It included actions for improving patient care: increasing openness and changes to regulation in hospitals.
NICE. NICE was also asked by the Department of Health and NHS England to create guidelines on staffing capacity to ensure safety in the NHS.
Bawa-Garba
WHAT
* In 2011, a 6-year old boy was admitted to Leicester Royal Infirmary
* Bawa-Garba was a paediatrics registrar who had just returned from maternity leave
* She made a number of mistakes in communication and treatment -> She did not explicitly ask the consultant to review the patient and did not clearly state that the patient should not be given certain medicine
* When the patient went into cardiac arrest from sepsis, she confused him with another patient who had a Do Not Resuscitate Order and caused his CPR to be stopped for 2 minutes. The boy died.
* Bawa-Garba (and a nurse) were found guilty of manslaughter and given a suspended sentence of 2 years. She was briefly struck off the medical register, which was then overturned, so she only had the 12 month suspension.
MISTAKES
* Chest x-ray that showed an infection was seen 2 and a half hours after it was available. This meant antibiotics were prescribed late. This was because Bawa-Garba was busy.
* Computer system failings meant that blood test results were delivered 5 hours late.
* Mother of patient was not clearly informed that a certain medication had to be stopped, so she administered it.
* Bawa-Garba stopped resuscitation of the boy, confusing him with another with a do not resuscitate order.
LESSONS
* Improving reflective practice
* Looking in computer and technology failures
* Questions about stress and workload of doctors
* Better registration of safety concerns
* Some calls from doctors to just lie about when you’ve made a mistake and never admit it’s your fault -> Reinforcing blame culture
Shropshire maternity scandal
In November 2019, a report from an interim inquiry into failings at the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Royal Hospital in Telford was leaked to the press.
The inquiry was investigating the deaths and injuries of babies at the two hospitals dating from 1979 to present, with the majority of cases having occurred since the year 2000.
Midwife Donna Ockendon led the review, with more than 1,800 cases examined after families were invited to contact the inquiry. The review was expanded from an initial 23 families, and the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Telford Hospitals were placed into special measures.
The Shropshire Maternity Scandal came to light with the Stanton-Davies family’s fight to ensure that lessons were learnt after their baby daughter’s death in 2009.
The pregnancy was meant to be flagged as high-risk and the mother, Rhiannon, should have never been on the unit in the first place. Compounding this, midwives failed to monitor their daughter Kate’s condition.
The family first secured an inquest into Kate’s death, and once this had been ruled avoidable, they challenged the NHS on how they investigated it. The resulting review found systemic failings of the former head of midwifery and midwives who altered notes retrospectively.
The Stanton-Davies family then worked with a second family and wrote to the Health Secretary at the time, Jeremy Hunt, who ordered an independent investigation.
Findings Of The Report
The scandal has been described as the biggest maternity scandal in the history of the NHS, with clinical malpractice continuing unchecked for over 40 years according to the leaked internal report.
An interim report examining 250 cases found that at least 42 babies and three mothers may have died avoidably. It also found that more than 50 newborns may have sustained avoidable brain damage.
The review examined over 1,800 cases. Not all cases involved death or serious harm, but many involved significant errors.
The report revealed that concerns over injuries to babies were highlighted in 2017 to regulators. The findings of this review by Donna Ockendon were published in December 2020.
Repeated clinical errors were inadequately followed up, which meant important lessons were not learnt.
Bereaved families weren’t treated with kindness or respect, with instances of staff referring to babies as ‘it’ and one baby’s body left to decompose for weeks after a post-mortem.
You need to know some examples of hot topics that you can apply to ethics questions for your Medical School interview. In this guide, you’ll learn everything you need to know about the Shropshire Maternity Scandal – including some example interview questions you could be asked.
What Is The Shropshire Maternity Scandal?
In November 2019, a report from an interim inquiry into failings at the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Royal Hospital in Telford was leaked to the press.
The inquiry was investigating the deaths and injuries of babies at the two hospitals dating from 1979 to present, with the majority of cases having occurred since the year 2000.
Midwife Donna Ockendon led the review, with more than 1,800 cases examined after families were invited to contact the inquiry. The review was expanded from an initial 23 families, and the Royal Shrewsbury and Princess Telford Hospitals were placed into special measures.
Turn Interviews into Offers
Get the most popular interview prep, trusted by 1000s every year
MMI CIRCUITS
INTERVIEW COURSES
Key Patient: Stanton-Davies Family
The Shropshire Maternity Scandal came to light with the Stanton-Davies family’s fight to ensure that lessons were learnt after their baby daughter’s death in 2009.
The pregnancy was meant to be flagged as high-risk and the mother, Rhiannon, should have never been on the unit in the first place. Compounding this, midwives failed to monitor their daughter Kate’s condition.
The family first secured an inquest into Kate’s death, and once this had been ruled avoidable, they challenged the NHS on how they investigated it. The resulting review found systemic failings of the former head of midwifery and midwives who altered notes retrospectively.
The Stanton-Davies family then worked with a second family and wrote to the Health Secretary at the time, Jeremy Hunt, who ordered an independent investigation.
Findings Of The Report
The scandal has been described as the biggest maternity scandal in the history of the NHS, with clinical malpractice continuing unchecked for over 40 years according to the leaked internal report.
An interim report examining 250 cases found that at least 42 babies and three mothers may have died avoidably. It also found that more than 50 newborns may have sustained avoidable brain damage.
The review examined over 1,800 cases. Not all cases involved death or serious harm, but many involved significant errors.
The report revealed that concerns over injuries to babies were highlighted in 2017 to regulators. The findings of this review by Donna Ockendon were published in December 2020.
Malpractice Noted
Repeated clinical errors were inadequately followed up, which meant important lessons were not learnt.
Bereaved families weren’t treated with kindness or respect, with instances of staff referring to babies as ‘it’ and one baby’s body left to decompose for weeks after a post-mortem.
Save 20% on Interview Prep
Combine Doctor-delivered strategy with MMI Circuits & more
INTERVIEW & MMI PACKAGES
The Report’s Impact
The Trust was ordered to repay £1 million that was given by NHS Resolution for good maternity care. Two months after the payment in September 2018, maternity services were rated inadequate by the Care Quality Commission (CQC) and were placed in special measures. Weekly status reports were required from the hospital bosses due to the concerns.
In June 2020, West Mercia Police began a criminal investigation into the deaths of babies at Shrewsbury and Telford Trust, to see whether there was evidence to support a criminal case against either the Trust or individuals involved. The case is ongoing.
In August 2020, it emerged that new areas of concern had been identified at the Royal Shrewsbury and Telford’s Princess Royal Hospitals. The CQC Chief Inspector of Hospitals, Ted Baker, has said that failing leadership is perpetuating poor care. The trust was rated inadequate on every measure.
Antibiotic resistance
PREVENTION
* Funding development of new drugs
* Education -> World Antibiotic Awareness Week
* WHO -> Global action plan on antibiotic resistance
* Preventing infections
* Only using antibiotics when necessary
* Alternating therapy
* Targeting quorum sensing
BAME and the NHS
Some of the inequalities faced by BAME staff include:
Unequal representation amongst board members. 19.7% of the NHS workforce is made up of BAME groups, but just 8.4% of board members are from a BAME background.
Recruitment problems. Lack of diverse representation at a senior level produces barriers for BAME staff, particularly during the recruitment process. White applicants are 1.46 times likelier to be appointed from shortlisting as opposed to BAME applicants.
Less likely to be supported. BAME staff are 1.22 likelier than their white colleagues to enter a formal disciplinary process. The GMC’s Fair to Refer report found Doctors from diverse groups did not always receive effective, timely or honest feedback due to difficult conversations being avoided where the manager is from a different ethnic group to the Doctor. There is also a culture of blame amongst some organisations, which creates additional risk for Doctors who are seen as ‘outsiders’.
Likelier discrimination. 15% of BAME staff reported experiences of discrimination from 2019 to 2020, compared to 6.6% of white staff.
What Is The NHS Doing To Address This?
The NHS People Plan has action points to increase BAME representation across the workforce, including at senior level – this should make the NHS more reflective of the patient population that it serves. Structural racism and unconscious biases still need to be addressed in order for equality to be truly achieved.
The NHS is striving to engage further with staff and staff networks so that BAME staff can be heard and share their lived experience, and offer action points they feel need to be taken. Steps towards establishing a stronger network have been introduced in the form of webinars, the first of which was attended by more than 240 heads of BAME staff networks.
HIV + PrEP
WHAT
* Pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP)
* Use of antiviral drugs as a preventative measure for patients at high risk of HIV
* Pill taken every day
* 90% protection during sex, 70% for drug users
ISSUES
* Who gets the drugs? -> Certain groups of people get priority with these drugs, which may seem unfair
* Might approve high-risk behaviour
* Doesn’t protect against other STIs
Junior doctor contract
WHAT
* Department of Health started re-writing contracts for junior doctors starting in 2016
* These contracts have an impact on pay and were designed to work along the 7-day NHS proposals
* The government wanted to increase the number of ‘standard hours’ from Monday to Saturday and generally reduce the bonus payed to doctors for working unsociable hours
* BMA disliked the suggestions as it implied that Saturdays were normal working days and it would cause more hours to be worked, leading to tired doctors
* 98% of junior doctors voted in favour of strikes
* Eventually a compromise was reached -> Basic pay increased by 10-11% (although it was meant to go up by 13%), while the night shift pay bonus was reduced from 50% extra to 37% extra. Also, while Saturdays and Sundays are now considered normal working hours, they would get up to 10% extra a year for working at least 7 weekends.
* There was also extra support for doctors who take time off (e.g. doctors on maternity leave)
SEE: Doctor strikes
Cannabis
From November 2018 specialist Doctors in England, Wales and Scotland can prescribe cannabis-derived medicine in exceptional circumstances.
this means they have a potential medical use and can now be legally prescribed in cases of children with rare, severe epilepsy, adults with vomiting/nausea from chemotherapy, and adults with muscle stiffness caused by MS – if other treatments have failed.
specialist physicians only
England’s Chief Medical Officer has called for scientific trials to check its safety, which may take years.
In 2019, the NHS provided only 18 prescriptions for cannabis-related medications.
Many campaigners who fought to get cannabis oil available for those with serious medical conditions feel let down. A report has concluded that families’ hopes were unfairly raised when the law changed last year, and products remain unlicensed due to lack of research.
eg) Medicinal cannabis hit the headlines back in 2018 when a child suffering from autism and severe epilepsy had his medication confiscated at Heathrow airport. The coverage of this case caused a public outcry and started a campaign to change the law.
Billy Caldwell had previously been treated for his seizures by a specialist in Chicago, and his antiepileptic medication intake was reduced from six medications to one. The treatment was very successful and saw the remission of his seizures for eight years.
In 2016 the seizures returned, becoming more frequent and severe.
In 2017 Billy was prescribed cannabis oil by his GP. This was the first prescription of cannabis oil in the UK – but the GP received a letter from the Home Office saying he must not renew the prescription or would face serious consequences. That’s because the oil contains low amounts of THC, which is illegal in the UK.
His mother travelled to Toronto to pick up medicinal cannabis and this was confiscated.
Billy wasn’t weaned off the medication, and he suffered seizures. He was admitted to hospital, where Doctors struggled to keep the seizures under control.
There was a huge public outcry and, due to mounting pressure, the Home Office decided that Billy would be allowed the cannabis oil as a special measure.
A hospital trust was given a special license to administer doses to Billy, which meant a daily four-hour round-trip for the family. His mother described it as being under hospital arrest.
Billy was later getting a prescription from a private paediatric neurologist in London, but this meant flying to England every few weeks to collect more oil.
In 2019, Billy was ultimately awarded a lifelong medicinal cannabis prescription on the NHS, in a decision that could pave the way for more patients to receive the treatment in the future.
5 medical schools
- The NHS has a shortage of Doctors in many different specialities – especially psychiatry, general practice, emergency medicine and paediatrics.
- GMC announced in 2016 that it was going to open new Medical Schools, with an aim to boost the number of Doctors and reduce the reliance on international graduates.
-1500 additional Medical School places – a 25% increase. - expansion of existing Medical Schools participated
- Research shows that Doctors tend to stay and work in the area where they trained, so the new Medical Schools are in regions where Trusts usually struggle to recruit. - Sunderland , anglia ruskin, Kent and medway, Lincoln, edge hill
The new Medical Schools will encourage Doctors to train and then work in areas which have particular medical staff shortages and difficult-to-fill vacancies. It is hoped that the UK will ultimately have enough medical graduates to support the NHS in a sustainable manner and to strengthen the workforce. This will help to address current staffing challenges, as well as the growing issue of an ageing population.
the BMA has pointed out that it will be several years before the benefits of the new Medical Schools will be felt in the NHS workforce. It takes at least 10 years to train to be a fully qualified GP from entering Medical School, but we need thousands more GPs now. We must work together, pulling out all the stops, to recruit more people to general practice, to make it easier for people to return to the profession after a career break or period working abroad, and to retain the experienced, skilled workforce we already have.”