Harshness of Versailles Flashcards
How many people died and were wounded in WW1?
8.5 million dead and 21 million wounded.
What does Newton say about Versailles?
“too severe on Germany.”
What does the idea of a ‘Carthaginian’ peace mean?
A “Carthaginian peace” is the imposition of a very brutal “peace” achieved by completely crushing the enemy. Keynes argued that the Treaty was a “Carthaginian Peace,” likening it to the utter destruction visited on Carthage by the Romans after their victory.
Who said the “treaty wasn’t excessively harsh”
Henig
What did Britain (Llyod George), France (Clemenceau) and the USA (Woodrow Wilson) want out of the treaty of Versailles?
Britain- A fair settlement
France- Revenge
USA- looking to pacify- horrified at brutally of war.
WW1 ended leaving a trail of ……… homes and factories were totally collapsed.
Trail of staggering damage
What did Germany reject before the treaty of Versailles was drawn up and signed?
Wilsons 14 points
How many days did Germany get to comment on the terms of Versailles?
21 days.
How many voted for and against Versailles in the Reichstag?
237 voted for Versailles and 138 against Versailles.
The allies threatened armed persuasion, by invading Germany if it wasn’t signed in how long?
24hrs.
How many amendments were made to the treaty of Versailles by the German government?
2 minor amendments
Normally a criminal in court of law is present and can defend their case- why was this not the cause in Versailles agreements for Germany?
They weren’t allowed to be present.
The treaty was decided by the “big three” and Italy was also linked into the decision? Why was this odd and why did the allies allow Italy?
Italy was part of the triple alliance at the start of the war. They could put pressure on the allies from the south.
What does Stephen Lee say about Versailles process of signing it?
“Germany came to see itself as a victim without actually being destroyed.”
Who said an “unrealistic mood of illusion and aggrivated sense of honour” around the signing of Versailles?
Feuchtwanger
What does Keynes say about the politics of Versailles?
“Political unwisdom”
How was loosing 25% percent of land lost to Germany from soviet Russia not a big loss?
Brest-Litovsk may have included a large territorial loss for Russia, but not necessarily for Soviet Russia. Back in 1917, the Soviets only controlled Moscow and the larger area surrounding Moscow. The areas conceded to Germany were not controlled by the Red Army yet. So basically Trotsky went for a gamble: signing the treaty, consolidating the Soviet power in Moscow, and speculating on a future German defeat, leave the German-occupied areas open subjects at the Paris conference
Despite the anger the treaty of Versailles was not as harsh as the French envisioned it- why was not as harsh?
It was a compromise
From the perspective of the allies, the treaty did not appear harsh- why?
Treaty of Brest-Litovsk which Russia signed after surrendering to the Germans, Russia suffered greater losses. For instance, Russia lost 25% of its territories in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk while Germany lost only 13% in the Treaty of Versailles. Russia also lost 80% of its coal mines in the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk while Germany only lost 16% in the Treaty of Versailles.
Alsace- Lorraine was returned to who?
France and areas contained both French and German speaking people
What percentage of upper Silesia population voted to remain part of Germany?
60%
What percentage of Germanys 1914 territory was lost?
13%
Some of the land Germany returned to Russia was made into new states what were they called?
Estonia, Lithuania and Latvia
Germany was forbidden from Auschless with what country?
Austria
How many people did Germany loose from their control?
7 million
How many square miles of German territory was lost?
25,000 square miles