GOVP2 - Legislature Flashcards
Benefits of bicameralism
Check on first chamber, more scrutiny, more representation/expertise with Lords
Issues with bicameralism
Delaying legislation, full role can be done by Commons, causes conflict and too conservative
Example of Select Committee power
2018 Amber Rudd forced to change policy on immigration targets due to Home Affairs Select Committee questioning - Windrush Scandal
When were life peerages brought about?
1958 Life Peerages Act
Use of 1949 Parliament Act
Blair passing Hunting Act 2004 when blocked in Lords
1997 Labour Manifesto on Lords
End ‘the right of hereditary peers to sit and vote in the House of Lords’
When was the Lords changed by New Labour?
1999 House of Lords Act
4 roles of Lords
Consideration/revision of bills, initiation of non-controversial legislation, power of delay, general debating
Who are non-controversial bills begun in the Lords?
25% of laws are to even out the workload on either House, and also where peers want to air their opinions on social reform
Example of key Lords committee
Select Committee on EU, with around 70 peers working to scrutinise EU legislation
Benefit of Lords to revise bills
Have time and expertise to clarify bills which have come straight out of the Commons
Why does the type of peers in the Lords make it in need of reform?
Hereditary peers do not turn up to debate, and are not democratic, and life peers are political tools with no independence (Blair’s use against Tory cronies)
Why does the make-up of the Lords make it in need of reform?
26 Bishops of Church of England, no other religions, and also 26% women and few minorities particularly with hereditary peers
How has the House of Lords become more active in recent years?
Diversity with a large number of specialists who can debate government on issues, and New Labour revision reaction turned to Brexit fight
Unitary reason for not reforming Lords
No need to have an outlet for federal regions rights
Political reasoning for not reforming Lords
Many from all parties dislike the idea, too controversial for too few votes
Which areas to Private Members Bills focus on?
Moral issues outside party interests such as abortion
Difference between green and white papers
Green made for Commons discussion, white for ministers to outline bill before publishing
Number of departmental select committees
19
2005-06 number of Private Members Bills passed in each chamber
3 in Commons, 13 in Lords
2 examples of important scrutiny
Westland Affair of 1986 (where Trade and Industry Secretary Brittan resigns after lack of candour with Parliament in debate) and high level of debate without party guidelines on Iraq
Role of Parliament for executive
Future government, recruiting
Work MP’s most proud for in 2001 (Guardian using 200 MPs)
43 - Introducing own legislation, 27 - Constituency investment, 25 - Select Committee Service
MP’s 4 obligations
Party, constituency, nation, conscience/special interests
Main role of MP’s to constituents
Solving welfare problems