GIS29 Geography, Migration, Development And Disease Burden Flashcards
Disease burden
**Assessing health impact of a disease **quantitatively at ***population level
Potential uses:
- compare ***disease burden over time / between places / and person
- compare ***health losses due to different risk factors / disease states
- identify ***priority actions
- estimate Clinical / ***cost-effectiveness of interventions
- guide ***policies and strategies adoption and implementation
Measuring health events
- Fatal events
- mortality - Non-fatal events
- hospital care
- primary care - Summary measure of both
- Quality-adjusted life years (QALYs)
- Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs)
Measuring mortality
- Mortality rate
- Number of deaths in a population, scaled to the size of that population, ***per unit of time
- e.g. deaths per 1000 individuals per year - Crude death rate
- Total number of deaths per year per 1000 population at risk of dying in the middle of the year
- Without considering cause of death
- Overall impression in a single figure
Specific / stratified mortality rates
- Sub-population specific rates
- Age-specific
- Sex-specific
- rate of death occurring **in a subgroup of the population
- used when crude rate inadequate to describe **conditions having different load in population subgroups - Cause/ disease-specific
- death rate for a ***specific cause of death
Standardised rates
- Age / sex standardised rate
- Take account of the **different age / sex structures of 2 populations
—> eliminate effect of the characteristic being standardised
—> factors being standardised can no longer be used to explain variations
- Allow for **direct comparison of mortality experience across different geographical areas / over time - Direct standardisation
- a common age-structured population —> observe the rate - Indirect standardisation
- a common set of age-specific rates —> observe the population
Measures of morbidity
- Health care utilisation data
- hospital-based data
- primary care data - Surveillance data
- ILI-surveillance systems - Registration of disease
- Cancer registry - Population-based health information
- General household survey / local health surveys
Problems of traditional assessments of the number of disease burden
Measured either
- the number of deaths
- the amount of suffering (impaired QOL) due to disease incidence
- but NOT both
Make it difficult to compare:
- losses that **occur at different ages
- conditions having **differential impact on length / QOL
—> some conditions do not markedly shorten life but reduce QOL
—> some conditions do shorten life but also reduce QOL
Examples of inadequacy of traditional health indicators
- death at age 20 years vs death at age 70 years
- 200 acute respiratory infections vs 400 cases of infectious diarrhoea
- cancer treatment resulting in an average survival of 10 years compared to untreated average survival of 2 years = gain of 8 whole years of life per person treated?
Other health indicators
- Focusing on either mortality / morbidity
—> Life expectancy - Combining data on mortality and non-fatal outcomes into a single number
—> Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs)
—> Quality-adjusted life year (QALY)
—> Disability-adjusted life expectancy (DALE)
—> Healthy life year (HeaLY)
Life expectancy
Life expectancy:
- Average no. of years an individual of a given age is expected to live if current mortality rates continue to apply
—> a statistical abstraction based on existing age-specific death rates (assuming mortality at each age remains constant in the future)
—> a hypothetical measure and indicator of current health and mortality condition
Life expectancy at birth:
- average no. of years a newborn baby can be expected to live
- average no. of years to be lived by a group of people born in the same year
- a measure of overall QOL in a country and summarises mortality at all ages
Life expectancy at a given age:
- average no. of ADDITIONAL years a person of age X will live, based on the age-specific death rates for a given year if current mortality trends continue to apply
Relationship between life expectancy and GDP
↑ GDP —> ↑ life expectancy
***Quality-adjusted life year (QALY)
Adjust life years for QOL
—> a single measurement of changes in QOL relative to a state of perfect wellbeing (valued as unity)
***QALY = Life years x Quality of life weight(0-1)
QOL: pain / mood / self-care ability / social activities / household activities / paid employment
Uses:
- comparison of clinical and cost-effectiveness of different interventions (pharmaceuticals, procedures, programmes)
- adopted by NICE in UK
Problems:
- theoretical and practical difficulties of deriving valid indices of QOL
- reservation regarding the fairness and appropriateness for using as a basis for assessing / determining health needs
***Disability-adjusted life years (DALYs)
- summary measure of population health by combining mortality and disability
- combines in one measure:
—> Time lost due to premature mortality + Time lost due to disability
—> “Time” (years) lost as the unit of measurement
—> measures Health Gap: relative to an “ideal” life expectancy (80 years for men and 82.5 years for women)
***DALY = YLL + YLD
YLL: years of life lost due to premature mortality
YLD: years of life lost due to disability
***YLL: years of life lost due to premature mortality
YLL, for a given cause, age, sex:
***YLL = N x L
N: no. of deaths
L: standard life expectancy at age of death (in years)
***YLD: years of life lost due to disability
***YLD = I x L x DW
YLD: years lived with disability
I: no. of incident disability cases
DW: disability weight (reflect severity of disease on a scale 0 (perfect health) to 1 (dead))
L: average duration of disability (years)
Age weights
- Social preference of value of year lived by a young adult
—> a year of life in young adulthood worth more than a year lived by young child / old aged
Time discounting
People’s preference on a healthy year of life immediately rather than in the future
3% time discount rate added to every year of life lost in the future
—> estimate net present value of years of life lost
Global disease burden
Death: CD ~ NCD
YLL: CD»_space; NCD
YLD: CD «_space;NCD
DALY: CD ~ NCD
Contributors to global DALY in different age groups
Neonates:
- Neonatal disorder (NND)
Children:
- GE (GI infection)
Adult:
- Mental + other NCD + TA
- HIV
Old age:
- MSD (musculoskeletal) + DM + other NCDs
- IHD + Cancer
Temporal pattern of GDB over last few decades
- Changing proportions of DALYs by different age groups
—> ↓ proportion of DALY by <5
—> ↑ proportion of DALY by 15-69
(disease more affect elderly now) - Overall decline in global age-specific mortality rate
—> huge decline in neonatal MR, smaller decline in adult MR - % change in no. of deaths by country
—> children <5: ↓ no. of deaths for most developing regions apart from sub-Saharan Africa
—> young adults (15-49): ↑ no. of deaths in Botswana, South Africa, Zambia, and Zimbabwe by >500%
(Only small amount attributed to larger population size, mostly due to rapid increases in HIV/AIDS mortality - Change in global cause of death (deaths per 100,000)
- CD: generally ↓ (except HIV/AIDS)
- NCD: generally ↑ - Change in global DALYs
- CD: generally ↓ (except HIV/AIDS)
- NCD: generally ↑ - Change in global YLD
- Mainly due to NCD
Geo-temporal pattern of GDB over last few decades
- DALYs
- Developed countries (high SDI: socio-demographic index):
—> Mainly NCD, generally remained similar
- Developing countries (low SDI):
—> Mainly CD, with some NCD ↑ - Death
- Developed:
—> Mainly NCD, generally remained similar
- Developing:
—> Mainly CD but generally ↓, with some NCD ↑ - YLL
- Developed:
—> Mainly NCD, with some NCD ↑
- Developing:
—> Mainly CD, with some NCD ↑ - YLD
- Developed:
—> Mainly NCD, generally remained similar
- Developing:
—> Mainly ***NCD, generally remained similar - China DALYs
- CD: generally ↓
- NCD: generally ↑ - China YLDs
- Young age: Nutritional deficiencies
- Adult / elderly: Mental / COPD / MSD / other NCD
Major temporal trends in GDB
- Since 1970, globally, Men and women:
- gained slightly more than 10 years of life expectancy overall
- but spend more years living with illness and disability - Broad shift from communicable, maternal, neonatal, nutritional causes towards NCD
- Infectious diseases, maternal and child illness, malnutrition now cause fewer deaths and less illness than 20 years ago
—> fewer children dying every year - NCD (heart disease, cancer) become dominant causes of death and disability worldwide
—> but more young and middle-aged adults are dying and suffering from disease and injury
General global epidemiological transition
- Majority of global mortality contributed by ***developing countries
- Marked ***regional heterogeneity exists in many causes (e.g. violence, suicide, liver cancer, DM)
- Many developing countries suffer from ***“Double disease burden”
—> communicable, maternal, neonatal and nutritional deficiencies remain dominant causes of disease burden (YLL and DALY)
—> increasing burden from NCDs
Geographical distribution and reasons for occurrence of different communicable and non-communicable GI diseases
—> Infantile diarrhoea
Incidence / prevalence of childhood diarrhoea varies >10-fold across geographic areas (very high in central Africa, very low in Japan)
Major risk factor for infantile diarrhoea
- poor sanitation
- lack of clean food and water
- poverty
Treatment:
- ORS
- zinc tablets
Prevention:
- increase clean water and safe sanitation
- promote hygiene education and practice
- exclusive breastfeeding
Geographical distribution and reasons for occurrence of different communicable and non-communicable GI diseases
—> Colorectal cancer
Geographical distribution:
- Incidence of CA colon varies >20 fold across geographic areas
- 2nd most common cancer in developed countries
- Relatively rare in developing countries
—> more towards either a lifestyle / environmental / genetic factor
Temporal changes in disease risk:
- Incidence rates ↑ rapidly in some countries with formerly low rates
- level of risk experienced changes with time
- migrants quickly acquire cancer pattern of host country
—> more towards either a ***lifestyle / environmental rather than genetic factor (meat consumption ↑ —> ↑ colon cancer incidence)
Geographical distribution and reasons for occurrence of different communicable and non-communicable GI diseases
—> Hepatocellular carcinoma
Geographical distribution
- Incidence of HCC varies >12-fold across geographical areas
- 80% of cases in ***developing countries
- uncommon in where hepatitis is not endemic (where mostly metastasis CA)
- correspond closely with patterns of ***hepatitis B endemicity
Risk factors and prevention for HCC
Hep B/ Hep C
- percutaneous blood exposure
—> main-line drug addict
—> blood transfusions
- unprotected sexual intercourse (MSM: men who have sex with men)
- vertical transmission from mother to infant
Prevention of Hep B transmission in HK - public health programs —> universal newborn vaccination (major factor) —> screening of blood products for HBV —> antenatal screening of Hep B infection in pregnant women - behavioural approach —> avoid sharing / reuse of needles —> use of condom / safe sex
Endemicity of Hep B in China
- Highly endemic for chronic Hep B infection
- estimated 130 million HBV carrier
- most cases of acute Hep B infection occur in perinatal / early childhood period
- incidence of HBV still ↑ despite vaccination programme since 1990s
- 1 million new cases in 2005
Summary: QALY, DALY, YLL, YLD
- QALY = Life years x QOL weight (0-1)
- DALY = YLL + YLD
- YLL = N x L
(N: no. of deaths, L: standard life expectancy at age of death (in years)) - YLD = I x L x DW
(I: no. of incident disability cases
L: average duration of disability (years)
DW: disability weight (reflect severity of disease 0-1))