Gender Crime And Justice

Question 1

Overview

Answer 1

There are striking gender differences in the patterns of recorded crime. Girls and women appear to commit fewer crimes than boys and men and, when they do offend, females tend to commit different kinds of crimes from males.
Traditionally, male-dominated criminology neglected female criminality, both because females were seen as committing less crime, and because their behaviour was seen as less in need of controlling. However, more recently, feminists have focused attention on the patterns and causes of female criminality.
Sociologists have also turned their attention to the causes of male criminality. In particular, there has been considerable interest in the relationship between masculinity and crime, and some sociologists have argued that crime is a way for some males to achieve and express their masculinity.

Question 2

Gender patterns of recorded crime stats

Answer 2

Most crime appears to be committed by males. As Heidensohn and Silvestri (2012) observe, gender differences are the most significant feature of recorded crime. For example, official statistics show that:
• Three out of four convicted offenders in England and
Wales are male.
• By the age of 40, 9% of females have a criminal conviction, as against 32% of males.

Question 3

Gender patterns of official stats

Answer 3

Among offenders, there are some significant gender differences. For example, official statistics show that:
• A higher proportion of female than male offenders are convicted of property offences (except burglary).
A higher proportion of male than female offenders are convicted of violence or sexual offences.
• Males are more likely to be repeat offenders, to have longer criminal careers and to commit more serious crimes. For example, men are about 15 times more likely to be convicted of homicide.

Question 4

Do women commit more crime?

Answer 4

Some sociologists and criminologists argue that the statistics underestimate the amount of female as against male offending. Two arguments have been put forward in support of this view.
• Typically ‘female’ crimes are less likely to be reported.
For example, shoplifting is less likely to be noticed or reported than the violent or sexual crimes more often committed by men. Similarly, prostitution - which females are much more likely than males to engage in - is unlikely to be reported by either party.
• Some claim that even when women’s crimes are detected or reported, they are less likely to be prosecuted or, if prosecuted, more likely to be let off relatively lightly.

Question 5

Explaining female crime

Answer 5

Functionalist Sex Role Theory
Chivalry thesis
Patriarchal control
Liberation Thesis

Question 6

Chivalry thesis sociologist

Answer 6

•Pollock (1950)
•Graham and Bowling (1995)
• Flood-Page et al (2000)

Question 7

Chilvary thesis

Answer 7

The thesis argues that most criminal justice agents
- such as police officers, magistrates and judges - are men, and men are socialised to act in a ‘chivalrous’ way towards women.
For example, Otto Pollak (1950) argues that men have a protective attitude towards women. The criminal justice system is thus more lenient with women and so their crimes are less likely to end up in the official statistics. This in turn gives an invalid picture that exaggerates the extent of gender differences in rates of offending.

Question 8

Chivalry thesis and self reported crime

Answer 8

For example, John Graham and Ben Bowling’s (1995) research on a sample of 1,721 14-25-year-olds found that although males were more likely to offend, the difference was smaller than that recorded in the official statistics.
They found that males were 2.33 times more likely to admit to having committed an offence in the previous twelve months - whereas the official statistics show males as four times more likely to offend. Similarly, Flood-Page et al (2000) found that, while only one in 11 female self-reported offenders had been cautioned or prosecuted, the figure for males was over one in seven self-reported offenders.

Question 9

Official stats and chivalry thesis

Answer 9

court statistics appear to give some support to the chivalry thesis. For example: • Females are more likely than males to be released on bail rather than remanded in custody.
• Females are more likely than males to receive a fine or a community sentence, and less likely to be sent to prison.
Women on average receive shorter prison sentences.
Only one in nine female offenders receive a prison sentence for shoplifting, but one in five males.
Similarly, Roger Hood’s (1992) study of over 3,000 defendants found that women were about one-third less likely to be jailed in similar cases.

Question 10

Evidence against chivalry thesis

Answer 10

Farrington and Alison
(1983) study of sentencing of 408 offences of theft in a magistrates’ court found that women were not sentenced more leniently for comparable offences.
Similarly, Buckle and Farrington’s (1984) observational study of shoplifting in a department store witnessed twice as many males shoplifting as females
- despite the fact that the numbers of male and female offenders in the official statistics are more or less equal. This small-scale study thus suggests that women shoplifters may be more likely to be prosecuted than their male counterparts.

Question 11

Eval of self report studies and chivalry thesis

Answer 11

Self-report studies also provide evidence that males commit more offences. For example, young men are more likely than females to report binge drinking, taking illegal drugs or engaging in disorderly conduct. Hales et al (2009) found that they were significantly more likely to have been offenders in all major offence categories. Other studies suggest that the gender gap increases as the offences become more serious.

Question 12

Underreporting male crimes against women

Answer 12

The chivalry thesis also ignores the fact that many male crimes do not get reported. For example, in 2012, only 8% of females who had been victims of a serious sexual assault reported it to the police, while Yearnshire (1997) found that a woman typically suffers 35 assaults before reporting domestic violence.
Crimes of the powerful are also under-represented in self-report and victim surveys, and these are also more likely to be committed by men by virtue of their more privileged position in the job market.
If women appear to be treated more leniently, it may simply be because their offences are less serious. For example, the lower rate of prosecutions of females as compared with their self-reported offending may be because the crimes they admit to are less serious and less likely to go to trial.
Women offenders also seem more likely to snow remorse, and this may help to explain why they are more likely to receive a caution instead of going to court.

Question 13

Bias against women

Answer 13

Many feminists argue that, far from the criminal justice system being biased in favour of women, as the chivaly thesis claims, it is biased against them. As Heidensohn
(1996) argues, the courts treat females more harshly than males when they deviate from gender norms. For example.
• Double standards - courts punish girls but not boys for. premature or ‘promiscuous’ sexual activity. Such girls can end up in care without ever having committed an offence. Sharpe (2009) found from her analysis of 55 youth worker records, that seven out of 11 girls were referred for support because they were sexually active, but none out of 44 boys.

Question 14

Custodial sentences and bias against women

Answer 14

Pat Carlen (1997) puts forward a similar view in relation to custodial sentences. She argues that when women are jailed, it is less for ‘the seriousness of their crimes and more according to the court’s assessment of them as wives, mothers and daughters’. Girls whose parents believe them to be beyond control are more likely to receive custodial sentences than girls who live more ‘conventional’ lives.
Carlen found that Scottish judges were much more likely to jail women whose children were in care than women who they saw as good mothers.

Question 15

Why do double standards exist in the CJS

Answer 15

Feminists argue that these double standards exist because the criminal justice system is patriarchal. Nowhere is this more evident than in the way the system deals with rape cases. There have been numerous cases of male judges making sexist, victim-blaming remarks. Similarly, as Sandra Walklate (1998) argues, in rape cases it is not the defendant who is on trial but the victim, since she has to prove her respectability in order to have her evidence accepted.

Question 16

Explaining female crime

Answer 16

However, sociologists take the view that social rather than biological factors are the cause of gender differences in offending. Sociologists have put forward three main explanations of gender differences in crime: sex role theory, control theory and the liberation thesis.

Question 17

Sociologist behind functional sex role theory

Answer 17

Parsons
Cohen

Question 18

Functional sex role theory

Answer 18

The functionalist Talcott Parsons (1955) traces differences in crime and deviance to the gender roles in the conventional nuclear family. While men take the instrumental, breadwinner role, performed largely outside the home, women perform the expressive role in the home, where they take the main responsibility for socialising the children.
While this gives girls access to an adult role model, Parsons argues, it tends to mean that boys reject feminine models of behaviour that express tenderness, gentleness and emotion.
Instead, boys seek to distance themselves from such models by engaging in ‘compensatory compulsory masculinity’ through aggression and anti-social behaviour, which can slip over into acts of delinquency.
Because men have much less of a socialising role than women in the conventional nuclear family, socialisation can be more difficult for boys than for girls. According to Albert K. Cohen
(1955), this relative lack of an adult male role model means boys are more likely to turn to all-male street gangs as a source of masculine identity. in these subcultural groups, status is earned by acts of toughness, risk-taking and delinquency.

Question 19

New right and functional sex role theory

Answer 19

Similarly, New Right theorists argue that the absence of a male role model in matrifocal lone parent families leads to boys turning to criminal street gangs as a source of status and identity.

Question 20

criticisms of functionalist sex role theory sociologists

Answer 20

walklate
heidensohn

Question 21

Criticisms of functional sex role theory

Answer 21

Sandra Walklate (2003) criticises sex role theory for its biological assumptions. According to Walklate, Parsons assumes that because women have the biological capacity to bear children, they are best suited to the expressive role.
Thus, although the theory tries to explain gender differences in crime in terms of behaviour learned through socialisation, it is ultimately based on untested biological assumptions about sex differences.
Feminists locate their explanations in the patriarchal (male-dominated) nature of society and women’s subordinate position in it.

Heidensohn
• Parsons ignores the role of power and control on shaping
socialisation and the expectations placed on women’s
behaviour

Question 22

Sociologist behind patriarchal control

Answer 22

Heidensohn
Dobash and Dobash (1979)

Question 23

Patriarchal control

Answer 23

Frances Heidensohn (1996) argues that the most striking thing about women’s behaviour is how conformist it is - they commit fewer and less serious crimes than men. In her view, this is because patriarchal society imposes greater control over women and this reduces their opportunities to offend. This patriarchal control operates at home, in public spaces and at work.

Question 24

Control at home

Answer 24

Women’s domestic role, with its constant round of housework and childcare, imposes severe restrictions on their time and movement and confines them to the house for long periods, reducing their opportunities to offend.
Women who try to reject their domestic role may find that their partners seek to impose it by force, through domestic violence.
As Dobash and Dobash (1979) show, many violent attacks result from men’s dissatisfaction with their wives’ performance of domestic duties. Men also exercise control through their financial power, for example by denying women sufficient funds for leisure activities, thereby restricting their time outside the home.
Daughters too are subject to patriarchal control. Girls are less likely to be allowed to come and go as they please or to stay out late. As a result, they develop a ‘bedroom culture’, socialising at home with friends rather than in public spaces.
As a result, they have less opportunity to engage in deviant behaviour on the streets.

Question 25

Control in public

Answer 25

Women are controlled in public places by the threat or fear of male violence against them, especially sexual violence. For example, the Islington Crime Survey found that 54% of women avoided going out after dark for fear of being victims of crime, as against only 14% of men.
Heidensohn notes that sensationalist media reporting of rapes adds to women’s fear. Distorted media portrayals of the typical rapist as a stranger who carries out random attacks frightens women into staying indoors.
Similarly, Sue Lees (1993) notes that in school, boys maintain control through sexualised verbal abuse, for example labelling girls as ‘slags’ if they fail to conform to gender role expectations.

Question 26

Control at work

Answer 26

Women’s behaviour at work is controlled by male supervisors and managers. Sexual harassment is widespread and helps keep women ‘in their place’.
Furthermore, women’s subordinate position reduces their opportunities to engage in major criminal activity at work.
For example, the ‘glass ceiling’ prevents many women from rising to senior positions where there is greater opportunity to commit fraud. As a result, they are less likely to be involved in white collar crime.
In general, these patriarchal restrictions on women’s lives mean they have fewer opportunities for crime. However, Heidensohn recognises that patriarchy can also push some women into crime. For example, women are more likely to be poor (for example, as a result of gender inequalities in the labour market) and may turn to theft or prostitution to gain a decent standard of living.

Question 27

Class and gender deals sociologist

Answer 27

Carlen

Question 28

Class and gender deals

Answer 28

Carlen uses a version of Travis Hirschi’s (1969) control theory to explain female crime. Hirschi argues that humans act rationally and are controlled by being offered a ‘deal’, of rewards in return for conforming to social norms. People will turn to crime if they do not believe the rewards will be forthcoming, and if the rewards of crime appear greater than the risks. Using unstructured tape-recorded interviews, Pat Carlen
(1988) conducted a study of thirty-nine 15-46 year old working-class women who had been convicted of a range of crimes including theft, fraud, handling stolen goods, burglary, drugs, prostitution, violence and arson.
Twenty were in prison or youth custody at the time of the interviews. Although Carlen recognises that there are some middle-class female offenders, she argues that most convicted serious female criminals are working-class.

Question 29

Carlen and working class women

Answer 29

Carlen argues that working-class women are generally led to conform through the promise of two types of rewards or ‘deals’:
• The class deal: women who work will be offered material rewards, with a decent standard of living and leisure opportunities.
• The gender deal: patriarchal ideology promises women material and emotional rewards from family life by conforming to the norms of a conventional domestic gender role.

Question 30

Class deal and Carlen

Answer 30

If these rewards are not available or not worth the effort, crime becomes more likely. Carlen argues that this was the case with the women in her study.
In terms of the class deal, the women had failed to find a legitimate way of earning a decent living and this left them feeling powerless, oppressed and the victims of injustice.
• Thirty-two of them had always been in poverty.
• Some found that qualifications gained in jail had been no help in gaining work upon release. Others had been on training courses but still could not get a job.
• Many had experienced problems and humiliations in trying to claim benefits.
As they had gained no rewards from the class deal, they felt they had nothing to lose by using crime to escape from poverty.

Question 31

Gender deals Carlen

Answer 31

In terms of the gender deal for conforming to patriarchal family norms, most of the women had either not had the opportunity to make the deal, or saw few rewards and many disadvantages in family life.
• Some had been abused physically or sexually by their fathers, or subjected to domestic violence by partners.
• Over half had spent time in care, which broke the bonds with family and friends.
• Those leaving or running away from care often found themselves homeless, unemployed and poor. Carlen concludes that, for these women, poverty and being brought up in care or an oppressive family life were the two main causes of their criminality.

Question 32

Eval of patriarchal control

Answer 32

Heidensohn and Carlen’s approaches to female crime are based on a combination of feminism and control theory:
• Heidensohn shows the many patriarchal controls that help prevent women from deviating.
• Carlen shows how the failure of patriarchal society to deliver the promised ‘deals’ to some women removes the controls that prevent them from offending.
However, both control theory and feminism can be accused of seeing women’s behaviour as determined by external forces such as patriarchal controls or class and gender deals.
Critics argue that this underplays the importance of free will and choice in offending.
Furthermore, Carlen’s sample was small and may be unrepresentative, consisting as it did largely of working-class and serious offenders.

• Connected to the claim that as women are so controlled in
patriarchal society they simply have less opportunities to commit crime
Right realists argue people have free will and choose to
offend
•Carlen’s sample is also small and unrepresentative
• Largely working-class serious offenders

Question 33

Liberation thesis sociologist

Answer 33

Adler

Question 34

Liberation thesis

Answer 34

If patriarchal society exercises control over women to prevent them from deviating, then it would seem logical to assume that, if society becomes less patriarchal and more equal, women’s crime rates will become similar to men’s. Adler argues that, as women become liberated from patriarchy, their crimes will become as frequent and as serious as men’s. Women’s liberation has led to a new type of female criminal and a rise in the female crime rate.
Adler argues that changes in the structure of society have led to changes in women’s offending behaviour. As patriarchal controls and discrimination have lessened, and opportunities in education and work have become more equal, women have begun to adopt traditionally ‘male roles in both legitimate activity (work) and illegitimate activity (crime).
As a result, women no longer just commit traditional
‘female’ crimes such as shoplifting and prostitution. They now also commit typically ‘male’ offences such as crimes of violence and white-collar crimes.
This is because of women’s greater self-confidence and assertiveness, and the fact that they now have greater opportunities in the legitimate structure. For example, there are more women in senior positions at work and this gives them the opportunity to commit serious white-collar crimes such as fraud.

Question 35

Evidence to support liberation thesis

Answer 35

Both the overall rate of female offending and the female share of offences rose during the second half of the 20th century. For example, between the 1950s and 1990s, the female share of offences rose from one in 7 to one in 6.

• Adler argues that the pattern of female crime has shifted. She cites studies showing rising levels of female participation in crimes previously regarded as ‘male’, such as embezzlement and armed robbery.
More recently, there has been media talk of the growth of ‘girl gangs’, while a study by Martin Denscombe
(2001) of Midlands teenagers’ self-images found that females were as likely as males to engage in risk-taking behaviour and that girls were adopting more ‘male’ stances, such as the desire to be in control and look ‘hard’.

Question 36

criticisms of adler sociologist

Answer 36

chesney-lind
laidler and hunt
batchelor
carlen

Question 37

Criticisms of liberation thesis

Answer 37

• The female crime rate began rising in the 1950s - long before the women’s liberation movement, which emerged in the late 1960s.
• Most female criminals are working-class - the group least likely to be influenced by women’s liberation, which has benefited middle-class women much more. According to Chesney-Lind (1997), in the USA poor and marginalised women are more likely than liberated middle-class women to be criminals.
• Chesney-Lind did find evidence of women branching out into more typically male offences such as drugs.
However, this is usually because of their link with prostitution - a very ‘unliberated’ female offence.
• There is little evidence that the illegitimate opportunity structure of professional crime has opened up to women. Laidler and Hunt (2001) found that female gang members in the USA were expected to conform to conventional gender roles in the same way as non-deviant girls.
Nevertheless, Adler’s thesis does draw our attention to the importance of investigating the relationship between changes in women’s position and changes in patterns of female offending.
However, it can be argued that she overestimates both the extent to which women have become liberated and the extent to which they are now able to engage in serious violent crime.

Question 38

Sociologist critic of liberation thesis

Answer 38

• Batchelor (2009)
• Girls tend to be involved with predominately male gangs and are ‘Girls in
Gangs’ rather than part of Girl Gangs
Many of the roles they adopt and actually traditional stereotypes such as sex objects for the gang
This brings into question the whole idea that girls are more liberated now
• Carlen (1988)
• Most women involved in crime come from a working class background
• Working-class are less likely to be influenced by feminism
Carlen argues that class is far more of an influence in leading to criminal
behaviour than gender is

Question 39

females and violent crime sociologist

Answer 39

hand and dodd

Question 40

Females and violent crime

Answer 40

One trend in the official statistics that seems to support Adler’s liberation thesis is the increase in the female arrest and conviction statistics for violent crime. For example, according to Hand and Dodd (2009), between 2000 and 2008, police statistics show the number of females arrested for violence rose by an average of 17% each year. Similar trends have been noted in other countries, including Canada, Australia and the USA.
If these police statistics are an accurate picture of offending, it suggests that females are increasingly committing typically ‘male’ crimes, since violent offending has traditionally been a male form of crime.

Question 41

sociologist for the criminalisation of females

Answer 41

Steffensmeier and Schwartz (2009)

Question 42

The criminalisation of females

Answer 42

However, evidence from other sources paints a different picture. For example, in the USA, Steffensmeier and Schwartz (2009) found that while the female share of arrests for violence grew from one-fifth to one-third between 1980 and 2003, this rise in the police statistics was not matched by the findings of victim surveys. That is, victims did not report any increase in attacks by females.
Similarly, self-report studies showed no upward trend in females’ violent criminality.

Question 43

sociologist for net widening

Answer 43

Steffensmeier and Schwartz (2009)
Chesney-LInd
Sharpe and Gelsthorpe
Worrall

Question 44

Net widening

Answer 44

Steffensmeier and Schwartz conclude that in reality there has been no change in women’s involvement in violent crime. They argue that the rise in arrests is due to the justice system ‘widening the net’ - arresting and prosecuting females for less serious forms of violence than previously.
Similarly, Chesney-Lind (2006) argues that a policy of mandatory arrests for domestic violence has led to a steep rise in the female violence statistics in the USA. Where a couple fight, both may be arrested, even though it is likely that the woman is the victim. Females previously ignored by the justice system now find themselves being labelled as violent offenders.
In the UK, too, Sharpe and Gelsthorpe (2009) note that net-widening policies are producing a rise in the official statistics for females’ violent crimes. There is a growing trend towards prosecuting females for low-level physical altercations, even in some cases for playground fights. Most convictions are for minor offences not involving weapons.
This trend is an example of what Jock Young (2011) calls
‘defining deviance up’ to catch trivial offences in the net.
Worrall (2004) argues that in the past, girls’ miscehaviour was more likely to be seen as a ‘welfare’ issue, whereas now it has been re-labelled as criminality.

Question 45

Moral panic about girls

Answer 45

One view is that it is a social construction resulting from a moral panic over young women’s behavour.leorexample, Burman and Batchelor (2009) point to media depictions of young andmen as drunk and disorderly, out of control and looking
for fights’.
Reports featuring binge drinking, girl gangs and so on may be affecting the criminal justice system. For example, Sharpe (2009) found that professionals such as judges, probation officers and police were influenced by media stereotypes of violent ‘ladettes’ and many believed that girs behaviour was rapidly getting worse. Similarly, in the USA, Steffensmeier et al (2005) found that media-driven moral panics about girls were affecting sentencing decisions.
The overall effect is a self-fulfilling prophecy and an amplification spiral: reports of girls’ misbehaviour sensitise police and courts, who take a tougher stance, resulting in more convictions, which produces further negative media coverage and so on.

Question 46

Gender and victimisation

Answer 46

Large-scale national victim surveys such as the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW 2012) show gender differences in the level and types of victimisation, and in the relationship between victims and offenders.

Question 47

Homicide victims - gender and victimisation

Answer 47

About 70% are male. Female victims are more likely to know their killer and in 60% of these cases, this was a partner or ex-partner. Male victims are most likely to be killed by a friend or acquaintance.

Question 48

Victims of violence - gender and victimisation

Answer 48

Fewer women than men are victims of violence overall. However:
• More women are victims of intimate violence (domestic abuse, sexual assault and stalking). One in four will experience domestic abuse during their adult life.
• Five times more women than men report having been sexually assaulted.
• Women are most likely to be victimised by an acquaintance, men by a stranger.
• Only 8% of females who had experienced serious sexual assault reported it. A third of those who didn’t report it said they believed the police couldn’t do much to help (CSEW 2012).

Question 49

Mismatch between fear and risk - gender and victimisation

Answer 49

Research shows women have a greater fear of crime but the SEW shows they are at less risk of victimisation. However, some local victim surveys such as by Lea and Young (1993) have found that women are in fact at greater risk than men. There is also some evidence from early studies (such as Sparks et al, 1977) that female victims of violence may be more likely to refuse to be interviewed.
Furthermore, victim surveys do not necessarily convey the requency or severity of the victimisation. For example, in the case of domestic abuse, Walby and Allen (2004) have shown that women were much more likely to be victims of multiple incidents. Ansara and Hindi (2011) found that women victims experienced more severe violence and control.

Question 50

Moral panic quote

Answer 50

As Burman and Batchelor put it,
‘What we are witnessing is not an increase in violent offending, but the increased reporting, recording and prosecuting of young women accused of violent offences.

Question 51

Why do men commit crime

Answer 51

Men are socialised into more aggressive, risk taking behaviour
• Men are socialised to be more selfish and therefore succumb to
the pleasure of crime
• The shift in family structure has meant more males are raised without a male role model (Murry)
• There is a crisis in masculinity which men attempt to resolve by conforming to the hegemonic masculinity which leads them to turn to crime

Question 52

Masculinity and crime sociologist

Answer 52

James Messerschmidt

Question 53

Masculinity and crime

Answer 53

James Messerschmidt (1993) argues that masculinity is a social construct or ‘accomplishment’ and men have to constantly work at constructing and presenting it to others. In doing so, some men have more resources than others to draw upon.
Messerschmidt argues that different masculinities coexist within society, but that one of these, hegemonic masculinity, is the dominant, prestigious form that most men wish to accomplish. However, some men have subordinated masculinities.
These include gay men, who have no desire to accomplish hegemonic masculinity, as well as lower-class and some minority ethnic group men, who lack the resources to do so. Messerschmidt sees crime and deviance as resources that different men may use for accomplishing masculinity. For example, class and ethnic differences among youths lead to different forms of rule breaking to demonstrate masculinity:

Question 54

White middle class youth

Answer 54

White middle-class youths have to subordinate themselves to teachers in order to achieve middle-class status, leading to an accommodating masculinity in school. Outside school, their masculinity takes an oppositional form, for example through drinking, pranks and vandalism.

Question 55

White working class yourh

Answer 55

• White working-class youths have less chance of educational success, so their masculinity is oppositional both in and out of school. It is constructed around sexist attitudes, being tough and opposing teachers’ authority.
The ‘lads’ in Willis’ (1977) study are a good example of this kind of masculinity.

Question 56

Black lower WC youth

Answer 56

Black lower working-class youths may have few expectations of a reasonable job due to racism and may use gang membership and violence to express their masculinity, or turn to serious property crime to achieve material success.
Messerschmidt acknowledges that middle-class men t00 may use crime. The difference lies in the type of crime - while middle-class males commit white-collar and corporate crime to accomplish hegemonic masculinity, poorer groups may use street robbery to achieve a subordinated masculinity.

Question 57

Assert masculinity

Answer 57

Messerschmidt (1993) argues different classes and ethnicities commit different crimes to assert their masculinity:

Question 58

Katz

Answer 58

Katz (1988)
• Males are generally socialised to take more risk and to think less of others
• Argues that most theories ignore the pleasure in committing crime
• Crime is enjoyable and petty crimes will offer a ‘sneaky thrill’
• More serious crimes provide pleasure in achieving status and control over the victim
• Therefore, men commit crime because it is pleasurable and since they are socialised to be more selfish than women, they are more likely to indulge themselves

Question 59

Critic of Messerschmidt

Answer 59

Is masculinity an explanation of male crime, or just a description of male offenders (e.g. tough, controlling etc)? Messerschmidt is in danger of a circular argument, that masculinity explains male crimes (e.g. violence) because they are crimes committed by males (who have violent characteristics).
• Messerschmidt doesn’t explain why not all men use crime to accomplish masculinity.
• He over-works the concept of masculinity to explain virtually all male crimes, from joy riding to embezzlement.

Question 60

Postmodernist masculinity and crime sociologist

Answer 60

Winlow

Question 61

Postmodernist masculinity and crime

Answer 61

globalisation has led to a shift from a modern industrial society to a late modern or postmodern de-industrialised society. This has led to the loss of many of the traditional manual jobs through which working-class men were able to express their masculinity by hard physical labour and by providing for their families.
At the same time as job opportunities in industry have declined, there has been an expansion of the service sector, including the night-time leisure economy of clubs, pubs and bars. For some young working-class men, this has provided a combination of legal employment, lucrative criminal opportunities and a means of expressing their masculinity.

Question 62

Winlows study

Answer 62

Simon Winlow’s (2001) study of bouncers in Sunderland in the north east of England, an area of de-industrialisation and high unemployment.

Question 63

Winlow and bouncers

Answer 63

Working as bouncers in the pubs and clubs provided young men with both paid work and the opportunity for illegal business ventures in drugs, as well as the opportunity to demonstrate their masculinity through the use of violence.

Question 64

Bodily capital

Answer 64

In this subculture, the ability to use violence becomes not just a way of displaying masculinity, but a commodity with which to earn a living.
To maintain their reputation and employability, the men must use their bodily capital. For example, many of the bouncers seek to develop their physical assets by bodybuilding.
Winlow notes that this is not just a matter of being able to use violence and win fights, but of maintaining the sign value of their bodies, ‘looking the part’ so as to discourage competitors from challenging them. in other words, the signs of masculinity become an important commodity in their own right. This reflects the idea that in postmodern society, signs take on a reality of their own independent of the thing they supposedly represent.

Question 65

Why is winlows study important

Answer 65

Winlow’s study is important because it shows how the expression of masculinity changes with the move from a modern industrial society to a postmodern, de-industrialised one. At the same time, this change opens up new criminal opportunities for men who are able to use violence to express masculinity, by creating the conditions for the growth of an organised criminal subculture.

Question 66

Evaluation of Winlow

Answer 66

• May be useful in showing how the expression of masculinity changes as we move from modernity to postmodernity, but do all men express masculinity in this way?
• Possibly quite specific to bouncers? Not all men have access to legal employment with illegal opportunities.
• Is Winlow’s sample unrepresentative? Is this trait only typical on men in Sunderland?

Question 67

Eval of PM and masculinity

Answer 67

• Bit more up to date and sophisticated than the other theories BUT still same basic
explanation- socialisation causes men to commit crime
• Is this a circular argument? Masculinity explains male ‘macho’ crime, because they are crimes committed by ‘macho’ males.
• Over generalises: do all men commit crime to construct masculinity? Does masculinity explain the motive behind all crimes? What about poverty/ marginalisation as MORE causal?

Question 68

Overall Evals

Answer 68

Men are more likely to commit crime because:
• They are socialised into more aggressive, risk taking behaviour
The shift in family structure has meant more males are raised without a male
role model
• Men are socialised to be more selfish and so seek ‘pleasure’
There is a crisis in masculinity which men attempt to resolve by turning to
crime. Class and ethnic ditterences in crime types rates can be accounted for
due to different expressions of masculinity