Gender Flashcards
What is the deficit approach to language and gender?
Male language is the standard, while women’s language is deficient
Who created the deficit model?
Robin Lakoff, 1975
What are the features of language defined in the deficit model?
Hedging, fillers, tag questions, apologising for opinions…
What does lakoff claim that the features de4fined in the deficit model suggest about women?
That they speak with uncertainty due to the fact that they have less power compared to men
Who defined male as norm?
Spender, 1980
What is male as norm?
The idea that language itself is patriarchal as the male term is the default
Why is male as norm significant?
As it makes it difficult to challenge the patriarchal structures in society
Who investigated the use of tag questions by women?
Janet Holmes, 1984
What are the three types of tag questions?
Confrontational, modal and affective
What is the purpose of confrontational tag questions?
They create an assertive tone and strengthen the negative force of an utterance
What is the purpose of modal tag questions?
They request information or confirmation and ar4e speaker-orientated
What is the purpose of affective tag questions?
They are address-orientated and interactional, and are motivated by concern for the addresse
Why do women use more tag questions?
As they give them more power in the conversation
What are the criticisms of a deficit approach?
- it is outdated; stereotypes have moved on
- it assumes all men/women act the same way
- it is too generalising
- it doesn’t acknowledge conscious choice
What are the three deficit approach theories?
The deficit model - Lakoff, 1975
Male as Norm - Spender, 1980
Tag questions - Holmes, 1984
What is the dominance approach to language and gender?
The idea that men’s language dominates over women’s
Who did the gender and interruptions study?
Zimmerman and West, 1975
Who were the participants in the gender and interruptions study?
White, 20-35, middle class men and women
Where did the studied conversations take place? (Zimmerman and West, 1975)
The conversations were casual and took place in public areas like coffee shops