FRSC 3110 Crim Flashcards
Four definitional perspectives in present day criminology
Legalistic
Political
Sociological
Psychological
Legalistic Perspective
Crime: thought of the most straight forward. An invention of the law
Human conduct in violation of the criminal laws of a state, the federal government, or a provincial or local jurisdiction that has the power to make such laws
Without the law to determine the behavior to be criminal there would be no crime
So…is crime just an invention of the law?
The social, moral and individual significance of fundamentally immoral forms of behaviour is not easily recognized
Need to consider the temporal element
Problems:
Requires the justice system to function properly, since it involves people, there is error.
Laws change as morals and society change. Gives power to who’s able to make the laws?
Political perspective
Defines crime in terms of power structures
Crime is the result of criteria built into the law by powerful groups & used to label selected undesirable behavior as illegal
Law serves the interests of the politically powerful so they dictate what is criminal
Criminal laws do not bear any inherent relationship to popular notions of right and wrong
Sociological Perspective
Crime is an antisocial act that is necessary to repress in order to preserve the existing system of society (Fattah)
Primarily an offense against human relationships and then a violation of the law (Classen)
Need a broader consideration of crime than either the legal or political perspectives
Psychological Perspective
Crime as problem behavior
A form of social maladjustment.
Results in difficulties in living within a framework of acceptable social arrangements
Three contrasting points of view on what should be defined as criminal
The Consensus Perspective
The Pluralistic Perspective
The Conflict Perspective
Consensus Perspective
Perspective on social organization
Holds that laws should be enacted to criminalize given forms of behavior when members of society generally agree that such laws are necessary
Core values exist within society
Laws reflect the collective will of the people
Laws serve all people equally
Those who violate the law represent a unique subgroup of the population that have to be brought in line
Whose values contravene the majority
Pluralist Perspective
Holds that multiple values and beliefs exist in any complex society…
But most social actors agree on usefulness of law as a means of dispute resolution
Many diverse social groups exist within society
Each social group has its own characteristic set of values, beliefs, and interests
Formalized laws are viewed as useful in the settlement of disputes
The legal system is value-neutral and concerned with the best interests of society
Value Neutral
Value Neutral
free of petty disputes or above the level of general contentiousness that may characterize relationships between groups
Conflict Perspective
An approach to social organization that considers conflict a fundamental aspect of social life and can never be fully resolved
Society is comprised of diverse social groups
Each group has different definitions of right and wrong
Conflict between groups is unavoidable
Group conflict centers on the exercise of political power
Law is a tool of power
The powerful strive to keep their power
Further their interests (gain and deny “legitimate” access to resources)
But no matter how you look at it, crime is diverse, in both nature and motive.
Crime rate trends in the 60s and 70s
Increase in alcohol consumption, increase in divorce rates, increase in use of mind-altering drugs
Dramatic increase in crime rates
Contributed to greater interest in discipline of criminology
Definitions of criminology
Boyd - “the scientific study of crime”
Gabor – “the systematic study of crime & reaction of society to criminality”
Winterdyk – “the scientific study of human behaviour, crime causation, crime prevention, and the punishment and rehab of offenders”
Schmalleger & Volk – “an interdisciplinary profession built around the scientific study of crime and criminal behavior, including their forms, causes, legal aspects, prevention, control”
3 things criminologists do
The study of what motivates people to commit crimes
Identifying effective crime prevention strategies
Considering the response of society to different crimes
Definition of criminology
Draws on sociology, psychology, biology, law geography, economics
Criminologist definition
Study crime and its prevention
Criminals and their treatment
Societies responses to crime
Criminalist
Focus on the collection of evidence from crime scenes. Used mostly in the U.S
Identify, document, collect, test, analyze & preserve evidence
Interpret findings and testify in court
Criminalization and decriminalization
Criminalization process
How certain behaviors become criminalized over time, while others become decriminalized
The stigmatization process — how offenders are treated or “labeled”
Net widening/shrinking — the potential of new laws and methods to increase/decrease “community” supervision and impact social control
The effects of smartphones and electronic surveillance
3 approaches for integrating theories
Sociological approaches
Psychological approaches
Biological approaches
Sociological Approaches
Focus on the social order and on how social forces work to define crime and create the conditions in which crime can either diminish or flourish
Examine how social conditions (social context) can influence our laws and our crime rates.
Argue that criminal conduct is more likely to be driven by social conditions than by individual “aberrations”
Psychological Approaches
Focus on individual criminal behavior
Trying to predict the risk of reoffending
Trying to evaluate the effectiveness of treatment and rehabilitation
Put the individual front and center
they focus on the individual’s psyche and behavior
Biological Approaches
Early criminologists argue that criminality was a biological trait
Little empirical evidence to support the notion of a crime gene
Recent biological approaches have focused more on interplay between biology and the environment
Argue that some individuals have personality traits or certain characteristics that predispose them to committing crime
Social Problem Perspective
Crime is the manifestation of underlying social problems:
Poverty
Discrimination
Breakdown of traditional social institutions
Pervasive family violence
Inadequate socialization practices
Social Responsibility Perspective
Individuals are fundamentally responsible for their own behavior
They choose crime over other more law-abiding courses of action
Why measure crime
Gause the heath of a community or society
Determine if crime is on the increase, in decline, or fairly stable over time and compare the rates across neighborhoods, regions, or nations.
Predict crime to prevent it.
Determine the risk of victimization for different groups.
Establish the social and economic impact of crime on society.
Allocate resources in the most cost-effective way.
Create and evaluate crime prevention programs.
Debunk crime myths.
2 ways to measure crime
Quantitative and qualitative data
Quantitative data
Data represented in numeric form
Methods for collection highly structured
Shows overall patterns – comparisons made by group, times & patterns
Issues are what to count, how to define crime, how to count?
Qualitative Data
Data collected result of interactions with research participants
Puts context to quantitative research
Basis for crime measuring for many of commonly used crime statistics
Crimes known to police
Crime Funnel
Large amount of undetected, unreported crime. Most crimes (two thirds) are not reported to police.
Undetected/unreported crime → Detected but unreported crime → Reported crime→Reported by police (UCR)
4 sources of data
Official Crime Statistics – Uniform
Crime Reports (UCR & UCR2)
Victimization Surveys
Self-report Surveys
Other (observational and experimental studies; biographies, documentaries, public records)
UCR
Uniform Crime Report
Three areas of concern with official crime data
The failure of victims and witnesses to report many crimes.
Law enforcement practices and recordkeeping may vary.
Methodological issues (E.g. How crime counted?)
Dark figure of crime
is crime that is unknown, either because it is undiscovered or unreported.
Police discover < 5% of crime themselves
two-thirds of crimes are not reported to the police
Suggests that data collected by the UCR is “erroneous and incomplete”
Reasons victims report crime
Completed (vs. attempted)
Produces injuries
Involves weapon
Direct confrontation
Substantial financial loss
Committed by stranger
Insured property