Forensics Flashcards
What is offender profiling
An investigative technique used to narrow down the list of suspects by identifying the major personality and behavioural characteristics of the offender from an analysis of the crimes they committed
Briefly describe the top down approach
- aka typology approach
- offender profilers will match what is known about the crime and the offender to a pre existing template the FBI developed
- organised/ disorganised
Describe an organised offender:
Crime scene
Crime Scene: The victim is deliberately targeted- a ‘type’ Crime has been planned in advance Body hidden No weapon at crime scene
Describe an organised offender:
Personality
Planned the crime in advance High degree of control Above average intelligence Skilled professional occupation Socially competent
Describe disorganised offender:
Crime scene
Victim is known Little evidence of planning Spontaneous Body left at scene Little control
Describe the disorganised offender:
Personality
Lower than average IQ
Unskilled work
History of sexual dysfunction
Live alone
Evaluate the top down approach
❌canter, investigated 100 murders, found characteristics for ‘organised’ criminals to be true but not for ‘disorganised’
❌Alison: predictive validity
assumes how they act at the crime scene is how they act in real life
What is the bottom up approach
Profilers work up from the evidence gathered at the crime scene to develop hypotheses about the likely characteristics and social background of the offender
To generate a profile of the offender
What is investigative profiling
A type of bottom up profiling:
- aim is to establish patterns of behaviour that are likely to occur or coexist across crime scenes so to establish a statistical ‘database’
- an attempt to apply statistical procedures alongside psychological theory to the analysis of crime scene evidence
What is interpersonal coherence
The idea that the way an offender behaves at the scene reflects their behaviour on more everyday situations
Define geographical profiling
A form of bottom up profiling based on the patterns shown by the locations of a series of crimes
Allows the researcher to make educated guesses about where the offender is likely to strike next
How is timing of offences related to georgraphical profiling
Information about the geographical location is more useful when it’s combined with the information about when the crime was committed
Canters ‘circle theory’ proposed two models of offender behaviour, what are they
The marauder- who operates in close proximity to their home base
The commuter- who is likely to have travelled a distance away from their usual residence
Evaluate the bottom up approach
✅John Duffy, ‘railway rapist’ carried out 24 sexual attacks and 3 murders in women near railway, canter analysed geographical information from crime scenes and details from past similar offences, profile was surprisingly accurate
✅lundrigan & canter, investigated spatial consistency in the behaviour of killers. The location of each body disposal created a centre of gravity where the offenders base was in the centre, supports the role of spatial information
✅comparison, bottom up profiling is more objective and scientific than the top down approach as it is more grounded in evidence and psychological theory and less driven by speculation and hunches
❌Rachel Nickell - took 16yrs to find real killer after killed was ruled out because he was several inches taller than profile
What are the two biological explanations of offending
Atavistic form
Genetic explanations
Neural explanations
Define atavism
Relating to or characterised by reverting back to something ancient or ancestoral
Who suggested atavistic form
Lombroso
What did lombroso suggest
-Criminals were a more primitive version of humans, essentially a genetic throwback to an earlier species
‘-Less evolved people’
-Not evolved enough to function in a civilised society
Name 3 physical anomalies that lombroso suggested
Narrow sloping brow
High cheek bones
Long ears
What are the characteristics of the two sub types of criminal according to lombroso
Murderers:
Bloodshot eyes
Curly hair
Long ears
Sexual deviants:
Glinting eyes
Swollen fleshy lips
Projecting ears
Evaluate atavistic form
✅lombroso
Examined facial and cranial features of hundreds of Italian convicts, found 40% of criminal acts could be accounted by atavistic characteristics
❌scientific racism
Many of the facial characteristics identified were typical of African origin, this theory would offer support for eugenics (selective breeding)
✅father of modern criminology
Lombroso has been credited for shifting the emphasis in crime research away from
Being ‘weak minded’ towards a more scientific credible claim
Define neural explanation
An explanation of behaviour in terms of the brain and nervous system
Describe Raine as supporting evidence for the neural explanation
Studied 41 violent offenders using PET scans, found violent offenders showed significantly less activity in prefrontal lobe than the controls
Suggesting they have less control over impulsive behaviour
What does the genetic explanation suggest
People may inherit a gene that makes them pre determined to criminal behaviour
Describe Tihonen
A genetic analysis of almost 900 offenders revealed abnormalities one the MAOA gene (responsible for dopamine and serotonin- links to aggression)
What does the MAOA gene do
Monoamine oxidase A
ENZYME↪️ breaks down neurotransmitters in the brain including dopamine and serotonin
Low levels of serotonin have been associated with impulsive and aggressive behaviour
Describe Christiansen (1977)
Looked at over 3,500 twin sets in Denmark
52% concordance rate for criminality was found for MZ twins
22% CC for DZ twins
❌not 100% = other factors must be involved
Evaluate neural and genetic explanation
❌diathesis stress model
Diathesis= a genetic predisposition
Stress= triggered by a stressor
The idea of epigenetics suggests that genes are switched on or off as a result of environmental factors Eg childhood
✅Caspi
Longitudinal study of 1000 people, found a significant number of men with low MAOA genes had experienced maltreatment when they were babies
❌Jim Fallon
Low activity of prefrontal cortex. Defective MAOA gene, not a serial killers as not had trauma in childhood
❌reductionism, reduces behaviour down to our biological components such as na and brain structures
What did Hans Eysenck Argue
There are identifiable personality traits and that these have a genetic basis
A personality is a mix of biological tendencies combined with learning experiences
NATURE and NURTURE
How was Eysencks criminal personality tested
Using a questionnaire designed to give a
N score- neuroticism
P score- psychotism
E score- extraversion
What is the biological basis of a high neurotic score
Over active sympathetic nervous system
↪️unstable and therefore unpredictable