forensic psychology Flashcards
what is offender profiling?
- an investigative tool used by police to solve crimes.
- aims to narrow the field of enquiry and list of suspects.
The American approach - Top down approach
- it originated in the USA as a result of the FBI’s work.
- the FBI drew upon data gathered from interviews with serial killers.
- offender profiling is is used to match whats known about a crime and offender to a pre-existing template that the FBI developed.
Organised and Disorganised offenders
- ORGANISED OFFENDERS
planned the crime in advance, victim targeted, high control, little evidence or clues left behind, above average intelligence, skilled professional occupation, married maybe children. - DISORGANISED OFFENDERS
little planning, spontaneous offence, body at crime scene, lower than average IQ, unemployed, failed relationships, live alone near the offence.
stages of FBI profile
- Data assimilation - reviewing of evidence (photos, pathology)
- Crime scene classification - organised or dis
- Crime reconstruction - hypothesis in terms of sequence of events and behaviour of victim.
- Profile generation - hypothesis related to offence. (background, characteristics)
EVALUATION
- Only applies to certain crimes
- based on outdated personality models
- counter evidence (psychologist?)
- top down profiling is best suites to scenes that reveal important details about the suspect. e.g. rape, torture. more common offences such as burglary can not be profiled as the scene tells little about the offender. limited approach.
- offender profiling is based on the idea that offenders have patterns of behaviour that are consistent. critics suggest it is naive and external factors are constantly changing to impact behaviours. poor validity.
- CANTER analysed data from 100 murders in the USA. details of each case were examined with reference to characteristics of typical o and d offenders.findings did not support the d offender which undermines the approach.
what is the bottom up approach? (BRITISH)
- generates a picture of the offender through analysis of crime scene evidence.
- characteristics, routine behaviour, social background.
- the profile emerges as the investigator engages in deeper scrutiny of details of the offence.
what is investigative psychology?
- it attempts to apply statistical procedures alongside psychological theory, to analyse crime scene evidence.
- it tries to establish patterns of behaviour that occur across scenes. this is a database which is a baseline for comparison.
- details are matched against the database to reveal important details about the offender.
- INTERPERSONAL COHERENCE is the way an offender acts at the scene. e.g. some rapists may have control to humiliate victims but others are more apologetic.
what is geographical profiling?
(Psychologist?)
circle theory
(psychologist?)
- ROSSMO used geographical profiling.
- it uses info about the location of linked crime scenes to make inferences about the home base of the offender. (crime mapping)
- the assumption is that serial offenders restrict work to geographical areas they are familiar with.
- investigators can make educated guesses about where an offender is likely to strike next.
- CANTER’S circle theory proposed two models of offender behaviour.
1. Marauder
operates close proximity to home base.
2. Commuter
travelled distances away from their base.
Patterns of offending forms a circle around their base.
EVALUATION
- evidence for investigative psychology (psychologists?)
- evidence for geographical profiling (psychologists?)
- scientific basis
- CANTER AND HERITAGE did a content analysis of sexual assault cases. They used a computer programme to identify correlations. impersonal language and lack of relation to victims were found. this shows that statistical techniques can be applied to most cases.
- LUNDRIGAN AND CANTER collated information from 120 murder cases. analysis revealed spatial consistency in behaviours of killers. the offenders base was in the centre of offences. this supports the circle theory.
- bottom up profiling is more objective and scientific and less driven by speculation. with aid of AI, investigators can manipulate geographical, biological, and psychological data quickly to produce insights and results that assist in the investigation.
what is the atavistic form? (psychologist?)
- LOMBROSO suggested criminals were genetic throwbacks and were biologically different from non-criminals.
- his ideas laid the foundation for modern offender profiling techniques.
- offenders lacked evolutionary development so could not adjust to the demands of civilised society and would turn to crime.
what are the atavistic characteristics? (psychologist?)
-LOMBROSO argued features of the face and head make criminals physically different.
- the atavistic form included a narrow slopping brow, strong jaw, high cheekbones, facial asymmetry, dark skin and extra toes, fingers or nipples.
- Murderers had bloodshot eyes, long ears, swollen lips.
- they use criminal slang, have tattoos and are unemployed.
what was LOMBROSO’S research?
- he examined features of many living and dead convicts. He examined 383 skulls of dead criminals and 3839 living ones to find 40% of criminal acts could be accounted for by atavistic characteristics.
EVALUATION
- contribution to criminology
- scientific racism (psychologist?)
- contradictory evidence (psychologist?)
- LOMBROSO is the father of modern criminology and has shifted emphasis in crime research away from moralistic discourse and towards a more scientific and credible realm. trying to describe people who are likely to commit crime is the beginning of criminal profiling.
- DELISI draws attention to racial undertones in the many of the features identified such as curly hair, dark skin are found amongst those of African descent. This makes his work uncomfortable and controversial today.
- GORING set out to establish if there was physical or mental abnormalities among the criminal classes. he conducted a comparison between 3000 criminals and 3000 non and found no evidence that offenders had the characteristics.
what is the genetic explanation for crime? (psychologists?)
- offenders inherit a gene that predisposes them to commit crime.
- this is commonly demonstrated by twin studies.
LANGE investigated 13 identical (MZ) and 17 non-identical (DZ) twins where one had spent time in prison. 10 of the MZ and 2 DZ had co-twins also in prison. Genetics must play a role in offending behaviours.
candidate genes research
(psychologist?)
- TIHONEN genetically analysed offenders and found abnormalities in 2 genes associated with violent crime. in the sample those with high risk combination were 13 times more likely to have a history of violent behaviour.
Diathesis stress model explanation
- genetics have influence on offending but so does environment.
- tendency towards criminal behaviour comes about through a combination of genetic predisposition and biological or psychological trigger.
neural explanation
prefrontal cortex (psychologist?)
mirror neurons (psychologist?)
- there are neural differences in the brains of criminals and non - criminals.
- RAINE studied antisocial personality disorder brains. He found several dozen brain imaging studies showing individuals with APD have reduced activity in their prefrontal cortex (regulates emotional behaviour).
- KEYSERS found when criminals were asked to empathise did the empathy reaction activate. This shows APD individuals are not totally without empathy but have a neural switch that can be turned on and off.
EVALUATION
- problems with twin studies
- support for the diathesis stress model of crime (psychologist?)
- biological reductionism
- LANGES research was poorly controlled, and judgements were based on appearance rather than DNA testing this means they lack validity. Twin studies also include smaller sample sizes and are unrepresentative of the rest of the population. most twins are reared in the same environment, which is a confounding variable.
- MEDNICK studies 13,000 adoptees and found when neither biological nor adoptive patents had convictions, 13.5% of adoptees had. When either did it was 20% and when both it was 24.5%. This shows that biological and environmental are important.
- Criminality is complex and explanations that reduce offending behaviour to a genetic or neural level are overly simplistic. Crime runs in family but so does mental illness, poverty and social deprivation.
General personality theory (EYSNECK)
- EYSNECK was important in personality and inteligence research.
- he proposed that behaviour could be represented along introversion/extraversion and neuroticism/stability.
Biological basis
- EYSENCK believed personality traits had a biological origin and come about through the nervous system we have.
- extroverts have an underactive nervous system which seeks excitement, stimulation and risk taking behaviours. They learn from mistakes.
- neurotic people are nervous, jumpy, over anxious which makes them hard to predict.
The criminal personality
- neurotic-extravert
- they are also cold , unemotional, and prone to aggression.
The role of socialisation
- EYSENCK believed personality is linked to criminal behaviour via socialisation process.
- criminal behaviour is developmentally immature and concerned with immediate gratification.
- the process of delayed gratification is taught to children to be more patient and socially oriented.
- people with the criminal personality were hard to condition and act on impulses.