Forensic psychology Flashcards
define top down processing
an experienced profiler uses pre-existing templates of different types of offender to fit the offender into one of these templates, based on crime scene evidence
what is top down processing also known as?
typological approach
what are the six stages to top down processing?
- Profiling inputs
- Decision process models
- Crime assessment
- Criminal profile
- Report writing
- Apprehension
Detail step 1- profiling inputs
data is collected on the crime scene, background info about victims, details of the crime(s)
detail step 2- decision process models
data is organised based into meaningful patterns such as murder type, time/loocation factors
detail step 3- crime assessment
offender is classified as organised or disorganised based on factors such as evidence of planning, familiarity of victim, use of restraints, evidence left at the scene etc
detail step 4- criminal profile
a profile is constructed including info such as likely background, habits, beliefs
detail step 5- report writing
a written report is given to the investigating agency and the people matching the profile are evaluated. if there is new evidence or no subject is identified, the process goes back to step 2
detail step 6- apprehension
if a suspect is apprehended, the profile is reviewed at every stage to check that the conclusions made were valid
top down approach- evaluation peel 1
p- research support of usefulness in real life
ev- copson, 184 US police officers, 82% believed approach useful, 90% would use again
ex- useful in narrowing down suspect list, directing investigation and saving time, approach is both effective and useful
l- whole approach is based on flawed data, obtained from most extreme violent crimes, cannot be generalised, not useful in real life
top down approach- evaluation peeleel
p- idea of organised vs disorganised offenders is flawed
ev- canter, analysed 39 characteristics in murders by 100 serial killers, no clear division between organised/disorganised, little evidence for disorganised
ex- assumption of two specific offender types is flawed, most crimes are not disorganised, if majority are classified as organised, little is narrowed down, not effective
l- better to consider offenders on a continuum, improve the top down approach
ev- douglas et al, third category of ‘mixed’ offender, that sits on this continuum
ex- allows for offenders who have elements of both organised/disorganised, easier to classify
l- too general, may act as a ‘dustbin category’, most offenders would fit this category, doesn’t narrow suspect list, reducing effectiveness
define bottom up processing
a data driven approach that makes use of statistical data on similar crimes in order to make predictions about the characteristics of an offender
what is the bottom up approach sometimes known as?
the british approach
what are the two sub-sections of bottom up processing
investigative psychology and geographical psychology
what are the main features of investigative psychology (canter)?
- interpersonal coherence
- forensic awareness
- smallest space analysis
detail interpersonal coherence
the assumption that: people are consistent in their behaviour- there will be a correlation between the crime and how people behave in everyday life, and that people’s behaviour changes over time- looking at differences in crimes over a 4 year period might offer further clues
detail forensic awareness
certain behaviours may reveal an awareness of particular police techniques and past experience