Final Flashcards
Why do some say the assertiveness of the 2018 NPR is not right?
It is too aggressive and expensive
Why do some scholars say the assertiveness of the 2018 NPR is the right move?
The US has neglected its nukes for too long, the US must adapt to great power competition, the US must adapt to technological evolution, costs are manageable
Why do some scholars say the US needs tactical nukes against Russia and China?
Strategic nukes are too destructive to be used and tactical nukes will compensate for the erosion of the US conventional military edge
What were Biden’s campaign promises on nukes?
The US would only use nukes to deter enemies or retaliate, and we would work with other great powers on arms control
What has Biden done on nukes since in power?
Remained vague under the conditions nukes would be used, and endorsed the US nuclear modernization program
How many domestic sites are there of nukes?
24, in 11 states
How many warheads does the US have?
5,244
How many nuclear warheads does the US have deployed?
1,770
How many nukes does the US have in storage?
1,938
How many nukes does the US have retired?
1,536
What assets does the US nuclear program have?
Best delivery vehicles, best intelligence capabilities, global network of bases
When was the emergence of the nuclear triad?
1960
When did debates start about the survival of the triad?
End of the Cold War
What are the arguments against the nuclear triad?
It is pointless and has destabilizing effects
Why do some say the triad is pointless?
Terrorists are the main threat to US and cannot be deterred, rogue states are the other main threats, but have small arsenal’s, because of technological breakthroughs that facilitate detection some elements of the triad are likely to lose their stealth
What did the US strategic command of 1992 say?
Retain the triad to prepare for new or resurgence enemies
Why do some scholars argue the triad should be retained?
Dismantling the triad would be risky, each branch of the triad offers specific strategic advantages, the nuclear triad makes US nuclear attacks more unpredictable for the enemy, the triad advances the cause of nuclear disarmament
Why do some scholars say dismantling the nuclear triad would be risky?
It would be a sign of weakness for enemies and allies, reduces US ability to counter a system, failure or enemy tech breakthroughs
How does the nuclear triad advance the cause of nuclear disarmament?
US leaders will be more willing to reduce the size of America’s arsenal because the triad makes them feel more secure
When did US leaders first start considering BMDs?
The 1940s
What was the first serious attempt at ballistic missile defense?
Strategic Defense initiative of 1983
When did the US withdraw from the anti-ballistic missile treaty?
2001
How much has the US spent on BMD’s since 1983?
Over $2 billion
How many ground-based midcourse defense interceptors are there?
44 with 40 in Alaska, and four in California
What is the function of ground-based midcourse defense interceptors?
Well, there’s not enough interceptors to stop a full scale Russian, or Chinese ICBM attack, small nuclear weapons states ICBM can be stopped, like North Korea, and in the future, Iran
What is terminal high altitude area defense?
Mobile BMD systems designed to intercepts short and medium range missiles during their final descent
Where are the main THAAD systems?
Overseas US bases like Guam and some US allies like South Korea, Israel and the UAE
What are aegis BMD’s?
Systems initially on Americas aegis ships designed to intercept short and medium range ballistic missiles
What are patriot advanced capability 3 BMDs?
Mobile BMDs deployed in various parts of the world to defend small areas like military bases or an airfield
Why does the US invest in BMD systems?
To deter attacks, minimize damage in case of general nuclear war, entrench US influence in the allied states that deployed those BMD’s, encircle Russia, and China
Why do BMD systems deter attacks?
An enemy would not like to waste assets that are likely to be intercepted
How is US influence entrenched in allied states that deploy BMD’s?
The systems require inter-operability and signal solidarity with the United States
What are other uses for BMD systems?
Intelligence collection on enemy sites through radars and attack on enemy sides
Why do some scholars oppose BMD systems?
Questionable effectiveness, very expensive, and a risk of escalation
When did the industrial military complex emerge?
The early Cold War first coined in Eisenhower’s’s farewell speech in 1960
What are the members of the industrial military complex?
The US military, military corporations, Congress, and think tanks
What members of the trump administration were also employed in defense contractors?
SecDef James Mattis was a board member of General dynamics, White House Chief of Staff John Kelly was an advisor to DynCorp, secretary of army Mark Esper was the former Raytheon, Vice President
What percent of the top 10 foreign policy and defense think tanks worldwide received money from military corporations?
80%
What percent of the top 10 foreign-policy in defense think tanks worldwide receive money from governments?
90%
Why do governments incorporations fund think tank research?
For objective analysis, but also access to informal networks were policies are formed, leveraging the intellectual or political prestige of think tanks, to push favorable narratives or policy ideas, obstructing the outlets that could support alternative voices, and to prevent critical information from reaching the mass public
What are the consequences of government incorporation funding on think tanks?
Rare direct censorship, common self censorship, perspective filtering
What are the consequences of governments and corporations funding think tanks on US nuclear policy?
No change in the US nuclear policy, and constant push for expansion and modernization
When did China first start developing the nuclear program?
Spring of 1952
Why did China start their nuclear program?
Because of US nuclear threats during the Korean War
Why was there an acceleration in China’s nuclear program in 1954?
Discovery of uranium reserves
Why was there a debate about the desirability of nukes in China in 1961?
The Sino-Soviet split ending Soviet nuclear assistant and economic disaster of the great leap forward
When was China’s first nuclear test?
October 1964
What did China’s first nuclear doctrine say?
They would adopt a minimum deterrence strategy, pledge no first use, and oppose the US Soviet arms race
In what ways has China neglected its nuclear program?
It had no details, operational doctrine, a small unsophisticated and vulnerable arsenal. Only a few dozen missiles, a few bombers in a single nuclear submarine.
What were Mao Zedong and Deng Xiaping’s beliefs about China’s nukes?
They did not believe in value of nukes for comment, and the girls were turns in preventing nuclear blackmail
How did the communist parties domination over the military in China affect the nuclear policy?
Secrecy and intellectual conformism hurt nuclear debates. There was an unwillingness to defy the leaders views and the cultural revolution disrupted China’s military institutions.
What was China’s strategic culture like that led to nuclear neglect?
Emphasis on moral dimensions in an emphasis on an indirect approach to war
What was China’s first official nuclear strategy?
2006 white paper
What does the 2006 white paper say?
The Chinese nuclear doctrine was the same as in the past
Why was it remarkable the Chinese nuclear doctrine stayed the same as in the past in the 2006 white paper?
Chinese fast growing resources, trying to see huge commercial military reforms during these years, and the relative opening of China as the communist regime became less oppressive
What is the function of the 2015 white paper?
It showed that China had growing nuclear ambitions and then to 2016 reforms, including a higher status for nuclear weapons in Chinese military
What expanding nuclear assets does China have?
More nukes, more missiles, more road mobile missiles, or SLBMs, and more anti-satellite weapons to destroy US satellitesq
What are the new debates among Chinese leaders?
Should China abandon first no use and should China raise its alert status
What is China’s sprint to parity?
The growth of nuclear weapons was likely 1500 by 2035
In what ways has China been trying to deceive the world about its nuclear weapons?
Hiding its nukes in new tunnels, covertly testing tactical nukes, and the lack of transparency and accountability
Why do some scholars say that you guys should not feel overly alarmed by China’s nuclear program?
Chinese nuclear arsenal remain small, China’s readiness level is still love, Chinese nuclear secrecy is understandable, the reluctance on arms control is normal, China lacks fissile material to build more nukes, China’s lesson from history is to focus on economic growth, China is building up because it worries about the US, and US intelligence agencies have gotten China wrong many times before
Why do some scholars say Chinese nuclear secrecy is understandable?
It is surrounded by US military assets and allies, the US has huge offensive capabilities, and China’s few nukes and delivery vehicles
What are some flashpoints for a future US China war?
The East China Sea, the South China Sea, or most likely, Taiwan
What are some reasons why China might escalate a conflict to the nuclear level?
The vulnerability of China’s nuclear arsenal, the inherent dynamics of any crisis can make escalation inevitable, the US could inadvertently strike nuclear assets
How do the inherent dynamics of any crisis make escalation inevitable?
Risk of misperceptions, risk of bad intelligence, and a huge pressure on leaders to show brinkmanship
What are some reasons why China would not escalate a conflict the nuclear level?
China will not fear US is about to destroy its nukes and the US has everything under control
Why does China not fear the US is about to destroy its nukes?
It’s nuclear assets are well hidden, its nuclear assets are dispersed, and its nuclear assets are strongly hardened
Why do we have limited intelligence on North Korea’s nuclear program?
It’s a secretive and isolated dictatorship
When did North Korea first construct a nuclear reactor?
The early 1960s
When was North Korea’s first nuclear test?
2006
What is the security rationale North Korea has for its nukes?
Since 1950, US troops have been in South Korea, and have made nuclear threats, as well as an early post Cold War insecurity and concerns about states that abandon nukes or nuclear programs that were attacked
How did identity play a role in the decision of the North Korean nuclear program?
The North Koreans want to overcome memories of Japanese colonialism in a frustrated with their dependency on China and Russia, or other great powers, this concept means they take extreme measures to retain control and show hostility
How did North Korea’s nukes lead to domestic political gains?
The strengthen the masses support for the countries leaders, and divert attention away from domestic failures
What was the 1993 to 1994 crisis between the US and North Korea?
An incident where both countries made threats in the US considered preventative strikes, and North Korea’s facilities. It was ended by Jimmy Carter’s visit to Pyongyang and the US North Korea agreed framework.
What did the six party talks from 2003 to 2009 say?
North Korea would disarm in exchange for economic and security cooperation. However, they will soon test their first nuclear weapon.
What was Obama’s strategy towards North Korea’s nuclear program?
Strategic patience, or having more sanctions to incline North Korea to work towards denuclearization
Why did the rise of Kim Jong-un need to an expansion of North Korea’s nuclear ambitions?
Kim Jong-un was domestically weak, North Korea faced tensions with China, and there was a fear of a US coup
What caused the 2017 US North Korean nuclear crisis?
In August, US Intel showed that North Korea’s ICBMs could reach the US homeland, so Trump issued several threats and the North Koreans retaliated
What ended the 2017 US North Korean nuclear crisis?
North Korea is needed for economic assistance, election of a new South Korean president open to talks, and trumps interest in a big summit
What happened during Trump and Kim’s first meeting in Singapore, June 2018?
Trump declared there was no longer a nuclear threat from North Korea, but no real progress was made towards denuclearization
How is North Korea still a growing threat?
The continued build up of their nukes, road, mobile launchers, solid, fuel missiles (harder to detect and faster launches), considers, tactical, nukes, and recently tested a new ICBM
What is the rate of success during the US missile defense tests?
56%
Why might China oppose the US intervention in North Korea?
Prevent the US from deploying at China’s border
Why might China try to help the US neutralize North Korea as long as the US promises not to stay in the country?
China might be concerned about how North Korea’s instability could destabilize their country, and Beijing is tired of North Korea’s reckless nuclear policies
What is extended deterrence?
The protection of allies, possibly with nuclear strikes
How many US nukes were in east Asia in the late 1960s?
More than 3000
What events have led to growing concerns of Americas allies in east Asia?
The US drawl of its tactical nukes, North Korea’s nuclear development, China’s nuclear buildup, trumps rejection of alliances, China’s military and economy, catching up with the US, and Russia’s attack on Ukraine
What percent of South Koreans in 2017 wanted a nuclear weapon?
60%
What has Japan’s debate about developing a nuclear weapon looked like?
They have a strong aversion to nuclear weapons among the people, but they worry about North Korea and China
What was the relationship like between the US and Iran in the Shah era?
Good, Iran participated in Atoms for Peace and they had major civilian plans
What led to growing Iran nuclear ambitions?
The Iran-Iraq War (1980-1988), where Iraq attacked Iran and used chemical weapons, with only support from the west
When did the Iran nuclear controversy start?
Post-CW, with CIA predictions that Iran would have the bomb by 2000, and being in Bush’s axis of evil speech
Why did the US not strike Iran in the early 2000s?
Entanglements in Iraq
What was Stuxnet?
A US Israel computer virus discovered in 2010 to derail Iran centrifuges
When was the JSPOA signed?
July 2015
Who signed the JCPOA?
Iran, US, EU, China, Russia, France, Britain, Germany