Exam 2 Flashcards
What are the key insights of nuclear optimism?
Nukes make leaders more reasonable and nukes explain why there hasn’t been a world war since 1945
What policy do nuclear optimists support?
More nuclear weapons for more stability
What are the three approaches that nuclear pessimists say increase the risk of instability?
Risk of irrational leadership, even rational leaders will consider nuclear war, and there are inherent risks in large organizations
What did nuclear pessimists believe about Donald Trump?
His impulsive personality was a danger
Why might rational leaders consider nuclear war?
Assumption enemy is preparing for war, assumption some nuclear war scenarios are better than others, assumption using nukes is still better than being invaded, need to defend your credibility
What is a nuclear crisis?
A standoff between two nuclear powered state
What are inherent risks with large organizations?
Goals and identities, reliance on routines, impact of politics on organizations
Why are militaries more interested in preventative nuclear war?
They see war as likely in the near term and inevitable in the long run, they have less inhibitions towards using violence, they are offensive minded, and they only focus on the war
How are large organizations in general prone to accident?
Objectives can trump safety, complex procedures, denial, deflect blame and minimize problems, and political leaders are often unaware of what they do
How is the risk of accidents higher in developing countries?
They have insufficient resources, privilege opacity, have limited experience with nukes, and often have domestic instability
What are the six ways nukes can impact a states policy?
More aggressive policies, more ambitious policies, more independence from a powerful ally, nurture an alliance at a lesser cost, more resistance in nuclear crises, and better ability to compromise
What does it mean to have a more aggressive policy?
More conventional forces deployed, more belligerent rhetoric, greater tolerance for escalation
What does it mean to have a more ambitious policy?
Forge new alliances and make new commitments
What is an example of a more ambitious policy made?
The US making long term security commitments in Western Europe
What does it mean to have more independence from a powerful ally?
Less consultations with the ally, less concessions with the ally, growing readiness to challenge the ally’s domination
What is an example of a state becoming more independent from an ally?
France withdrawing from NATO integrated command structure in 1996
How can nukes nurture an alliance at a lesser cost?
It is less expensive than deploying massive troop numbers
What is an example of nukes nurturing an alliance?
China providing a bomb design for Pakistan
How can nukes lead to more resistance during nuclear crises?
If you have nukes, you can defend your interests more staunchly during a crisis
What is an example of nukes leading to more resistance during a crisis?
During India-Pakistan crises, Pakistan could resist India’s pressures for much longer
How do nukes lead to a better ability to compromise?
Nukes make you feel secure and bolster your self-esteem, so they may make you more willing to compromise
How did developing the nuke change the British policy?
Britain was able to reduce its conventional power without losing credibility, they helped Britain bolster its junior allies, and emboldened them against the US
What is arms control?
Restrictions on the development/use of nukes and missiles
What is nonproliferation?
Efforts to stem the spread of nukes