Final Flashcards
Takings Rule Statement
A government taking typically arises under the police power which affords broad discretion to regulate health, safety, and the welfare of the people
A regulation is different from a taking
Exaction
The government may impose an exaction or demand in exchange for a benefit conferred by the government
(think the Gov is requiring a developer to give land for a new park)
Exaction Elements
- essential nexus between public need and proposed exaction
- benefit of demand is roughly proportional to the burden
If the government takes private property and transfers it to another private owner, what must the challenger prove?
Challenger must prove that the transfer is not rationally related to any conceivable public purpose
STEVE gets my land instead of me? HOW IS THAT related to any CONCEIVE (rhymes with Steve) public purpose??
Penn Central Factors to determine if a regulation is a taking
- economic impact on property owner
- interference with reasonable investment backed expectations
- character of regulation
“Does it benefit society?”
“Does is violate essential attributes of property ownership?”
A government regulation is a per-se taking when:
- permanent physical occupation
2. total loss of economic value
Which amendment contains the takings clause?
The 5th A
Liberty includes:
- freedom of action
- right to contract
- right to employment
Property Includes:
- legit claim
- entitlement
- benefits/public school
How much process?
- individual interest
- procedure
- government interest
Equal protection suspect class
Government must prove least restrictive means to achieve compelling
Equal protection quasi-suspect
Government must prove substantial related to important
How can the government regulate in public and designated forums?
Time, place, manner IF
Content neutral
Narrowly tailored important government interest
Leave open alternative channels
How can the government regulate in limited and non-public forums?
- View point neutral
2. Reasonably related to legit gov.
Content Neutral: Intermediate
Content-Neutral Regulation: Symbolic Speech/Expressive Conduct
- Advance important interest
- Unrelated to suppression of speech
- Narrowly tailored to further those interests
(ie The freedom of speech can extend to symbolic acts or expressive conduct undertaken to communicate an idea, although the government may regulate such conduct if the regulation is narrowly tailored to an important government interest, and is unrelated to the suppression of ideas.)
Speech and Conduct Initial Rule Statement
Presumptively unconstitutional to place burdens on speech because of its content (except unprotected speech)
Lemon Test
- If the government action doesn’t involve a sect preference, valid under establishment clause if secular purpose
- Has a primary effect that neither advance or inhibits religion
- Does not produce excessive government entanglement with religion
Can the government deny benefits or impose a restriction on someone based on their religious beliefs?
Technically, yes, if there is a compelling interest. However, the Supreme Court has never found an interest so compelling that it justifies such action
The government cannot require employees to take a religious oath, states may not exclude clerics from holding public office, and courts may not declare a religious belief to be false. What clause is this?
Free exercise clause.
10th A
Fed virtually unlimited power to regulate. Congress may regulate states so long as exercising enumerated power
Dormant CC
States may not discriminate against interstate commerce unless necessary compelling and no reasonable non-discriminatory alternative
Under Dormant CC, what if the state action is non-discriminatory on its face but yet still burdens interstate commerce?
Valid only if important state interest unreasonable burden on commerce
Under Dormant CC, what if state action operates as a tariff or trade barrier?
Unconstitutional per-se
When does SCOTUS have original jx?
- when a state is a party
2. ambassador, public ministers, and consuls
Enumerated Powers Rules Statement
Congress can exercise those powers enumerated in the constitution plus powers necessary proper to carry out the powers vested in the government
Taxing and Spending Rules Statement
Most taxes will be upheld if the Congress has power to regulate the activity OR reasonably relationship to revenue production
Commerce
Channels
Instrumentalities
Activities with sub-effect on interstate
How can you tell if an activities have a sub-effect on interstate?
Economic or commercial AND rational basis that aggregate affect interstate commerce
Civil Rights
13, 14, 15 A’s
When may Congress delegate legislative power?
If “intelligible” standard and not exclusively a power of Congress
Schools that open facilities to religious speech
SCOTUS has held that schools that open facilities to religious speech under a CONTENT NEUTRAL policy do not violate establishment
Invasion of Privacy
Public dissemination of truthful private information that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person and not newsworthy
Actual Malice “Defamation”
Reckless disregard for the truth or knowledge of falsity
Heightened Intermediate EP Scrutiny
Sub related important AND exceedingly persuasive
Private Actors = Gov.
Traditional
Exclusive
-OR-
Significant Entanglement between state and private actors
Accessions
Physically united BUT with separate identities (ex. GPS)
After acquired clause + attachment
After acquired clause = automatic attachment unless consumer goods after 10 days
PMSI Equipment
Automatic perfection but then must file within 20 days
Small scale assignment of accounts receivable
Automatically perfects
PMSI Inventory
Automatic perfection but must file by the time the debtor has possession of inventory and give notice to 3P
Deposit Account
Only perfected by control
Security Interest from Proceeds
Automatic perfection but only for 20 days
Exception where the security interests in proceeds remains perfected beyond 20 days
- cash proceeds
- financing statement in same office
- “all of debtors property”
When do you need to re-perfect?
- 20 days after delivery of goods
- after 5 years
- if debtors moves within 4 months
- if collateral moves 1 year
BIOC takes free
- merchant
- good faith
- without knowledge
Perfect v. Lien
Perfect wins
Whole v. Accession
Whole wins
Mortgage v. Fixture where creditor did not perfect within 20 days
Mortgage wins
PMSI in Equipment if perfected within 20 days of debtors possession v. After-acquired
PMSI wins
Rights of secured party
take back as long as no violence (breach of peace) (trickery is ok)
Judicial writ ordering sheriff to get collateral
forclosure (with notice)
How to dispose of collateral
- via commercially reasonable sale
2. via public purchase
Rule statement for when you see an accession (like GPS installed into cars)
The issue is whether a security interest in goods continues after its installation into equipment that another creditor has a perfected interest in.
PMSI definition/ rule statement
A purchase money security interest (PMSI) arises when a creditor extends value to the debtor for the purpose of enabling the debtor to acquire rights in the collateral.
Filing a financing statement with the trade name
a filing in the debtor’s trade name instead of its corporate name is not effective unless the trade name is so similar that is is not seriously misleading
the buyer of consumer goods in a consumer-to-consumer transaction
takes free of a security interest if the buyer buys without knowledge of the security interest before the creditor files a financial statement.
identifiable cash proceeds.
cash, checks, and deposit accounts
what do you file to transform a GP to an LLP
file a “qualification” with the appropriate state office
Dissociation
RUPA 2013 - need to give notice, but it does not need to be in writing.
Winding up
assets distributed
liability paid
business settled
duties owed during winding up and dissolution process
still owe fiduciary duties (care, loyalty, and good faith and fair dealing) but no longer owe a duty not to compete
solutions for a breach in a partnership
direct action
demand accounting
is there a right to sunlight, fresh air, or view
no!
“don’t record this until later”
irrelevant– deed is still delivered
When can a private person sue for a public nuisance?
Typically public nuisance claims are brought by the government, but a private person can sue for a public nuisance if they sustain harm that is different from the public at large.
Public nuisance is one that interferes with health, safety, or convenience of the public at large.
“buzz words” for private nuisance
interfered with reasonable use and enjoyment of property
“coming to the nuisance”
would only work if came, without good faith, for purpose of litigating the nuisance
how to convey a deed
- intent to convey - delivery of the deed. So therefore, just destroying or ripping up the deed will not mean that it was not delivered.
are juries of 6 allowed?
yes, but must be unanimous
Conflict of laws: A federal court exercising ____ jurisdiction over ____ claims must apply the conflict of laws approach of ____
A federal court exercising diversity jx over non-federal claims must apply the conflict of laws approach of the state in which it sits
Are decisions from foreign courts given FFC?
No - but they may be recognized. Ct will look at whether the court had jx and if fair procedures were used.
Contract under the Most Significant Relationship test
think about buying a membership at a SPA that has unlimited milk chocolate -
subject matter of the contract
party location
acceptance of contract (location)
Torts Most Significant Relationship test
CRIPled by a candy bar.
Conduct location
Relationship location
Injury location
Party location
Basically, with the government interest test
court will look at its own forum laws and other forum laws and determine if the Gov has a legitimate interest in applying one of those two
Requirments to remove a case from state to fed
D must file notice of removal in fed court for the district in which the state action is pending within 30 days of the D receipt of complaint.
Must be signed
must include a statement for the basis of the federal jurisdiction
Most important thing to remember about removal
Removal is not properly if the D is a citizen of the forum state and the case is based on diversity
Create a trust
SPITball
Settlor with capacity to convey
Present intent to create a trust
Trustee with duties
Beneficiary is definite (identified by name OR sufficiently describes how beneficiaries will be ascertained) (sole trustee cannot be sole beneficiary)
In contrast, a beneficiary may serve as trustee as long as the SOLE beneficiary is not the SOLE trustee (so this would be fine: A woman purported to create a trust, naming her niece and nephew as beneficiaries and her niece as the sole trustee.)
To be extra fancy, when the sole B is the sole T, you can call it the “doctrine of merger” because the unity has merged.
(And also a trust must have a valid purpose (not contrary to public policy)
Can a trust be created without a writing?
yes, as long as it is clear and convincing
Per Capita
equal between grandchildren
4 exceptions to things that are not “adjudications on the merits”
- Dismissal for lack of jx
- Dismissal for improper venue
- Dismissal for failure to join a party
- Dismissal without prejudice
What does it mean to say that the power of Congress is remedial?
Any exercise of the enforcement power must be congruent and proportional to the violation it is addressing. Congress may not legislate to prohibit constitutional behavior where there is no constitutional injury to be prevented or remedied.
Comandeer
Congress may not commander or require states to adopt or enforce a federal program
or requires states to govern in a certain way
Overbreadth
If a law is facially overbroad, it will be invalidated. A law is overbroad if it regulates speech that the Constitution allows and as well as unprotected speech at the same time.
Vagueness
If a law is facially vague, it will be invalidated. A law is vague if a reasonable person cannot tell what speech is prohibited and what is allowed.