Family Law Flashcards
Breach of the Promise to Marry
Claim + damages (tort damages) incl. actual damages (money spent in preparation of marriage) as well as loss to reputation, injury to health, mental anguish. Punitive damages also available
Abolished in most states.
Gifts in Contemplation of Marriage
Gifts made before marriage on the condition of the subsequent marriage are NULL if the marriage fails to take place. Consider the type of property given, conditions attached, and the intent of the donor
Antenuptial (Premarital) Agreements
Governed by the UPAA. Rights of the parties in the event of death or divorce. Can agree to disposition of property at divorce and alimony (unless waiver would result in one party becoming a public charge). Cannot be bound re: custody/child support.
If a marriage is found to be void, premarital agreement is enforceable only to the extent necessary to avoid an inequitable result.
3 Requirements for Validity of Antenuptial Agreements
(1) in writing and signed (2) entered into voluntarily (no fraud, duress, overreaching), (3) full disclosure of assets OR proof party had independent knowledge. UPAA threshold consideration: was contract unconscionable when executed? Also consider waiver. May consider FAIRNESS and INDEPENDENT COUNSEL . Can agree on state law/law of state w/ significant connections OR where agreement was executed
Marriage Requirements (4)
(1) License (medical certificate, 72 hour waiting period–> these defects will not invalidate),
(2) Authorized officiant,
(3) No legal impediments to marriage (not too closely related, no bigamy),
(4) capacity to consent (under the influence, handicapped, age)
Common Law Marriage Requirements (3)
(1) Consent to marry (not just cohabit). Need capacity and no legal impediments.
(2) Cohabitation
(3) Holding yourself out publicly as husband and wife.
States that do not permit common law marriage will recognize common law marriages from other states.
Marriage By Estoppel/Putative Marriage
Equitable remedy given by courts to innocent who acted in good faith when entering into an invalid marriage.
In some states, putative spouse can acquire all of the rights of a legal spouse.
Rights and Responsibilities Among Spouses: Property
Each spouse owns and controls his own property but in the event of a divorce, title is not dispositive.
If title to real estate: joint tenancy by the entireties is presumed, and one spouse cannot convey or encumber without consent of other spouse.
Rights and Responsibilities Among Spouses: Support
During marriage, spouses owe support to one another.
Doctrine of necessaries can be used to make one spouse liable to 3d parties for other spouse’s purchases for necessary expenses.
Principles of agency may require that one spouse be held liable to third party for the other spouse’s authorized purchases.
Rights and Responsibilities Among Spouses: Spousal Abuse Orders
Protect victims of domestic abuse.
Victim entitled to a protective order against the other spouse which can be granted ex parte and can last for 1 month to several years.
Rights and Responsibilities Among Spouses: Tortious Interference with Marriage
Claims against 3rd parties for interference with marriage:
(1) Alienation of Affection
(2) Criminal Conversation
Alienation of Affection (3 Elements)
(1) Genuine love and affection between spouses
(2) Love and affection alienated and destroyed
(3) Defendant’s acts caused the loss of love and affection.
Adultery is NOT a requirement
Proof of damages required and highly subjective. Punitive damages may be permitted
Abolished in most states.
Criminal Conversation (3 Elements)
(1) Marriage of the spouses
(2) Adultery between the defendant and the spouse during the marriage
(3) Damages are the same as alienation claim (required and highly subjective. Punitive damages may be permitted).
Abolished in most states.
Annulment
Declaration that marriage is invalid.
Available for defective marriages that are legally void or voidable.
Void Marriage
Fail to meet essential requirements, so invalid (“utter nullity”).
Can be attacked by one of parties or collaterally by a third party even after the death of one of the parties.
May or may not be remedied by continued habitation after removal of impediment (e.g. bigamy– may be remedied upon death/divorce of spouse; too closely related may not be remedied).
If marriage is found void, premarital agreement enforceable only to extent necessary to avoid inequitable result.
Parties may walk away without a court order; annulment action usually brought to determine property distribution and child support.
Voidable Marriage
Event or condition affecting adequacy of consent to marriage contract.
Treated as valid until annulled.
Can be attacked only by or on behalf of a party to the marriage, and in some cases only by the party who sought to be protected. If ratification occurs or one spouse dies, marriage can no longer be invalidated.
Can be ratified by continued cohabitation after removal of infirmity.
Examples: nonage, incurable physical impotence, lack of capacity, duress, fraud
Presumption of validity of marriage
States generally presume that the most recent marriage is valid and a party must overcome the presumption by strong evidence that the prior marriage subsists.
5 Effects of Annulment
(1) Marriage is set aside as if it never existed
(2) Children remain legitimate
(3) Child support can be awarded
(4) Spousal support may be awarded, but not in all states
(5) Property generally treated as if never married: put spouses in “pre-marital” state
Divorce and Separation: Jurisdiction
ONE of the spouses must be domiciled in the state seeking to enter divorce.
Generally, residency in a state for a minimum period of time (90 days to 6 months), then there is a presumption she is domiciled there and the court will have jurisdiction.
For financial issues (property rights and support) court must have personal jurisdiction.
NOTE: more than one state may have jurisdiction!
5 Grounds for Fault-based Divorce
(1) Adultery
Often proved thru circumstantial evidence of opportunity and inclination
Corroboration often required
(2) Desertion for a specified time.
Unjustifiable departure from marital home with no intent to return.
(3) Cruelty (physical/mental)
(4) Habitual drunkenness/drug use commencing after marriage
(5) Insanity
May require institutionalization
No-Fault Divorce
Allows for dissolution of marriage w/o regard to marital fault.
Generally, can be allowed on proof of:
-irreconcilable differences (may require agreement of spouses)
-living separate and apart for specified time period (if spouses agree, the period may be shorter; if unilateral, period may be longer)
Incompatibility
Defense to No-Fault Divorce
Reconciliation
4 Defenses for Fault-Based Grounds for Divorce
(1) Collusion: parties agreed to simulate grounds for divorce
(2) Connivance: π willingly consented to other spouse’s misconduct
(3) Condonation/forgiveness: π forgave marital offense w/ full knowledge of offense.
(4) Recrimination (doctrine of unclean hands): π also guilty of marital fault
Legal Separation
Often permitted for same grounds as divorce. AKA “divorce from bed and board.”