Family Law Flashcards
breach of promise to marry
Kind of a hybrid between a contract and tort cause of action. Elements:
1. promise to marry
2. breach
3. damages (including actual damages (for example, money already spent on the wedding) and damages for loss of reputation, mental anguish, and injury to health. Punitive damages may be available.)
does donee have a right to a gift made in contemplation of marriage?
Yes. Engagement ring is the main example. Must be made in contemplation.
antenuptual (premarital) agreements
Content
* Can cover disposition of property, choise of law, etc. unreasonable provisions might not be enforced.
* Can cover alimony but court may find provision unenforcable if disadvantaged spouse is a public charge.
* Child custody and support provisions are unenforceable.
Requirements
* must be in writing and signed
* must be entered into voluntarily (look out for night before duress)
* there must be fair and full disclosure of the parties’ assets.
What are the requirements for marriage?
1) License
* minority : communiciable disease certificate
* majority: waiting period.
2) Ceremony with authorized officiant
3) No legal impediments
* not too closely related. (no ascendants, descendents, siblings [including half-sibilings], aunt/uncle, niece/nephew. first cousins sometimes ok)
* no prior undissolved marriage
4) capacity to consent at the time of ceremony.
* intoxication.
* 18 is age of majority. 16+ with parental consent. 15- judicial consent.
- procedural failure does not inalidate
What are the requirements for common law marriage?
- Consent to marry, which includes having capacity and a lack of legal impediments
- Cohabitation
- The couple holding themselves out publicly as spouses
Abolished in most states but full faith and credit applies.
Marriage by estoppel
A good faith spouse of a prior married person may aquire legal rights.
Propery in marriage
- If spouses take title to real estate jointly, a tenancy by the entirety is presumptively created.
- Most property acquired during marriage is marital property no matter how titled. court has discretion to distribute.
The doctrine of necessaries
One spouse may be liable to third parties for the other spouse’s purchases for necessary expenses, such as food, clothing, and health care.
spousal abuse orders
- All states allow protective orders against violent spouse.
- May be ex parte and can last from one month to several years by state.
tortuous interference with marriage for alienation of affecition
A claim against a third party for alienation of affection. Elements:
1. Genuine love between validly married spouses
2. Evidence that love or affection was aliented
3. The defendant’s actions caused the loss of love and affection.
4. Damages
Adultery is not required! Can be someone turning one spouse against another
tortuous interference with marriage for “criminal conversation”
A claim against a third party for adultery with the plaintiff’s spouse. Elements:
1. valid marriage
2. adultery
Constitutional privacy rights
The following rights fall within the constitutionally protected right to privacy under the due process clause of the 5th amendment:
* The right to marry
* The right to procreate
* The right to use or sell contraceptives
* The right of related persons to live together
* The right of parents to educate their children outside the public schools
* The right of parents to decide issues concerning the care, custody, and control of their children
Annulment
- Declares a marriage invalid if void or voidable.
- Marriage set aside as never existing
- Children are still considered married children.
- Generally spousal support is not awarded in annulment actions
Annullment for void marriage
- There is no marriage at all.
- Essential requirement of marriage missing.
- Cannot be ratified
- Annulment brought to determine property distribution and child custody.
- Can be brought by third parties (IRS, insurance companies)
Void marriages inlcude:
* bigamy
* consanguity
Exceptions
* Some state statutes provide that the marriage becomes valid if the parties continue to cohabit after impediment removed
* States generally presume that the most recent marriage is valid, and a party must overcome the presumption by strong evidence that the prior marriage subsists.
* A bigamous marriage might become valid if former spouse dies.
Annullment for voidable marriage
- Valid until declaired null.
- An imediment may allow one of the spouses to bring an anullment action.
- No third party action.
- Can be ratified after impediment removal by continued cohabitation.
Voidable marriages include:
* invalid consent
* Nonage
* incurable physical impotence.
* duress
* fraud on essential element of marriage (ex. misrepresentation of fertility)
Which state has jurisdiction over divorce
- One spouse has to be domiciled for a minimum period (at least 90 days)
- Two states can have jurisdiction. The one that renders judgement first causes the other to lose SMJ for mootness.
- For jurisdiction over financial aspects of divorce the court will need personal jursidiction over the defendant.
Divorce Grounds - No Fault Divorce
- Allow spouses to get a divorce without need to assert marital fault.
3 types: - Irreconcialable difference - bilateral consent
- incompatibility - bilateral consent
- Spouses living apart for statutory period - unilateral - reconciliaition defense (resets statutory period)
Divorce Grounds - Fault grounds
Typical grounds:
* Adultery - circumstantial evidence of opportunity and inclination. Corroboration usually required.
* Willful and unjustified desertion (or abandonment) for statutory time period.
* Extreme physical or mental cruelty
* drug addiction or habitual drunkenness commencing after the marriage.
* Insantiy
Defenses
* Collusion (no real adultery)
* Connivance (swingers can’t sue on adultery)
* Condonation (knowledge of adultery and forgiveness).
* Recrimination (unclean hands with adultery)
What is “legal separation”
- Does not terminate the marriage, but the parties can have all of their rights regarding property, spousal support, custody, and child support adjudicated in this proceeding.
- Often used for religious reasons or by older people.
Two step process for property division
- Classification - marital property or separate property?
- Division - how to divide marital estate (title doesn’t matter)
What is equitable division of marital property?
- court have the autority to order an equitible distribution of all marital property, no matter how title is held.
- The majority approach to property division. Each spouse takes their separate property, and the court only divides the property acquired during the marriage.
What is considered separate property?
Separate property inlcudes:
* Property owned before marriage
* Property acquired by gift or inheritance
* Property acquired in exchange for separate property
* Income from and appreciation of separate property (unless improved)
* Pain and suffering awards
* Personal damages awards
* Any property acquired after an order of legal separation that includes a final disposition of property
What is considered marital property?
Marital property inlcudes all other property acquired during the marriage. Marital property is subject to equitable distribution by the court.
Includes:
* Property acquired during the marriage
* Earnings - even if only made by one spouse
* Employment benefits, pensions, and stock options (even if they will not be exercised or vested until after the divorce)
* Lost wages awards
* Reimbursement for medical bills incurred and paid with marital property
* Recovery for damages to marital property
Some jurisdictions use the date of separation as the end of the marital estate, and others use the date of filing for divorce.
Methods by which separate property becomes marital property
Comingling - The separate property is inextricably intertwined with marital property or with the separate property of the other spouse and cannot be traced by the court. (bank account)
Transmutation - The separate property is treated in a way that evidences an intention for the property to be marital property (for example, placing separate property in the names of both spouses)
Improvement of separate property during marriage
When separate property is improved by the use of marital funds or the effort of a spouse, courts generally hold that the property remains separate property, but most jurisdictions grant the marital estate or the nonowning spouse reimbursement for the value added to the separate property.
Property Acquired Before Marriage But Paid for After
Majority - Property Acquired Before Marriage But Paid for After should be apportioned between separate and marital estates in proportion to the contribution of separate and marital funds to pay for the property. (such as a house mortgage). Initial buyer keeps property but has to reimburse other spouse for value of their share of input during marriage.
Lots of state variation
Treatment of pensions earned during marriage
- The portion of a pension earned during a marriage is marital property subject to distribution.
- Some courts will give the non-earning spouse other funds from the marital estate to offset the amount of the pension plan.
- Often one of the most valuble parts of a marital estate.
Professional License or Degree and Alimony
Some jurisdictions use alimony to compensate supporting spouses for their contribution during the other spouse’s education or training.
Is property division or alimony a taxable event?
Neither, but alimony was before 2019.
How does the court make an equitable division of a martial estate?
The factors considered in dividing the property usually include:
* The age, education, background, and earning capabilities of both parties
* The duration of the marriage, and whether there were any prior marriages
* The standard of living during the marriage
* The present incomes of both parties, their vocational skills, and employability
* The source of the money used to purchase the property
* The** health** of the parties
* The assets, debts, and liabilities of the parties
* The needs of the parties
* The child custody provisions
* Whether the distribution is in addition to, or in lieu of, alimony
* Each party’s opportunity to acquire future income and assets
* Each party’s contribution to the acquisition or enhancement of the existing marital assets (not necessarily earning - homemaking also)
* Each party’s contribution as a homemaker to the family unit
* Economic fault (that is, whether either party has dissipated marital property such as gambling or use on an illicit lover)
Notes
* Court have great discretion. Focus on your analysis rather than the conclusion.
* Equitable division is not modifiable.
* Courts can divide in kind or by contribution
* Martial fault not relevant for property division but IS relevant for Alimony
What is alimony?
Alimony (also known as spousal support or maintenance) is paid to an economically dependent spouse.
There are four types of alimony:
* Permanent Periodic Spousal Support
* Lump Sum
* Rehabilitative Spousal Support
* Reimbursement Spousal Support