Family Law Flashcards
Valid marriage
- Consent—both parties agree
- Capacity—parties are legally capable of consent
-
Compliance with legal formalities
-
License
- Age—meet minimum age (usually 18 years old) or have parental consent
- Waiting period between the license and ceremony
- Premarital medical testing required by some states but results cannot block issuance
- Ceremony—most require solemnization by an officiant with two witnesses present
-
License
Note: Same-sex couples may marry in all states; all states and federal government must recognize an out-of-state same-sex couple due to FFCC
Common law marriage
Marriage without a ceremony and/or license
- Consent—both parties must agree they are married
- Capacity—both parties must have the capacity to consent (i.e., old enough and not too closely related)
- Present intent to be married
- Cohabitation—both parties must live together as married spouses
- Holding out—both parties must hold themselves out as married in public
Note: relatively few states will grant a common law marriage, but almost all states will recognize a common law marriage validly entered into elsewhere
Annulment
Voids a marriage as if it was never validly formed.
-
Property distribution:
- A party seeking annulment may request an equitable distribution of property and in some states, spousal support;
- Once completed, the property distribution may not be modified
Void marriages
Marriage null from its inception due to specific grounds
- Bigamy: Enoch Arden statute can make the marriage voidable if the parties in good faith but incorrectly believed the previous spouse died, so long as any additional requirements (e.g., divorce) are met
- Incest or consanguinity
- Incapacity
Voidable marriage
A marriage that is valid until declared void after a challenge by one of the spouses
- Grounds: underage, impotence, intoxication, fraud or duress, lack of intent, or bigamy based upon error about death
- Validation: voidable marriages can be validated once the impediment is removed (e.g., underage spouse stays in marriage after reaching age of consent) or ratified (e.g., marriage is consummated despite lack of intent)
Separation Agreement
An agreement made while planning for divorce
- Contract principles apply; consideration is provided by the mutual promises
- Enforceable so long as not unconscionable or based on fraud
- Merges with the divorce decree
Limited divorce
AKA “divorce from bed and board”
- Recognized in most states but rarely used (usually for religious reasons)
- Parties live apart and remain legally married but the court can resolve support and property issues
Divorce
A decree that terminates a marriage relationship
- No-fault divorce
- Fault grounds
Faults for divorce
Traditionally, the only way to get divorced was to plead fault by spouse.
-
Grounds: Adultery, cruelty, desertion (abandonment), habitual drunkenness,
bigamy, imprisonment, indignity, institutionalization - Defenses include recrimination, unclean hands, connivance (consent to the marital wrong), condonation, collusion, provocation, insanity, consent, justification
Note: marital fault is usually irrelevant for division of property and child custody arrangements (exception: marital fault entailed significant economic impact (e.g., gave gifts to a mistress)
No-fault divorce
- More common justification for divorce today (issued in all states)
Jurisdictional issues (divorce)
- In order for a state to grant a divorce, at least one of the parties must be a resident of the state
- Divorce decree will be given FFC in other states, so long as state that issued decree had proper jurisdiction
-
Divisible divorce: when a court has PJ over only one spouse
- That court can issue a divorce decree (subject to FFC)
- Court will lack jurisdiction over property, support, and custody issues
Prenuptual (premarital) agreements
-
Applicable law: Uniform Premarital Agreement Act (UPAA) followed by many states
- To resolve a conflict of laws regarding enforceability, apply the law of the state with the most significant relationship to the agreement and subsequent marriage
-
Enforceability:
- Full and fair disclosure of the assets and obligations (if not, argue unconscionability)
-
Terms are fair and reasonable considering the wealth, age, and health of the parties;
- Modern courts will generally find terms fair so long as agreement will not leave a spouse dependent upon public assistance
-
Voluntary (e.g., no fraud, duress, or undue influence).
- Consider: time pressure to sign the agreement, prior business experience, and opportunity to consult independent counsel
- Modification: The parties may include a clause to prevent modification of the agreement, but a court may always modify child support provisions
Separation/Settlement Agreements
Parties define property, custody, and support issues pending divorce. Type of agreement depends upon state law and the length of the separation.
- Enforceability: same as prenuptual (full and fair disclosure, reasonable terms, voluntary)
- Modification: as with prenuptual agreement, provisions related to child support and custody are modifiable by the court if the terms are not in the best interests of the child
-
Merger: the agreement will generally merge into the divorce decree
- If not, enforcement will be through contract law rather than judgment enforcement
Jurisdictional requirements for division of marital property
- SMJ and PJ over both spouses
- SMJ usually requires residency in the state
Theories of property division
- Equitable distribution (majority approach)
- Community property (minority approach)
Community property approach
Minority approach to division of assets at divorce (c.f. equitable distribution)
- Community property is split 50/50 and presumed to include all property acquired during marriage, including earnings of a spouse
Equitable distribution approach
Majority approach to division of property at divorce. Divides property “equitably,” but not necessarily “equally” (i.e., 50/50).
-
Factors affecting distribution include:
- Length of the marriage
- Health/age/income of the spouses
- Contributions to education/child-rearing
- Future needs
Education - Non-marital assets
- Child custody
- Spousal support, and standard of living
Marital property and exceptions
Generally refers to any property acquired during the marriage and before the date of the final divorce degree.
-
Exceptions:
- Property acquired by gift or inheritance (except gifts between spouses)
- Property excluded pursuant to a valid agreement (prenup or separation agreement)
- Property that a party has sold/granted/conveyed for value in good faith before separation
- Property that was mortgaged or encumbered in good faith before final separation
- An award or settlement payment that was received for any cause that accrued prior to marriage
Note: the party seeking to exclude as separate property bears the burden of showing that property is not marital
Modification of a property division decree
Not allowed for changed circumstances, and can only be set aside based on grounds such as fraud.
Governing federal acts
- UPAA: prenups
- UIFSA: child support
- UCCJEA: child custody modification
- UPA: assisted reproduction