Criminal Law Flashcards
Required components of a crime
- Act (actus reus)
- State of mind (mens rea)
- Causation of the unlawful result
Mens rea standards
- Specific intent: intent to accomplish a particular result (e.g., to permanently deprive)
- General intent: intent to perform the unlawful act
- Malice: reckless disregard of the high probability of harm
- Strict liability: no state of mind required; act alone will suffice
- Transferred intent: intent to harm one victim can transfer to unintended victim (or unintended crime)
Accomplice definition and liability
- One who acts with the requisite mens rea to aid the principal before or during commission of the crime
-
Liability: planned and foreseeable crimes
- Principal need not be convicted
- Defense: withdrawal
Accessory
- One who acts with intent to assist the principal to avoid apprehension after a felony is complete
- Liability: is for a separate crime (e.g., obstruction of justice) but not the principal’s crime
Merger (criminal law)
Lesser included/inchoate crimes “merge” into more severe/completed crimes. Cannot be convicted of both inchoate and completed crime
- Includes solicitation, attempt
- Does not include conspiracy
Solicitation
To invite or urge another to commit a crime with the intent that the party do so. No return agreement is required.
Defense: renunciation if D prevents the commission of a crime
Withdrawal (conspiracy)
- Common law: cannot withdraw, because crime is committed the moment agreement is made
-
MPC:
- Before an overt act: communicate intention to withdraw with co-conspirators OR inform law enforcement
- After overt act: help thwart success of conspiracy
- Even if D cannot withdraw, he may limit his liability for substantive crimes by informing other conspirators of withdrawal or timely advising legal authorities
Attempt
Specific intent to commit a crime + completion of a substantial step
Defense: legal impossibility; no specific intent
Conspiracy
-
Elements:
- Agreement (express or implied) between two or more persons
- MPC: unilateral conspiracy will suffice
- Intent to achieve unlawful purpose
- Overt act in furtherance of the crime
- Agreement (express or implied) between two or more persons
- Defense: withdrawal
- Liability: for any foreseeable crimes committed in furtherance of the conspiracy
Relationships with co-conspirators
-
Chain conspiracy:
- Co-conspirators are engaged in an enterprise of many steps
- Each participant is liable for the substantive crimes of his co-conspirators
- e.g., drug distribution (everyone knows that there is a manufacturer, distributor, dealer)
-
Hub and spoke:
- Involves many people dealing with a central hub
- Participants are not liable for the substantive crimes of their co-conspirators because each spoke is treated as a separate agreement rather than one larger general agreement
- e.g., A pawn shop operates as a “fence” to sell stolen goods; each robber is responsible for conspiracy to sell stolen property, but not for the goods from other robbers.
Homicide
The killing of a living human being by another
-
Murder: unlawful killing with malice
- First-degree murder: deliberate, pre-meditated (specific intent)
- Second-degree/Common law: with malice (intent to kill, do serious bodily injury, or with reckless indifference to human life
- Felony murder: death that occurs during the commission or attempted commission of a violent felony
-
Manslaughter: unlawful killing without malice
- Voluntary: intentional killing resulting from adequate provocation
- Involuntary: unintentional killing caused by recklessness
Malice
- Intent to kill
- Intent to do serious bodily harm
- Reckless indifference to human life (depraved heart)
- Intent to commit a violent (BARRK) felony
Heat of passion
- Would provoke reasonable person and with no chance to cool off
- Provocation must cause fatal act; imperfect self-defense qualifies to mitigate murder to voluntary manslaughter
- Hearing about a spouse’s affair usually won’t suffice, but walking in will
Felony murder
- An unintended but foreseeable death caused by and occurring during the course of a dangerous or enumerated felony
-
Dangerous felonies (BARRK)
- Burglary
- Arson
- Rape
- Robbery
- Kidnapping
- Enumerated felony: one set out in state statute
- Note: death occurring during a felony other than a felony qualifying for FMR may be classified as second-degree murder or misdemeanor manslaughter
-
Dangerous felonies (BARRK)
Felony murder liability
-
D will be liable for deaths of
- Someone who resists the felony
- Bystanders killed during felony
- Third person killed by resister or police officers (minority rule)
-
D will not be liable for deaths of
- Co-felons killed by resister or police officers
Defenses to felony murder
- Defense to underlying felony
- Felony was not independent of killing (e.g., aggravated battery)
- Death was not foreseeable (no proximate cause)
- Death occurred after the felony was complete and D reached a point of safety
Battery
- Unlawful application of force
- To another
- That causes harmful or offensive touching
Assault
- Attempted battery,
OR
- Intentionally placing one
- In apprehension of
- Imminent bodily harm