Factors Affecting EWT: Misleading Information Flashcards
Define EWT
Evidence given to police
By one who witnessed crime or accident
Define misleading info
Incorrect info ginen to EWT after event
= gives wrong impression
May be in post event discussion (PED)
OR leading qus
What is a leading Qu
Qu which as phrased=
Suggests certain answer
Post Event Discussion ( PED )
= when x2 or more witness to event
May discuss what seen
May influence accuracy of eachothers recall
Explain Loftus x Plamer 1st study
1974
45 us students= 5groups of 9
= all saw vid of car crash
Verb used on speed = manipulated
Smashed
Collided
Hit
Bumped
Contacted
Smashed= estimate 40.8 mph
Contacted= 31.8 mph
F= speed affected by verb
A single word FX EWT accuracy
Explain Loftus x Plamer 2nd Study
On FX of leading QUS on later mem
150 students, 3 groups
All= vid of car crash + questionnaire
= asked how fast when…
1= smashed
2= hit
3= no speed Qu
1 week later asked if seen broken glass
(There was none)
Verb= distorted mem of OG event 1 week later= power of lead Qus
Explain the:
1)Response Bias x
2)Substitution Explanation
1) wording dosent FX Real mems, just how they decide to answer
2) wording changes PPTS memory
Explain Gabbert et al study 2003
A: FX of PED on EWT
P: 60 students, 60 adults
See vid of gurl stealing money
Filmed at diff points
Either indiv or in group
Co- witnesses told seen same vid= not true. They discussed
F: 71% co-witness group= recall info not seen. Without= no unseen info.
C: highlights issue of PED + effect on EWT accuracy