EXAM 4 FLASHCARDS
How is sexual selection different from natural selection? How is it similar?
Similar: sexual selection is a special case of natural selection where both selection favor traits that help increase the reproductive fitness of the individual
Different: Natural selection focuses more on traits that enhance the survival of the individual while sexual selection focuses more on the ability to attract mates and increase reproductive fitness.
male reproductive success is usually limited by availability of few eggs what is the 1ST HYPOTHESIS on how this changes male and female reproductive strategies?
Hypothesis 1: Most often, Males will COMPETE for females
- Eggs are limited
- Sperm is NOT limited
- Males who mate with multiple females tend to have higher reproductive success because there is less limitation on the number of gametes that males produce
- Females ONLY produce CERTAIN number of gametes
- Males often compete for access to female
male reproductive success is usually limited by availability of few eggs what is the 2ND HYPOTHESIS on how this changes male and female reproductive strategies?
Hypothesis 2: Male reproductive success more strongly tied to NUMBER OF MATES than female reproductive success
- Males having more mates = more reproductive success
- Females having more mates = do NOT result in more reproductive success
What is an example of the 2nd hypothesis discussed in lecture
1948 study on Drosophila
Bateman principle = relates reproductive success to number of mates
- Variability in reproductive success is greater in males than in females (more mates for males = more offspring)
- Variability in number of mates is greater in males than in females
- Sexual selection is often more intense in males (resulting in secondary sex characteristic, often time being more elaborate and more selective in males
- Females use more energy in order to produce and care for offspring than males
male reproductive success is usually limited by availability of few eggs what is the 3RD HYPOTHESIS on how this changes male and female reproductive strategies?
Hypothesis 3: Females tend to be the “choosy sex”
- Eggs are expensive to produce
- Eggs require more energy to produce than sperm
- Females are under selection to CHOOSE GOOD MATE so resources to produce (and develop and rear, in some cases) aren’t WASTED
- Form of “intersexual selection”
T/F: Females are always the choosy sex (if false give an example)
FALSE
Sygnathidae: seahorses, pipefishes, sea dragons
1. Males may incubate developing embryos one eggs are fertilized
2. Males are the choosy sex in this case because they put in the energy into rearing the offspring (don’t want to waste their time)
what is the difference between intersexual selection and intrasexual selection
- Intersexual selection occurs when individuals of one sex (usually females) choose mates of opposite sex based on certain desirable traits.
- Traits that are attractive to the opposite sex are selected.
- EX: Bright plumage in birds, elaborate courtship displays, and complex mating calls.
- Intrasexual selection when members of the same sex (usually males) compete for mates
- Traits that enhance an individual’s ability to compete with others of the same sex are selected.
- EX: Large body size, antlers in deer, and aggressive behaviors.
what is REASON 1 for the explanations for female mate choice
Reason 1: Direct Benefits
- Females choose mates that provide something to increase their chances of mating success
- Protection from predators
- Increased parental care
- Access to food/nuptial gifts
- Access to better territory/resources
- Increased resources to females
what is are the 2 examples of direct benefits
- Male bush katydid provides nuptial gift to female (provides protein and lipid rich material for females to eat when delivering sperm to her)
- Male lions help rear young and protect females
what is REASON 2 for the explanations for female mate choice
Reason 2: Good genes
- Differences among males provide information to female about the genetic qualities that can be inherited by offspring
- Males display “honest advertisement” of good genes
what is an example of good genes hypothesis
EXAMPLE: PEACOCK EYE SPOTS
- Females prefer males with elaborate tails and large eye spots
- More elaborate tails and eye spots get larger = increased weight in male offspring chicks and higher survival rates in offspring
what is the handicap principle
traits that REDUCE SURVIVAL CHANCES (handicap/costly signals) are preferred by females because they indicate heritable viability (tradeoff)
- Trait is making it so hard for that male to survive that the fact he’s even here indicates he must be high quality
- Signals underlying health/strength viability
- “good genes” may be indicated by a costly trait
what is the first example of the handicap principle
EXAMPLES: PEACOCK FEATHER
- Longer and more elaborate tails cost more to make and maintain = less fitness cost for higher quality males (high quality males survive much better)
- Low quality male = high fitness cost as tail length increases (could potentially die)
what is the second example of the handicap principle
EXAMPLE 2: SWORDTAIL FISH
1. Females prefer males with longer sword
- Fitness cost for low quality males because they are going to struggle to survive with long sword making it more difficult to swim
- Males that do have long sword indicates “i’m very healthy, very viable, and i will provide those strong genes to your offspring” = high quality
“good genes” may be indicated by traits that signal ___________. give an example of this
Resistance to Disease
EXAMPLE: RED DISPLAY IN DIFF BIRDS (ZEBRA FINCHES)
reddish/orange coloration in the beaks of zebra finches conferred by carotenoid pigments which are found in the diet of the birds. Red coloration means that they were able to procure these foods. Birds with bright red displays must have a healthy immune system because they are able to “waste their red pigments on frivolous displays, and do NOT have to use it for the immune system”.
Carotenoid: plant pigments that can NOT be synthesized de novo in birds/animals
NOT just reddish/orange but helpful to the immune system (important for good immune function).
what is REASON 3 for the explanations for female mate choice
Reason 3: Fisherian Sexual Selection OR “Arbitrary Choice”
- Females prefer arbitrary trait that provides NO information about male’s quality
- Sexy Sons Hypothesis (1979) - females benefit from mating with males that have trait because they are more likely to produce sons with desired trait who will also be preferred and be more fit and then pass trait on and on
what is the Fisherian Runaway Sexual Selection
- Can occur when genetic correlation between preference for trait and trait is high
- Over generation, preferred trait becomes exaggerated (runaway)
- EX: sword in fish get longer and longer; peacock tails get bigger and brighter (exaggeration over time)
- Natural selection will curve when fitness cost outweighs benefit
- EX: Antlers on a deer can only get so large
what is sexual conflict
- “Sexually antagonistic coevolution”
- When males increase their reproductive success via an adaptation that is detrimental to females, there is selection for a counter-adaptation in females to regain lost fitness
- Traits can evolve in one sex that are detrimental to the other sex
what is the first example for sexual conflict
EXAMPLE: GERRIDAE (WATER STRIDERS)
1. Female: possess “genital shield” and spines around vulvar opening
- In order to mate with her male needs to get her to open shield
- Male: grasps female with spiky legs from above when attempting to mate and drums water which brings in predators. As predators come in, females are at high risk of being killed. Male will NOT let go until she is dead or allows him access to mate and copulate with her
what is the 2nd example of sexual conflict
EXAMPLE: ELASMOBRANCHS
1. Mating involves male biting and grasping pectoral fins of female (she gets injured)
- Females have relatively thicker skin than males
- Males have developed larger teeth than females
what is the 3rd example of sexual conflict
EXAMPLE: Hermaphroditic Land Snails (individuals have the ability to produce both male and female gametes)
1. Reciprocal exchange of sperm during mating; each individual wants to fertilize as many of recipient’s eggs as possible
2. In copulatory canal the sperm may be digested
3. Love dart: sharp calcium carbonate structure coated in mucus with hormones/chemicals
- Increases uptake of sperm
- Reduced willingness to mate
- Those who receive love dart potentially have reduced lifespans after they’ve received it
EXAMPLE: Hummingbird and Hyena Hermaphroditic
1. Female hummingbirds evolved to look like males (apparently to evade aggression)
2. Hyenas: females have pseudo penis to look like male, but often times baby hyenas die during childbirth because of that narrow canal
what is sexual selection
selection that favors traits that increase reproductive success (as opposed to survival)
what are 3 examples of sexual selection discussed in lecture
- Females favor male peacocks with large tails and many large eye spots
- Peacock spider dances to attract mates
- Elephant seal often have very large and dominant so they can fight off males and over time develop large proboscis on their face that gets larger and larger over time
what are 3 key points for sexual selection
- Often favors DIFFERENT traits in males and females (what is attractive in a male may be different than that in female)
- Different size / different color / etc.
- Is a type of intraspecific (within the species) competition
- Is often associated with secondary sexual characteristics (develop once animal reaches maturity and signals they are ready for reproduction)
what is anisogamy
root of sexual selection; introduces opportunity for selection to operate differently in sexes
what are 4 key points of anisogamy
- Male and female gametes have different morphology
- Females produce LARGER/FEWER gametes than male
- Males produce SMALLER/MANY gametes than female
- Male reproductive success is limited by relatively few eggs that are available to fertilize (only one sperm is successful to fertilize egg = extreme competition)
what is the Bateman gradient
a statistical measurement of the relationship between reproductive success (# of offspring) and mating success (# of mates)
- In females there is a limit to how many offspring they can have
- Males there is no limit, more mates = more offspring
what is intersexual selection
one sex chooses which members of the opposite sex to mate with
what is intrasexual selection and 2 examples
often competition between members of the same sex for the opportunity to mate with members of the opposite sex
EXAMPLES
1. Male kangaroos fight intensely for female mates
2. Elephant seal dominant males will fight for females until bloody
what is an alternative tactic for intrasexual selection
Female Mimics/Sneaker Males
- Morphology that closely resembles females and causes the dominant males to NOT detect those males. Sneakers are able to sneak in and mate with females without big dominant males recognizing them
- Can end up selecting for different phenotypes of males that can have strong contrast
what is the good genes hypothesis
differences among males provide information to female about the genetic qualities that can be inherited by offspring
1. Males display “honest advertisement” of good genes
2. “Good genes” may be indicated by a costly trait
3. “Good genes” may be indicated by traits that signal resistance to disease
what is the Fisherian sexual selection
“Arbitrary Choice” - females prefer arbitrary trait that provide NO information about male’s quality
what is the sexy sons hypothesis
females benefit from mating with males that have trait because they are more likely to produce sons with desired trait (son will also be preferred and be more fit, and then pass trait on and on)
what is sexually antagonistic coevolution
often occurs when males increase their reproductive success through an adaptation that is simultaneously detrimental to females, creating selection for a counter-adaptation in females to regain their lost fitness.
what were the findings for Fig 1 in the reading (shows bill color rank and female preferance)
- carotenoid-supplemented males had a significant increase in bill color rank over the first 4 weeks
- females preferred carotenoid-supplemented males
what were the findings for Fig 2 for the reading (shows total carotenoids and PHA response)
- carotenoid-supplemented males had significantly higher plasma carotenoid concentrations compared to controls (higher levels of circulating carotenoids).
- carotenoid-supplemented males had significantly larger PHA responses, indicating better immune function
What is the cost of having a bright red beak for zebra finches?
- carotenoids may be toxic so bright beak display may come with a health risk
- display may come at a physiological cost as the carotenoids are diverted for ornamental purposes.
- Carotenoid availability in the environment may be limited
- Carotenoid displays may cause the male to be stand out more (conspicuous) to predators
What can be determined from Figure 2? in the reading
A. Males in the control group had fewer circulating carotenoids than the experimental group.
B. Males in the experimental group had stronger immune responses than the control group.
C. Males in the experimental group will pass along stronger immune systems to their progeny.
D. A and B
E. All of the above
D. A and B
Which of the following is not true of carotenoids?
A. Carotenoids can be synthesized de novo (anew) by animals, plants, bacteria, and most other organisms on Earth.
B. Carotenoids can be used by animals as Vitamin A precursors.
C. Carotenoids are associated with enhanced immune function in some animals.
D. Carotenoids are pigments that convey red, orange, and yellow coloration.
A. Carotenoids can be synthesized de novo (anew) by animals, plants, bacteria, and most other organisms on Earth.
What can be determined from Figure 1? from the reading
A. Males who were fed carotenoid-enriched diets had significantly brighter beaks than the control group after 8 weeks.
B. Females preferred males from the carotenoid-enriched group over the control group in most cases
C. Males in the control group were less likely to choose to perch next to females.
D. A. and B
E. All of the above
D. A. and B
The hypothesis which states that honest sexual signals which come at a cost to the individual will be attractive to the opposite sex because they reliably indicate quality of mate is known as the? __________
handicap principle
Which hypothesis was investigated in the zebra finch study?
A. Red beaks signal that offspring will be healthy.
B. Red beaks signal that the male is able to withstand and metabolize toxic levels of carotenoids in diet.
C. Red beaks signal that the male is able to effectively attain rare carotenoids from environment.
D. Red beaks signal that the male has superior underlying immune function.
D. Red beaks signal that the male has superior underlying immune function.
T/F: In studies of house finches, guppies, pupfish, and sticklebacks females have been found to prefer males with brighter carotenoid-based features.
TRUE
What variable was measured to determine male zebra finch attractiveness to females in the zebra finch study?
A. the number of successful matings of males in experimental vs. control groups
B. the number of offspring from males in experimental vs. control groups
C. the PHA response in males in experimental vs. control groups
D. the time that female birds spent perched next to the males in the experimental vs. control groups
D. the time that female birds spent perched next to the males in the experimental vs. control groups
Which of the following is a way that carotenoid displays (e.g., red feathers) could be “costly” to males? Check all that apply.
A. Carotenoids may be toxic to organisms and so a display may come with a health risk.
B. Carotenoids may have many physiological benefits, and a display may come at a physiological cost as the carotenoids are diverted for ornamental purposes.
C. Carotenoids reduce attractiveness to the opposite sex, and so a display may come at a fitness cost.
D. Carotenoid availability in the environment may be limited, requiring time and defense of food sources by males who utilize these for displays.
E. Carotenoid displays may cause the male to be more conspicuous to predators.
A. Carotenoids may be toxic to organisms and so a display may come with a health risk.
B. Carotenoids may have many physiological benefits, and a display may come at a physiological cost as the carotenoids are diverted for ornamental purposes.
D. Carotenoid availability in the environment may be limited, requiring time and defense of food sources by males who utilize these for displays.
E. Carotenoid displays may cause the male to be more conspicuous to predators.
Why is male reproductive success limited by the number of eggs?
A. Eggs are much larger and scarcer than sperm, limiting the number of opportunities for reproductive success for males
B. Sperm are short lived compared to eggs, and it is more expensive for males to reproduce because males produce a much greater number of gametes than there are eggs available to fertilize
C. Although eggs are not metabolically expensive to produce, most female organisms will only produce a small number of eggs during their life span
D. Eggs are smaller than sperm and short, lived, limiting the number of opportunities for reproductive success for males
A. Eggs are much larger and scarcer than sperm, limiting the number of opportunities for reproductive success for males
The Bateman principle – which suggests that males will have greater reproductive success if they have more mates, while the same is not true for females – relies on what underlying assumption(s)? CHECK ALL THAT APPLY
A. Males are limited in the number of gametes they produce
B. Females are limited in the number of gametes they produce
C. Females utilize more energy in order to produce, and subsequently care for, offspring than males
B. Females are limited in the number of gametes they produce
C. Females utilize more energy in order to produce, and subsequently care for, offspring than males
Direct benefits may include
A. Protection from predators
B. Increased parental care
C. Access to food / nuptial gifts
D. Access to better territory / resources
E. All of the above
E. All of the above
Based on the data in this slide, we see that peacock eyespot size is positively correlated with (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY)
PEACOCK FEATHER AND EYE SPOT STUDY IN MALE CHICKS
A. Male offspring weight
B. Chick survival rates
C. Number of mates
D. Health of male
A. Male offspring weight
B. Chick survival rates
According to the handicap principle, why are certain traits that reduce survival chances preferred by females?
A. They signify that the offspring will inherit a strong immune system
B. They suggest that the male has greater aggression
C. They are associated with superior hunting skills
D. They indicate the male’s ability to survive despite the handicaps
D. They indicate the male’s ability to survive despite the handicaps
Carotenoids (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY)
A. Can be used to confer red coloration to beaks and feather
B. Are used for immune function
C. Confer a fitness cost to males
D. Can be synthesized (produced) by animals
A. Can be used to confer red coloration to beaks and feather
B. Are used for immune function
According to the ‘Arbitrary Choice’ model, why do female organisms benefit from selecting mates with certain traits?
A. Because the traits provide a direct benefit to the survival of the females
B. Because they produce offspring that are more likely to survive in various environments
C. Because their offspring are more likely to inherit and exhibit these traits, making them attractive to mates
D. Because the traits may be linked to genetic benefits unrelated to the trait itself
C. Because their offspring are more likely to inherit and exhibit these traits, making them attractive to mates
Males of the hanging fly species Hylobittacus apicalis bring the female large prey during courtship. Which model of female mate choice does this describe?
A. Arbitrary choice
B. Sexy sons
C. Direct benefits
D. Good genes
E. Handicap principle
C. Direct benefits
Morphological or behavioral characteristics used to attract a mate can also have the consequence of drawing a predator’s attention to the individual who possesses that trait, yet these so-called expensive traits persist in many species. This describes
A. Direct benefits
B. The handicap principle
C. Sensory bias
D. Runaway sexual selection
B. The handicap principle
When a trait experiences the effects of
Fisherian runaway selection, what is likely to happen when the fitness cost of the trait outweighs its benefit?
A. The genetic preference for the trait will become more widespread
B. Natural selection will act to prevent further exaggeration of the trait
C. The trait will be removed from the population completely
D. The trait will continue to become more exaggerated over generation
B. Natural selection will act to prevent further exaggeration of the trait
When populations include two or male phenotypes that are all successful at passing on genes to the next generation, the population has likely experienced
A. Disruptive selection
B. Stabilizing selection
C. Directional selection
D. Convergent selection
A. Disruptive selection