Exam #2 Flashcards
Theory of Mind
Process by which we attribute and reason about the mental states of others
*Domain specific process mediated by LTPJ
ToM positive social outcomes (4)
- Increased popularity
- Better success when negotiating
- Increased prosocial behavior
- Positive evaluations of perspective-taker
ToM negative social outcomes (3)
- Friendlessness
- Loneliness and social isolation
- Risk for psychiatric illness
How is ToM measured? (6 ways)
- False belief attribution
- Trait judgments
- Strategic games with another person or computer
- Social animations
- Reading mind in eyes
- Rational actions
False-Belief task
Sally-Anne task, kids reliably pass it after 3.5 years of age
Problem with reading the mind in eye task
RMET may be biased against less education, non-white individuals who do not share race/ethnicity of task’s stimuli (reasons: culture, complex vocab, white faces)
Brain regions associated with ToM (7)
- DLPFC
- TPJ
- IFG
- STS
- Temporal pole
- PC
- MPFC
Cognitive components of ToM (4)
- Representing people and social relationships
- Representing representations
- Representing mental representations
- Executive functions
LTPJ damage
- Necessary for ToM
- Deficit in false-belief understanding
Frontal lobe damage
- False-belief understanding deficit
- Other cognitive deficits, affects executive functioning
Diverse lesion sites
Unimpaired
What brain regions respond more to beliefs?
RTPJ (may be special for belief info), LTPJ, PC, MPFC
Which brain regions respond more to thoughts?
RTPJ, LTPJ, PC=
respond selectively to mental states
Which brain region does not differentiate between thoughts, bodily sensations, and appearances?
MPFC=
recruited for any socially-relevant information, false>true beliefs, ToM still ok if damaged
Alternative account of RTPJ
Attention shifting/exogenous attention account, damage=impairment in reorienting attention
Mitchell (2008) interpretations about RTPJ
- Not selective for social cognition or mental state attribution
- ToM and attentional reorienting may require similar computation implemented in RTPJ
- Support for process-specific view of RTPJ (not content)
- Invalid>valid
Theory-theory (TT)
Naive psych or lay theory of psych that’s constructed from observation, inference, and instruction and used to predict or explain another person’s mental state or behavior (ex: apple falling from tree, where to sit), we understand workings of the mind and people
Simulation-theory (ST)
We can use our own body and mind as model for another person’s mind, simulate their experiences
Evidence for ST
- You slow down when you know that someone else is performing action incompatible with your own
- You only compute what other people see
- “Mirror system”-action observation
- “Pain matrix”-physical sensations
ST evidence-division of labor in MPFC
-DMPFC: thinking about others (ToM), dissimilar others
-VMPFC: thinking about self, making mental state inferences about similar others
DOUBLE DISSOCIATION
Evidence for TT/Against ST
- Systematicity of errors from children and adults suggest we rigidly use rules derived from theories to explain others’ mental states
- RTPJ doesn’t differentiate between culturally familiar vs. foreign or between common-sense beliefs and absurd beliefs
Sighted vs blind patients ToM
- Same neural network recruited for ToM
- RTPJ equally selective for belief info and seeing and hearing
- THEREFORE: visual experience plays little role in ToM in adults
Anchoring and Adjustment
We generate a plausible “anchor” value (MPFC) and then serially adjust away from that anchor, use ourselves as anchor, might use underlying TT processes
Building a brain
NS derived from cells arranged in hollow cylinder called the neural tube, neurons migrate out from tube to regions where they’ll mature
What part of the brain undergoes protracted synaptic development that continues well into adolescence?
Prefrontal cortex
White vs grey matter in development
- Linear increase in white matter during first 2 decades of life
- Grey matter volume (GMV) decreases between childhood and adulthood (inverted U)
Where does GMV loss start in the brain?
Primary sensorimotor areas–>PFC–>parietal cortex–>occipital cortex–>temporal cortex
Kids <4 engage in behaviors that imply mental state understanding such as (3)
- Kids can deceive and lie
- Imitate intended actions
- Engage in pretend play
Two-Systems Account
- Cognitively efficient, but limited and inflexible (implicit ToM), intact in infants and allows them to pass looking-time tests
- Flexible, but demanding of general cognitive resources (explicit ToM), develops more gradually
Anatomical changes in brain
- GMV follows cubic trajectory in all regions, peaks at ages 8-12
- Cortical thickness shows linear decrease from ages 8-23 in all regions except ATC
- Relates to synaptic pruning
Which developmental possibility is most accurate?
ToM is still developing after 4 years of age
TPJ and precuneus for functional changes in brain
Mental>People>Physical
MPFC for functional changes in brain
Mental, People>Physical