Exam 2 Flashcards
When was the UN created?
June 1945
How many original member states were in the UN?
51
How many members does the UN currently have?
193
What is the mission of the UN?
Peace, security, and international law
What are the powers of the 5 permanent members of the UN Security Council?
Drive the agenda, drive the debates, veto any resolution
Who are the permanent members of the UN Security Council?
US, Russia, Chin, Britain, France
When did China become a permanent member of the UN Security Council?
1971
What are the keys of the 10 rotating members of the UN Security Council?
They are elected for non-renewable, two year terms, they cannot veto resolutions, and they have a more marginal role
What are powers of the UN Security Council mentioned in Chapter VI of the UN Charter?
Promoting the pacific settlement of disputes (fact finding, arbitration, and investigation)
What are powers of the UN Security Council mentioned in Chapter VII of the UN Charter?
Take action with respect to the peace, breached of the peace, and acts of aggression. Use coercive means (use of force, diplomatic pressures, economic sanctions)
Who is in the UN general assembly?
All UN members
How many votes does each state get in the UN general assembly?
One, no matter the size
How are resolutions voted on in the UN general assembly?
Majority passage, except on important questions (2/3 of those present and voting is needed)
What are Uniting for Peace resolutions?
Covene urgent UNGA meeting to consider collective action when the UNSC is paralyzed
Why is there a rising number of members in the UN?
Decolonization, also meaning the UNGA is dominated by the Global South
How many members are there in the non-aligned movement?
120
What does Article 100 of the UN Charter say?
UN personnel are independent from their national governments and those governments cannot seek to influence them
Who appoints the UN Secretary General?
The UNGA on the UNSC’s recommendation
What was the election pattern of the SG until 2016?
Rotates from region to region with two terms
What does the P5 seek in a SG candidate?
A candidate who will not exert a troubling degree of independence, and cannot antagonize P5 members
How many employees are in the UN administration?
44,000
What is the regular budget of the UN/for peacekeeping, and how does it lead to limited means?
$3.12B budget, about 22x lower than US confectionary and alcohol expenses, and $6.45B for peacekeeping, 1/3 of US monthly expenditures in Iraq
What is the task of the secretariat?
Implementing UNSC decisions, mediation/negotiation, and Article 99 says the UNSG can request the UNSC to discuss a given problem (but this has only happened 3 times)
What is Dag Hammarskjold’s contribution as UNSG?
Peacekeeping operations (1950s)
What was Boutros Boutros-Ghali’s contribution as UNSG?
Agenda for peace, peace building (1992)
What was Kofi Annan’s contributions as UNSG?
Responsibility to protect (2005) and systemic prevention of conflicts (2006)
How many Chapter VII operations were conducted during the Cold War?
5
Why were there so few Chapter VII operations during the Cold War?
US/Soviet rivalry paralyzed the institution
When did the UNSC have a Chapter VII operation to impose a ceasefire during the Cold War?
In 1948, during the conflict between Israel and its Arab neighbors
When did the UNSC have a Chapter VII operation to use force during the Cold War?
From 1950-53 during the Korean War, and in 1960, during the Congo civil war
When did the UNSC have a Chapter VII operation to impose sanctions during the Cold War?
In 1966, against Rhodesia for HR violations by a white minority regime, and in 1977, against South Africa, for HR violations by a white majority regime
How many peacekeeping operations were conducted during the Cold War?
113 operations with 500,000 troops
What did UN peacekeeping operations involve?
Civilians/troops from various member states under UN command, conducting various missions.
Why was peacekeeping less controversial than Chapter VII operations?
It’s just about keeping the peace
What are the features of the UN’s post-WWII peacekeeping operations?
They are often in the Third World, small deployments, they respect the local states sovereignty, and there is no fighting/coercion
How did UN peacekeeping operations respect local state’s sovereignty?
Local states gave consent, there is no UN involvement in local politics, and no UN efforts to reshape local societues
Why did Chapter VII interventions increase?
After the Cold War, the US and Russia clashed less systematically
What did the Chapter VII intervention in 1990 in Saddam Hussein’s Iraq involve?
Iraq attacked Kuwait (which was a violation of national sovereignty) and had views on Saudi Arabia, which would have left them with 44% of global oil reserves. So, the UNSC backed a US-led international coalition
What other sanctions did the UNSC take after the end of the CW?
1990s economic sanctions against Saddam Hussein’s Iraq and 90s-2000s economic sanctions against N. Korea for their nuclear program
How did economic sanctions evolve in Chapter VII operations?
Initially, sanctions were blanket on a country’s entire economy, but this hurt innocent civilians, and not necessarily local regimes, so there became a growing emphasis on targeted sanctions (arms embargoes or against leader’s financial assets)
How has there been a growing activism against terrorism?
in the un
Late 80s: growing mobilization, 90s: vs. bin Laden, al-Qaeda , and the Afghan Taliban, and post-9/11: supported US war in self-defense in response to terrorist attack, but in 2005, members were still unable to agree on a definition of terrorism
How has the UNSC covered increasingly diverse issues?
They have tackled HR abuses, HIV?AIDS, and global warming, but there are many disagreements, like how to define human rights, is HIV a security or humanitarian question, and who pays for global warming
What has the expansion of the peacekeeping meant?
They require more money, operations, and troops
What has a drift toward peace building (from peacekeeping) meant?
They are going to intervene to prevent new violent conflicts by transforming attitudes, behaviors, and norms in a direction that supports the peaceful regulation of conflict, meaning it is more ambitious and intrusive than peacekeeping. It implies democratization, state-building, national-building, and economic reconstruction
What is the rationale of the debate on expansion of the UNSC?
The UNSCs permanent members do not reflect current distribution of power
What is the main stake of the debate on expansion of the UNSC?
Creating new permanent members
What would be the potential criteria of new permanent members of the UNSC?
Economic, demographic, and diversity (+long term demographic) criteria
What are the key obstacles in the way of the expansion of the UNSC’s permanent members
Huge geopolitical and symbolic stakes, how to avoid constant vetoes/paralysis, great powers still bypass the UNSC when it is in their national interest
What is the definition of human rights?
Rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our nationality, place of residence, sex, national or ethnic origin, color religion, language, or any other status. Human rights are a recently intellectual creation and an even more recent practice
When was the UN Declaration of Human Rights?
1948
What was the context of the UNDHR?
WWII
What does the UNDHR say?
No discrimination on the basis of race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, or birth
When was the Geneva War convention?
1949
What did the Geneva War Convention say?
Protection of civilians, protection of the wounded, etc.
When was the UN convention on the prevention and punishment of genocide?
1948
Who invented the concept of genocide?
Raphael Lemkin
What is the criteria used to define a genocide?
Any of the following acts committed with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial, or religious group, as such:
Killing members of the group
Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group
Inflicting on group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction
Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group
Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group
When was the UN declaration on the independence of colonial countries?
1960
What did the UN declaration on the independence of colonial countries say?
Colonialism was definitively discredited
When did the US endorse human rights?
The 1970s- in 1975, with the US making its foreign aid conditional on HR and in 1976, Jimmy Carter’s election
When was the UN Convention on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women?
1979
When was the UN convention against torture?
1985
When was the UN convention on the rights of the child?
1989
When was the UN convention on the protection of minorities?
1992
What changed in US policy post CW towards HR?
The US fully endorsed the spread of democracy and HR
How many states adopted new democratic constitutions between 1990 and 1996?
35
What did many say about democracy in the period immediately following the CW?
It was the only model of government with any broad legitimacy and ideological appeal in the world
What were the persistent limitations and ambiguities of HR following the CW?
Countless human rights violations (including by UNSC members), disagreements about the definition of HR, neocolonialism, persistent gender inequality, and few international interventions against genocides
What are civil/political rights?
Against state abuse and for political participation
What are economic and social right?
The state must provide essential goods and services
Why were there few international interventions against genocides?
Genocide is a contested concept, it requires dismissing local states’ sovereignty, and it requires great power leadership in the Un and beyond
When/what was the Rwandan genocide?
1994- Hutus massacred .8M Tutsis, the US/West did nothing
When/what was the Srebrencia massacre in ex-Yugoslavia?
1995, Dutch peacekeepers abandoned their positions as the Serb army units surrounded a UN safe area in Srebrenica, leading to the slaughter of 8,000 muslim men and boys
When/what was the crisis in Sudan’s Darfur?
2003-05, clashing assessments on if it was a genocide, China/Russia support to Sudan, and US overstretch lead to the death of .3M
What was the consequence of the failures of preventing genocides in the 90s-2000s?
International momentum for a new approach, responsibility to protect
When did the UN endorse R2P?
2005
What are the 3 pillars of R2P?
The responsibility of a state to protect its population against genocide, the international communities responsibility to assist the state to build this, and in situations where a state is failing to protect its population, the international community’s responsibility to take timely and decisive action
What are the problems with R2P?
R2P interventions are difficult to agree on, and they do not necessarily create more stability
What happened during the NATO led R2P intervention in Libya?
The UN approved a NATO intervention to protect civilians during uprisings against Colonel Gaddafi, but NATO pursued regime change instead, which led Russia, China, India, Brazil to accuse NATO of violating the mandate for neocolonial purposes. Since 2011, Libya had had more instability, fragmentation, and massive migrations to Europe
What are the challenges associated with peace building?
It creates local resentment, causes civilian casualties, can aggravate corruption, real peace building would take decades, too many goals, creation of local dependency, and risk of paralysis due to the number of actors involved
How can democratization and state building causes tensions?
Not every state wants equal rights, not every local wants a strong central state, and many locals do not like foreign interference
How can foreigner’s impatience hurt peace building?
Foreigners want to show success, so they focus on superficial things and tend to inflate results
How can foreigners ignorance hurt peace building?
Insufficient knowledge of local conditions, impose norms that do not fit local realities, local people are neglected
When did Afghanistan gain its independence from Britain?
1921
What was the relationship between the US and Afghanistan like during the CW?
The US gave arms and development projects to Afghanistan, but the Soviet had a larger influence. The US was okay with that as long as Afghanistan didn’t become a Soviet satellite state
Why did the US not like the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan?
The US feared that the Soviets would use it to invade the Middle East, which was responsible for 25% of US oil imports
When did the Soviets invade Afghanistan?
1979
How did the US intervene in the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan?
Covertly, they and the Saudis paid billion for arms, which the CIA delivered to Pakistan, and the distributed the arms to the Afghan resistance (the Mujahideen)
How was the Soviet Afghan war the first global jihad?
It led to Afghanistan and Pakistan’s radicalization and the arrival of thousands of Islamic radicals from the Middle East, including bin Laden
What was the outcome of the Soviet Afghan War?
In 1989, the Soviets withdrew, but from 1992-1996, there was a civil war in Afghanistan
What was the US response to the Afghan civil war?
They estimated their new regime would be Islamic, maybe fundamentalist and opposed to the US, but there was a lack of interest, since the CW had just ended, so there was no US effort to end the Afghan Civil War, no economic assistance, and they let Pakistan/Saudi Arabia support local radicals
When was the Taliban created?
1994
When did the Taliban take control of Kabul?
1996
What was the Taliban regime like?
Deeply violent and intolerant, and hosted bin Laden and al-Qaeda.
What was the US response to the rise of the Taliban?
Informal dialogue
Why did the US decide to intervene in Afghanistan?
The Taliban refused to hand over Bin Laden
Why did the US pursue a light footprint strategy in Afghanistan?
No Soviet like entanglement, anticipating an easy victory, already thinking about a war in Iraq
When did bin Laden escape to Pakistan?
In December 2001, at the Battle of Tora Bora, there were not enough US troops to take the mountain. Other Taliban leaders, including Mullah Omar, escaped to Pakistan as well.
What were the consequences of the Battle of Tora Bora?
The enemy got a second chance and the US had to stay in Afghanistan, leading to the US peace building effort
What were the milestone of the attempts to democratize Afghanistan?
In Dec. 2001, a new temporary government was installed, in 2004, there was a new constitution and presidential elections
What are the problems with foreign led democratization?
Ethnic rivalries, insecurity, underdevelopment, religious traditionalism, and hostility to foreign interference
Why do some scholars argue that Afghanistan was a lost opportunity?
The US and its allies did not do enough in Afghanistan, because of the low levels of troops, police, and financial assistance. The Iraq waar also diverted US attention
Why di some scholars argue the US had overreach in Afghanistan?
The US and its allies could not succeed with its democratization.
What are frequent problems with foreign led peace building efforts?
Post conflict society has huge societal tensions, building a state is a long process, foreigners tend to impose their agenda, massive aid creates dependency, massive aid exacerbates corruption, and too many actors leads to paralysis.
What are the challenged of peace building specifically in Afghanistan?
Institutions matter less than tribes and family, corruption, underdevelopment, low education levels
What was Obama’s approach to Afghanistan and the resurgence of the enemy?
Saw Afghanistan as a war of necessity (as opposed to Iraq), so he announced a surge in troops to reduce the Taliban’s momentum, kill al-Qaeda terrorists, train the Afghan army, and reduce corruption. Also had the new COIN strategy. But the surge ended after 18 months and was flawed
What happened after the surge?
The US killed bin Laden in Pakistan (May 2011), but al-Qaeda survived, there was a rising number of Taliban attacks, some high profile attacks, and the emergence of ISIS-Khorasan, which was much more radical than the Taliban
What was the problem with Afghan National Security Forces?
The took a back seat during battles, high absenteeism, high illiteracy, high drug use, corruption, and multiple abuses against the Afghan people
Why was there declining Afghan support for US presence in Afghanistan?
Military occupation/blunders, growing civilian casualties, and association with the corrupt regime in Kabul
What was Trump’s Afghanistan strategy?
Originally, a new small surge. But, in Feb 2020, he signed a peace deal with the Taliban, which led to US draw down, and eventual withdrawal altogether
What was Biden’s Afghanistan strategy?
He recognized the war could not be won, and in July 2021, he announced US withdrawal. Th Afghan regime quickly unraveled and by Aug, the Taliban entered Kabul.
What were the main critiques against Biden’s withdrawal from Afghanistan?
Should’ve made withdrawal conditional on an intra-Afghan agreement, and thousands of Afghans who worked for the US were left behind
What are the current challenges and tragedies for Afghanistan?
Security (Taliban and al-Qaeda relationship, should the US cooperate with Taliban against ISIS), underdevelopment, Taliban measures against women
What is grand strategy?
The intellectual architecture that lends structure to foreign policy. The conceptual logic that drives foreign policy.