Exam 1 Flashcards
What was the political configuration in Europe before 1500?
There were multiple configurations of power, with no clear borders, a fragmentation of political authority within each political entity, and overlapping authority. Examples included empires, monarchies, the church, towns, and personal hierarchies.
What is a state?
A political entity with two key features: a piece of territory with reasonably well defined borders, and political authorities who enjoy sovereignty. Also featured centralization of power and support by a central administration.
When was the Treaty of Westphalia?
1648
What was the reason for the Treaty of Westphalia?
To end the Thirty Years war in Europe
What does national sovereignty include?
Internal and external sovereignty
What is internal sovereignty?
Exclusive and legitimate political authority inside a state’s territory.
What is external sovereignty?
Each state is recognized by the others as the legitimate member of a community of equals.
What were the ambiguities/limitations of the Westphalian sovereignty?
It only applies to a few states in Europe, those states continued to fight each other, they colonized the rest of the world. But, it was a milestone for the spread of the state model.
When was the French Revolution?
1789
What was the impact of the French Revolution on the state?
It was the birth of modern nationalism, and state security evolved to be not only based on force and control, but also legitimacy
What is nationalism?
An intense sense of national community by a particular people in a geographically defined space.
What is the mutual reinforcing relationship between wars and the state?
States fight war, so to win those wars, states need to make the most of their natural resources, so states develop better means to control their population, so states can fight bigger and bigger wars, and this cycle continues over and over again.
What was the cause of the development for strategic thought in war?
Rise of the modern state and the rising scale of interstate wars
Who developed the science of war strategies?
Jomini and Clauswitz
What are geostrategic doctrines?
Developed by Alfred T. Mahan, it studies the forces that drive world politics across space
What was Alfred T Mahan’s concept of seapower?
Seapower was relevant for commerce and access to markets, war (blockades), and was a symbol of national greatness. Mahan recommended the US build a strong fleet, develop colonies with naval bases, and control the world’s chokepoints.
When was the discipline of IR created?
1919
When was International Security Studies created?
1945
Why was ISS created in 1945?
Due to WWII atrocities, the failure of multilateral institutions, and the onset of the Cold War.
Why was ISS created in 1945?
Due to WWII atrocities, the failure of multilateral institutions, and the onset of the Cold War.
What factors explain the evolution of the discipline of ISS?
Changes in the distribution of power among the leading states, technological breakthroughs, the inherent dynamics of academic debates, institutions that support the production of knowledge
What’s an example of the changes in the distribution of power among the leading states?
The US at the end of the CW
What is an example of a technological breakthrough?
The nuclear revolution, the Internet
What is meant by the inherent dynamic of academic debate?
Intellectual disagreements (arguments and counterarguments and theories in need of updates/corrections), as well as developments on other academic fields that influences ISS.
What is the impact of institutions that support the production of knowledge?
Allocation of resources, but this can lead to biases and can generate intellectual conformism.
What is Nye’s definition of ISS?
The study of the threat, use, and control of military force
What is Walt’s definition of ISS?
They conditions that make the use of force more likely, the ways that the use of force affects individuals, states, and societies, and the specific policies that states adapt in order to prepare for, prevent, or engage in war.
What do ISS scholars focus on/emphasize?
Focus on material dimensions that can be easily measured, emphasis on rationality (of states and people), emphasis on objectivity.
What are topics of interest to ISS scholars?
Nuclear deterrence, alliance formation, offense-defense balance.
Why do some scholars say defining security as military security is too narrow?
There’s also political security, economic security, societal security, and environmental security.
Why do some scholars say security is about more than survival?
Security as emancipation, freeing people from any form of violence
Why do some say ISS suffers from a severe Western bias?
It is an Anglo-American discipline. Out of 38,000 IR scholars, 17,000 worked in the US, and non-Western countries are dismissed
Why do some scholars believe that ISS’s focus on the state is too narrow?
They should focus on individuals, sub-national actors, regions, global institutions, and the biosphere.
Why do some scholars say ISS neglects women?
They do not address and acknowledge gender inequality.
What are the beliefs of critical security studies?
There is no such thing as objective reality, security is a political product, so it is the product of interpretations, power struggles, and biases, any expert must question his/her own biases.
What are the main assumptions of realism?
States matter much more than anyone else, rationality (most realists), and there is a dark side of human nature (greed, violence, and no moral universal principles)
What is the implication of anarchy for states in realist theory?
States live in constant insecurity and fear.
What is the implication of self-help for states in realist theory?
You can only trust yourself, alliances are only temporary, IOs can’t be trusted.
Why do states always follow their self-interest in realist theory?
Morality will not be regarded
Why is there competition in realist theory?
IS is a zero sum game and conflict is inevitable.
What are the main critiques of realism?
Analytical flaws and policy risks
What do some say the analytical flaws of realism are?
They underestimate international cooperation, underestimate the role of international organizations and non-state actors, underestimate the power of attraction, and they are unable to explain some important events.
What do some say the policy risks of realism are?
Practicing realism can cause dangerous self-fulfilling prophecies.
What are the key insights of classical realism?
Pessimism about human nature, the main goal of states: survive, and states always follow their self-interest
What did E.H. Carr’s “The Twenty Year Crisis” contribute to realism?
It said that the League of Nations was bound to fail and Great Powers just use ideals as pretexts to advance their interests.
What did Hans Morganthau say in “Politics Among Nations” in 1948 that contributed to classical realism?
Human nature cannot be transcended, and international politics is a struggle for power.
What is structural realism?
Based on “Theory of International Politics” by Kenneth Waltz, they say that the structure of the international system matters more than human nature.
What question defines the structure of the international system?
How many great powers?
What are the main types of international systems?
Unipolar, bipolar, and multipolar
How are state capabilities measured?
Population, territory, natural resources, economic situation, military strength, and political stability
What are the responses of states when facing a rising power?
Buckpassing, bandwagoning, and balancing
What is buckpassing?
Letting other states do the heavy lifting
What is bandwagoning?
Flocking to the strongest state
What is balancing?
Countering enemies by increasing one’s military strength. Includes internal (building up ones own capabilities) and external (forming alliances) balancing
What is the balance of power theory?
States will check concentrations of power by balancing. Ex: British balancing against Germany pre WWI.
What is a security dilemma?
When may of the means by which a state tries to increase its security decreases the security of others.
What are the mechanisms for a security dilemma?
A arms for self defense, but B sees that as a prelude to an attack, so B arms further, so then A arms further, because they think B has bad intentions, leading to a cycle of distrust.
What are the 2 processes that work concurrently in a security dilemma?
Dilemma of interpretation and dilemma of response.
What is a dilemma of interpretation?
Assessing others motives, intentions, or capabilities is hard, therefore, there is a tendency to assume the worst.
What is a dilemma of response?
There is a tendency to prefer toughness over reassurance/talks
What is the fatalist logic of addressing security dilemmas?
Competitive dynamics are inescapable and cooperation will only be opportunistic and short-term
What is the mitigator logic of addressing security dilemmas?
The worst competitive dynamics can be attenuated. The English School: laws and norms can make a difference.
What is transcender logic of realism?
Human societies can overcome the security dilemma through security communities.
What is defensive realism?
States are afraid, they know war is costly, and they want the status quo. As long as states worry for their survival, they will be aggressive, but once states have ensured their survival, they will not be aggressive anymore. States can signal benign intentions.
What do defensive realists believe about China’s intentions?
They have a history of being invaded, legitimate security concerns, and legitimate rights, hence China wants security, and knows that other states will balance against it if they are too aggressive
What do defensive realists believe about the US response to China’s rise?
They want to be sure China is not a threat, they want to protect regional trade, they want to protect local allies, so the US only wants stability.
What is the defensive realists takeaway from the China-US situation?
There is a security dilemma, but the US and China can reassure each other, and stability is attainable.
What do offensive realists believe?
The world is extremely dangerous, states’ goal is to maximize their relative power (at the expense of other states) whenever there is an opportunity. Aggression is to be expected, states will not be stupid, but if there is an opportunity to attack/disrupt, they will seize it.
What do offensive realists believe about China’s intentions?
China is aggressive, with their history of dominating Asia, China’s rising power makes China greedy, so they will try to expand whenever there is a chance.
What do offensive realists believe about the US reaction to China’s rise?
They want to retain global military primacy, so they want to maximize power at China’s expense, and they want to defend the world from China and keep dominating the world.
What do offensive realists believe the outcome of the US China situation is?
War is likely
What is rise and fall realism?
Hegemony=more stability, power transitions fuel instability (declining hegemony wages a preventive war, and a rising challenger may start a preventive war), ideological/cultural proximity can help prevent war (British-US power transition)
What do rise and fall realists believe will impact the risk of war?
Whether the US remains number one, or whether China’s military catches up eco/military/tech
What do neoclassical realists say?
Distribution of state capabilities is a good starting point, but domestic factors matter too.
What are some domestic factors that neoclassical realists point to?
Domestic political debates, leader’s perceptions, strategic culture.
What do neoclassical realists believe will happen between the US and China?
Nearly anything is possible, but domestic factors in China and the US will make a big difference
What are the main assumptions of liberalism?
Human progress is possible, focus on individual freedoms, a key-driver of IR is regime type, international cooperation is possible, states are not the only actors that matter in IR
What are negative freedoms?
Freedom from arbitrary authority
What is positive freedom?
Freedom to promote capacity/opportunities
What is the third type of freedom liberals promote?
Democratic participation and representation
Why do liberals believe regime type is a key driver of IR?
States are the transmission belt by which the preferences and social power of individuals and groups are translated into foreign policy. The main distinction is between liberal and illiberal regimes
What other actors do liberals believe matter, other than states?
International organizations and multinational corporations
What are the three main branches of liberalism?
Commercial liberalism, democratic peace theory, and neoliberal institutionalism.
When did commercial liberalism come up?
The 18th century, where scholars believed the hidden hand of the market would help optimize prosperity, and that states needed to get rid of protectionist barriers.
When did commercial liberalism start to rise?
The 18th century, where scholars believed the hidden hand of the market would help optimize prosperity, and that states needed to get rid of protectionist barriers.
How does free trade advance peace?
Rising interdependence, national prosperity, individual enrichment, and the pursuit of wealth leads to moral perfection.
What are the main milestones of commercial liberalism?
British endorsement of free trade and abolition of the Corn Laws (1846), President Wilson’s Fourteen Points (1919), failure of trade leading to WWII, post-WWII promotion of free trade, post-CW globalization leading to more interdependence.
What are some potential critiques of trade liberalism?
Trade can lead to aggressions (competition for strategic resources, aggressive business lobbies, and trade not preventing war) and trade can exacerbate human flaws (greed, racism, nationalism), today’s trade is not that free, free trade can be unfair