Evolution Flashcards
Why should we study evolution?
- Evolution unites sub disciplines of biology via providing common framework
- finding similarities differences and making sense of their functions and origins
What is evolutionary biology? What is the goal?
- the study of evolutionary pathways that led to lifeforms today and how populations continue to change
Goal: to understand origin, maintenance and diversity of life on earth
What does evolutionary biology encompass?
- identification and classification, relationships, adaptations, variation, origins and/or extinction, underlying mechanisms (eg: natural selection)
Why is survival of the fittest not an accurate depiction of evolution?
- generally true, but not exactly accurate because it’s not always the fittest alleles that are chosen.
better : descent with modification
What is descent with modification?
- changes in characteristics over generations
How can we understand how a species has evolved?
- we must know its ancestors and that modifications have occurred
What are the methods of modification for evolutionary processes ?
natural selection, genetic drift, non-random mating, mutation
What is natural selection?
- beneficial alleles increase in frequency due to increased survival and reproductive success of carriers
- Forms become better suited to the environment and increase in frequency in a population over long periods of time
Is natural selection a slow or fast process? Why?
A gradual process! Slight changes occur and over a great period of time will alter the form.
Describe the process of descent with modification via natural selection:
- Individuals possess genetic variations
- genetic mutations change the phenotypes of organisms
- Mutations can increase, decrease, or have no effect on fitness
- mutations can be disadvantageous or neutral, some advantageous which allows for greater survival rates
Result: evolutionary change via naturel selection
How do advantageous mutations result in natural selection?
- allows for that allele carrier to have greater reproductive success and lifespans, that allele will become more common and ‘stronger’
What is the result of an accumulation of advantageous genetic changes within a long period of time?
- produces new species, genera, families, can change taxonomic orders
Describe HIV/AIDs
An intracellular parasite targets helper T cells, hijacks host cells replication machinery, and damages or destroys cells. As more cells are destroyed immune system weakens and cannot fight opportunistic pathogens
What does HIV stand for?
Human Immunodeficiency Virus
What does AIDs stand for?
Acquired Immune Deficiency syndrome
What are some common causes of death for AIDS/HIV patients?
- a weakened immune system becomes susceptible to TB, hepatitis B and C, and cancer (AIDs is not the cause of death but weakens the immune system enough to be taken out easily by another illness)
What is the HIV life cycle?
- Extracellular virus called ‘virion’
- Virion encounters host immune cell: surface protein GP120 binds to CD4 and its coreceptor
- Virion fuses with host cell and RNA and enzymes enter
- HIV’s reverse transcriptase enzyme synthesizes HIV DNA (from the HIV RNA template)
- HIV’s integrase enzyme splices HIV genome into the host cell’s genome
6/7. Host cell transcribes/translates proteins encoded in the virus’ RNA
8/9. Viral proteins and mRNA are packaged into new virions and bud off from host cell membrane before maturing
What are the components of a virion? What does this cause?
- an agent of HIV : consists of very little cell membrane, 2 pieces of RNA, 3 enzymes, surface proteins
What is the minimum concentration of CD4T cells before the immune system begins to collapse?
- 200 cells / mm^2
How can we prevent AIDs/HIV? What are the treatment methods?
- stop them from replicating!
1) AZT azidothymine: prevents HIV DNA from being synthesized
2) HAART: highly active antiretroviral therapy
Describe AZT treatment and its drawbacks
- mimics the nucleotide thymidine and tricks reverse transcriptase, prevents HIV DNA from being synthesized
- issues: when treatment begins patients see a drop in viral load, increases over time until treatment ineffective : treatment less effective over time as virus evolves resistance
–> Greater concentration combated by greater resistance
How does AZT resistance come about?
–> Hypothetically if reverse transcriptase could avoid AZT then the virus would remain unchecked
- mutations that lead to changes in reverse transcriptase amino acid sequence allows enzyme to avoid AZT and change shape of binding site to no longer accept AZT
Describe HAART treatment
- alternative to AZT which develops resistance
- HAART uses multiple drugs at once, requiring an increased number of mutations to achieve resistance (less likely)
- NOT a cure
How did the study of evolution play a role in treating HIV/AIDs?
Understanding evolution and how resistance evolves allowed researchers to devise more effective HIV treatments
–> thanks to evolution studies someone diagnosed at 20 can live to 78
Why does HIV meet the requirements for natural selection?
- variation present: reverse transcriptase is prone to mistakes (half HIV DNA contains more than one error)
- Some of the variation Is heritable (mutation in all daughter visions)
- Not all individuals can survive (AZT blocks)
- Traits which enhance survival more common (resistant mutants become more common)
Evolutionary change via natural selection!
What are the requirements for natural selection?
- Variation present
- variation is heritable
- Not all individuals can survive/reproduce
- Traits which enhance survival/ reproduction become more common
What are the two evolutionary questions throughout the ages?
- how did life begin
- what are organisms so well suited to their environments?
What are the past and present explanations for the evolutionary questions?
Past: supernatural (mythology and divine creation)
Present: natural (process of evolution)
Why do we care about moving to natural explanations from supernatural ones?
all science builds on the work of those that came before, learn from past mistakes, question our own understanding
What is Methodological Naturalism?
- a strategy where one explains the world through laws of nature
- methodological : provides method to explain something and create hypothesis
- naturalism” rather than supernatural
What did methodological naturalism oversee?
Hypothesis testing: must not accept an explanation but test it too.
- helped develop the framework of the scientific method
What is evolution? How was the earth and evolution viewed in the past?
- Evolution : descent with modification over long periods of time
- in the past, earth was though to be young and unchanging (but this does not support the theory of evolution)
Which philosophers acknowledge there may be change?
Empedocles: plants before animals
Xenophanes: Mountains were once underwater
What proved that the earth was older than expected?
- geological evidence (rock strata, erosion, sedimentation rates)
- radiometric dating (4.5 billion years old)
What is our present understanding of the world?
- world is old and ever changing
What is unformitarianism?
- Evidence from geology and Charles Lyell
: Laws of nature are constant in time and space - geological processes have operated over long periods of time in a slow gradual manner
What is catastrophism?
Features arose via sudden cataclysmic events, unlikely to reoccur and impossible to experiment
Who disproved the spontaneous generation theory?
Francesi Redi
What was the former explanation for diversity and well suitedness among living organisms?
- spontaneous generation
- complex life forms arise from non living matter (mudflats –> frogs)
- experiment of flies trapped in jars by Redi disproved this theory
Who was Erasmus Darwin?
Before Darwin, described evolutionary change and the struggle for existence but failed to link the ideas
Who were the pre Darwin people?
- Erasmus Darwin and Robert Chambers
What did Robert Chambers discover? Name the term he coined.
- diversity of species changes gradually over time
- coined the principle of progressive development: new species must arise from old species
- population evolved but not individuals (did not explain why)
What is the Principle of Progressive Development?
- New species must arise from old species
- Organisms have an innate tendency to evolve in a given direction
What did Lamarck propose? What was he known for?
- New more complex species descend gradually from older, less complex species (inheritance of acquired characteristics where individuals evolve)
- famous for being wrong but the first to connect environment to the evolution of adaptations
What mechanism did Lamarck propose for his theory?
- inheritance of acquired characteristics
- habits of an individual bring about changes in its structure which are passed down the generations (incorrect)
What theory came first uniformatarianism or catastrophism?
Catastrophism was first, then uniformatarianism
Describe the pre Darwin theories
Darwin: struggle for existence
Chambers: principle of progressive development, changes occur gradually over time
Lamarck/Baptiste: Acquired characteristics
What were Darwin’s fundamental insights? What do they combine to create?
- the environment selects on variation in traits of individual organisms
- some variants more successful than others
- provides mechanisms (natural selection) that explains trait changes and adaptiveness - All species descended from on (or a few) common ancestor
= theory of evolution by natural selection
What are the 4 lines of evidence for descent with modification (evolution)?
- Species change through time (microevolution)
- Lineages split and diverge (speciation)
- New lifeforms arise from older life forms (macroevolution)
- Common ancestry: all species have arisen from one or a few common ancestors
Describe the first evidence of evolution
Species change through time: microevolution
- microevolution: populations of organisms change across generations
- selective breeding demonstrates such changes
What is microevolution? What proves it?
- populations of organisms change across generations
- selective breeding indicates traits can be selected for
Describe natural vs. artificial selection?
natural selection: evolutionary process where beneficial alleles have a better fitness and increase in frequency (humans may have hand in changing elements of environment)
artificial selection humans select reproducing individuals for desired traits (beneficial alleles play no role)
What is anthropogenic evolution?
- catch all phase for evolutionary changes induce by the actions of humans (climate change, habitat destruction, pollution, overfishing : their impacts on organisms)
what is the 2nd evidence for natural selection (descent with modification)?
lineages split and diverge (speciation)
Describe the fly experiment on different diets to explain speciation
two flies on different diets more prone to mate with those on similar diets : gradual speciation?
What is a species?
- consists of groups of actually or potentially interbreeding population that are reproductively isolated from other groups
(must be able to mate)
Is speciation fast or gradual?
gradual process!
What is the 3rd evidence of evolution?
New life forms arise from older life forms (macroevolution)
What is extinction and succession?
Extinction: all individuals in a species have died out and left no living descendants
The law of succession: animals that inhabit an area will resemble nearby fossils
What are fossils and fossil records?
- fossil records: history of life on earth as recorded by fossil evidence
- Fossils: remains or traces of once-living organisms (~10k or older)
In the use of antibiotics, does the adaptation or resistance in bacteria indicate artificial or natural selective forces?
- natural. not picked by humans or intended, a side effect. Natural resistance to antibiotics.
- natural selection is still considered natural even when organisms are reacting to conditions humans may have altered in the environment.
What is a transitional form?
- if new life forms descended from old ones, fossil records should contain such evidence of a species containing a mix of features between extinct and present day species
Describe the 4th evidence of natural selection
Common ancestry - all species have risen from one or a few common ancestors
What is homology?
- shared characteristics that are a result of common ancestry are greatest evidence for descent with modification
What is true about individuals/groups at the same hierarchal level on a tree of life?
they will resemble each other
- ex: squirrel and deer share more similarities than to frogs
What is a transformational process?
- ensemble changes because each individual member changes
- inheritance of acquired characteristics
ex: smashing course particles into fine dust (all go under change)
What is a variational process?
- ensemble changes because something sorts among the variants in the original ensemble
- natural selection (picks specific and ‘sifts’ them out)
Is evolution variational or transformational?
Variational because through evolution it works on selecting characteristics that increase fitness and increases the frequency of that trait in coming generations
What does artificial selection present?
- selective breedings demonstrates how traits of a population can change over generations
Which gene was involved in the different between wild and domestic tomatoes? How does it work?
- fw2.2 gene: produces a protein that inhibits cell division: more protein = less cellular division = smaller fruit
–> fw2.2 promoter region: on/off switch
How did researchers modify the tomato to identify the variation in the promoter region of the tomatoes?
Modified the domestic tomato by adding the gene to inhibit cell division and create a smaller domestic tomato
- reveals difference in the allele of this gene may be causing size difference
What were the possible routes from small tomatoes to large tomatoes?
- different alleles were present in wild populations
- both large and small fruits were present and we cultivated the large ones - large-fruit alleles arose in already cultivated crops and we encouraged to propagate
Are domestic and wild tomatoes considered the same species? Why or why not?
- they are NOT even though they initially developed from the wild tomatoes
- variation present can lead to modifications in that population over time and even to new species
Was the transition of wild tomatoes to domestic tomatoes because of artificial or natural selection?
- can be both!
- capable of creating entire new species!
What are the steps to the logic of evolution by natural selection?
- individuals within populations differ from one another (variation)
- variations are, at least in part, passed parent to offspring (inheritance)
- some individuals have higher fitness
- The successful individuals succeeded due to variant traits not just luck
What are the 3 components of natural selection?
- variation
- inheritance
- differential reproductive success
Do researchers study traits or the whole organism?
- TRAITS not the organism as a whole
True or false: populations evolve not individuals
true! natural selection works via variation within the populations
What is a major source of variation?
mutations: occur randomly and independently of whether they will be favoured by NS
Do mutations occur for natural selection to select for?
No! They occur independently of whether it will selected for by NS
True or false: Natural selection sorts on phenotype not genotype
- true!
Can phenotype be determine by the environment?
yes! Phenotype can be determined by the environment and by genotype
Explain the purpose of the Oldfield mice experiment as well as their characteristics
- Q: How does natural selection affect coat colour in Oldfield mice ?
and
Does natural selection favour a match between coat and environment colour? - preyed upon by visual hunters, 2 colours
–> darker inland form and lighter beach dwellers - there is variation present within species and within respective populations!
Do the oldfield mice meet the requirements for evolution by natural selection?
- must ask whether it meets requirements
- variation, heritability, fitness (it does, explain why)
Are oldfield mice coat colours inherited?
unsure. we must identify genes involved!
- when the variation is due to genetic variation the trait is heritable
- if the coat colour is light due to environmental factors like sun bleaching it is not heritable
How do we test if variation is heritable or environmental in a species?
- by identifying the genes involved!
What are the genes identified in oldfield mice?
–> Mc1R: controls type of pigment produced and deposited
- two pigments: dark (eumalin) and light (phaeomelanin)
- depends on alpha-MSH which binds to mc1R receptor to produce eumelanin (dark)
- if alphas MSH does not bind to Mc1R produced phaeomelanin (light)
–> also present: agouti
- produces ADP that competes with alpha MSH
- bind to MC1R and blocks production of eumelanin
Describe the role of genes in oldfield mice and how we can determine if variation is genetic or environmental?
- single mutation in Mc1R sequences: reduces ability to bind alpha-MSH
- mutation in regularity region of agouti: higher expression levels of ADP
- it is heritable!
describe how they measured differential reproductive success in old field mice. How did they ensure it was cause and effect rather than correlation?
- 3 different environments: light and dark mice in arena, measured survivors - percent of capture was higher for the mismatched mouse
- removed other factors: silicone mice in natural environments
- same results, match background = higher fitness
How might matching background coats developed in mice? was it quick or slow?
–> say mice with matching produced 1% more offspring than mismatched that gene would double in frequency every 70 gneeraostiond and in a population of 10000 gene frequency could read 100% in a few thousand generations
What are some potentially altering effects that may have altered results of the oldfield mice test?
0- researchers studied traits not entire organisms
- populations evolve not inviduals
- mutations can occur randomly and independalty
- NS sorts on phenotypes not genotype
Describe the case study of beak shape in relation to seed size, and whether natural selection occurred here (did it meet requirements)
Quick Facts
NS acts on individuals, but its consequences occur in populations
Eg; finches with larger beaks survived dorught while others starved, leading to a change in average beak size of the population
NS acts on phenotypes, but evolution consists of changes in allele frequencies
Eg; beak size was the trait being selected but without heritability (a genetic component) evolution could not have occurred
NS acts on existing traits but novel traits can evolve
Eg; new mutations can arise in future generations, and sexual reproduction can lead to new genetic combinations
NS lacks foresight and does not lead to perfection
Is natural selection synonymous with evolution? if no, what is the difference?
NO! NS is a tool used by evolution
- natural selection occurs within a generation, one of several processes of evolution
- evolution: occurs across generations, results from any of the major processes
Is it possible for natural selection to occur without evolution?
yes. for example if big beaked birds survive drought and have children who don’t have big beaks, then it wasn’t heritable and evolution / change will not occur
Why might natural selection not create perfect structures? Provide an example
- NS lacks foresight: does not act in the long run but in the short term, conditions may change later on and a species may be less well suited for the future
ex: blind spot in eye