evidence common law authorities Flashcards
Em v R
was it given of own free volition
Lee
Induced by promise
R v Long
Was the confession reliable
Ireland
Evidence obtained against public policy
Christie/Lee
Improperly obtained evidence
R v Noonan
Presumption of continuance
Anchor Products v Hedges
Res Ipsa Loquitur
McKinney
improperly obtained confessions
Longman
forensic disadvantage
Domican
direction when there’s ID evidence
Alexander v R
Visual ID
Weal v Bottom
Expert by experience
R v Holmes
Lay opinion
Makita v Sprowles
Expert evidence
West Oz v Montani hearsay exception
declaration as to cause of death
The Henry Coxon hearsay exception
In the course of duty
Higham v Ridgway hearsay exception
against pecuniary interest
Edwards v R hearsay exception
Informal admission
Perry v R hearsay exception
A persons contemporaneous statements about his own health. A person’s instantaneous reaction to an event such as nausea, physical pain, or overpowering depression.
Pallante v Stadiums
evidence in previous proceedings
Holloway v McFeeters
Assertion by conduct
Ratten v R
Implied hearsay
Teper v R
Reasons why hearsay is unreliable
Subramamian
Hearsay
R v Rowton
evidence of an accused’s good character
DPP v Boardman
guard against forbidden reasoning
Butera v DPP
Best evidence rule
R v Parker
prior consistent statements
R v Chin
Case splitting
Mooney v James
Leading questions @ common law
Piddington v Bennett & Wood
Finality rule
R v Umanski
Bias statement is an indication a witness may be hostile
McLellan v Bowyer
Prior inconsistent statement is an indication a witness may be hostile
R v Hayden & Slattery
Definition of hostile witness
Browne v Dunn
Fairness in cross examination
Dyers v R
Must not speculate about what a witness might have said
Jones v Dunkel
Inference for a failure to give evidence
Rhesa Shipping v Edmunds
Perfectly appropriate to find in favour of the defendant in a finely balanced case
Briginshaw
Civil standard of proof
More persuasion if criminal or fraudulent allegations exist
Davies v Taylor
odds of 51 to 49
May v O’Sullivan
No case to answer
Woolmington v DPP
Criminal standard of proof
Weissensteiner
When a judge may comment on a failure to give evidence
Smith v R
Sufficient relevance
R v Stephenson
sufficient relevance
IMM
Relevant evidence must be accepted as true
Re Van Beelan
Definition of relevance.
Common law test to refresh memory
what’s the opposite of hearsay
What’s the opposite of original evidence