End of Year Exam!! Flashcards
EXPLANATION
- To give an explanation is to give a cause or a reason that attempts to make sense of some puzzling phenomenon
- In an explanation we do know that the explanandum is TRUE
- Explanations are used to account for how and why something occurs and to draw out the meaning in a message
- An explanation may be put forward for something that is in fact false
- Wherever the explanandum is true/ puzzling, find an explanation
EXPLANANDUM
- the phenomenon we are trying to explain
EXPLANANS
- the statement that is supposed to explain that phenomenon
ARGUMENT
- In an argument we act as if we DON’T know whether the conclusion is true
- 3 parts: 1. Reason 2. Inference 3. Conclusion
FACT
- A fact is a reality that cannot be logically disputed or rejected
TRUTH CLAIM
- A truth claim is a proposition or statement that a particular person or belief system holds to be true
TYPES OF EXPLANATION
- Intentional
- Causal
- Functional
INTENTIONAL EXPLANATION
- Is an explanation that gives a persons reasons for acting
- E.g. The coach dropped Stella from the netball because he said she needed to regain some form in lower divisions
- By acting that the reasons that are given are the real reasons for why the person acted in that way, we are accepting an intentional explanation
GOOD INTENTIONAL EXPLANATION
- The reason given was believed to be true
- And it was the real reason for the action
- E.g. (1) The coach really believes that Sharon needs to regain form in the lower divisions (2) That belief was the real reason (not a pseudo-reason) for why he dropped her
CAUSAL EXPLANATION
- Is an explanation that puts forward a possible cause of some phenomenon
- E.g. The plane crashed because the pilot lost control while approaching the runway
GOOD EXPLANATION (CAUSAL/FUNCTIONAL)
- The explanans must be TRUE
- The connection between explanans and the explanandum must be STRONG
FUNCTIONAL EXPLANATION
- This is used to explain the role that something plays in a system
- E.g. Cars have laminated windscreens because laminated glass doesn’t no shatter on impact in a collision
- E.g. Kangaroos have large tails because the tail enables them to keep their balance whilst hopping
- Occur when we are explaining the workings of an human artifact/natural system
INTERPRETATION EXPLANATION
- Interpret means to ‘make sense’ or ‘give it a meaning’
- E.g. foreign language
- Interpreter make sense of A’s ‘foreign words’ by translating them into a language that B can understand
- Interpretations are possible only when there is an element of AMBUITY/UNCLARITY in a situation/statement
HERMENEUTICS
- Is the general theory of interpretation
- Began from the need to interpret the Bible (Jewish and Christian)
- Hans-Georg Gadamer; demonstrated hermeneutics is NOT a science, partially dependent on the background, culture and viewpoint of the person and therefore there may be no right (in interpretation of something)
HERMENEUTIC CIRCLE
- Problem in the process of interpretation
- Occurs when a part of the text can be understood only when we have an understanding of the whole text of which it is part
- We may never be able to make sense of some texts
- In interpreting a text we alternate between trying to grasp the meaning of the whole and trying to make sense of the various parts
INTERPRETING LITERATURE
- Internal or External
- Not mutually exclusive
INTERNAL INTERPRETATION
- When literature is taken on its own (external evidence ignored)
- Understanding text in this way is an example of a non-vicious hermeneutic cycle (in interpretation)
- Bears a close resemblance to the topic of ‘functional explanation’
EXTERNAL INTERPRETATION
- Divided into TWO approaches
• The AUTHOR’S intentions (whatever they may be)
• The CONTEXT of the work - Examples of ‘hermeneutic circle’ approach to interpretation
- Good interpretation
• Seek COHERENCE between the parts and the whole
• Have COMPLETENESS must account for all parts
EXTERNAL INTERPRETATION – AUTHOR’S INTENTIONS
- Works of literature are human constructions, (all human constructions involve INTENTIONS)
- Author’s intentions aren’t always known (some being anonymous, and intentions aren’t directly knowable)
- Intentions should be compared with external evidence (the text)
EXTERNAL INTERPRETATION – CONTEXT
- Refers to the circumstances relevant to something under consideration (contextual circumstances are outside the text)
TRUTH IN LITERATURE
- A matter of COHERENCE between sentences in the text
- Rather than CORRESPONDANCE between the writings and the outside world (which they refer to)
COHERENCE THEORY OF TRUTH
- Regards truth as coherence within some specified set of sentences, propositions or beliefs
- There is no single set of such “logical universes”
CORRESPONDENCE THEORY OF TRUTH
- States that the truth or falsity of a statement is determined only by how it relates to the world and whether it accurately describes (i.e., corresponds with) that world
- Claim that true beliefs and true statements correspond to the actual state of affairs
MODERNISM
- Goes back to the 18th century
- Progress in
• Rise of physical science/scientific way of viewing
• Decline in religious zeal and superstition
• Industrialization/Mechanized production
• Creation of civil liberties
• Expansion of political rights
• Attempts to abolish the slave trade
• ‘The Enlightenment’
POSTMODERNISM
- First meaning to express a reaction against the rigid formality and dehumanized coldness of some ‘modern’ architecture
- Applied to a philosophical position largely concerned with the interpretation of literature and pop culture
- Rejects the Enlightenment ideal of ‘reason’
- Claim that reason is too restrictive
- In literature rejects some of the ways that truth has been represented
PHILOSOPHICAL SCEPTICISM
- Language isn’t fixed and definable
- Language isn’t based on how the world is; human construct
- Language dictates how we see; no experience of the word is language free
PERSONHOOD
BIOLOGICAL - A member of the species HOMOSAPIENS PSYCHOLOGICAL - A conscious or rational being LEGAL/ETHICAL - Having certain rights and duties
‘AN INDIVIDUAL’ 5 MEANINGS
THE NON-SOCIAL INDIVIDUAL
- A person who has no desire to associate with other people, who would rather live alone if it were possible; a hermit
THE ANTI SOCIAL INDIVIDUAL
- Someone who seeks disrupt social life, and who will happily take the benefits of society while seeking to avoid any of the burdens
THE SOCIAL INDIVIDUALIST
- A person who is happy to live within the framework of society, but who wishes to be seen as possible as possible from other people; a harmless eccentric
THE SOCIAL INDIVIDUAL
- Someone who shares the general values of their society, seeking neither to be different from others nor to be the same as them
THE CONFORMIST INDIVIDUAL
- Someone who accepts the general values of society and who weeks to be the same as others, who feels uncomfortable if they are not doing what the majority do
PLATO’S IDEA OF SOCIETY
- Formulated the idea that society is like a kind of contract
- Introduced of what we would call the division of labour
- Various roles played by various people
- If there is an inner harmony between the various parts then they form a single entity
- Name for this desirable harmony is ‘justice’
PLATO’S IDEA OF JUSTICE
- Justice is the glue that keeps society together
ARISTOLE ON SOCIETY
- Polis ‘City State’
- All human beings are social beings, and that human community is a good thing
- That not all forms of society are equally good
- ‘Functions’ that every society must fulfill
- Education should be provided by the state and not just the family
- All societies have the same aim/purpose
- Happiness; a realization and perfect practice of excellence
- One society will differ from another because ‘different mean seek after happiness in different ways’
JUSTICE
- Is the ethnical concept by which we make decisions on the distribution of decision making right and on the exercise of power
- Personal virtue, but a concept that applies to societies as a whole
DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE
- Every kind of society involves the distribution of benefits and burdens
COMMUNATIVE JUSTICE
- Justice that applies to contracts and exchange
IDEOLOGY
- Is a system of beliefs that imposes an unjust way of life on a community
- ‘One person’s ideology is another person’s idea of the truth’
ETHICS
- Set of concepts, rules, principles and practices (and the decisions based on them) that are used to make human social life function successfully
- Enters into how we relate to the natural world and, for those who have religious beliefs, how we relate to region
ETHICS 4 PARTS
- Rights/Duties/Obligations
- Virtues and Vices
- Care and Caring
- Principles
DUTIES AND OBLIGATIONS
- Synonyms
- Bind us to act in certain ways
NEGATIVE OBLIGATION
- Obliged NOT to do something
- My right to free speech places others in my society under a constraint in that they should not stop me from speaking. But if in exercising my right to speak I unfairly defame someone (give false evidence that causes others to think less of them) then I have infringed their right to keep a good reputation.
POSITIVE OBLIGATION
- Obliged to ACT
- We all have a right to life. If I am injured and in danger of dying, other people have an obligation to try to help me. If you know HOW to save me you have a stronger obligation to try to help me.
MORAL JUDGEMENTS
- Individual Actions
- On Character; trustworthy/fair minded/thoughtful/prudish