Education Flashcards
Functionalist- Durkheim.
Identified 2 main functions of education.
Social Solidarity
Specialist Skills
What is social solidarity?
Functionalist view
Durkheim
individual member must feel themselves to be part of the community. Without social solidarity, social life and cooperation would be impossible because each individual would pursue their own (selfish) desires
How does education enforce social solidarity?
Functionalist view
Durkheim
By transmitting the society’s culture (beliefs and values) from one generation to the next. Teaching history instils a sense of shared heritage and a commitment to wider society groups.
What is society in miniature?
Functionalist view
Durkheim
The belief that school prepares us for wider society. Both in school and work people must interact.
Specialist Skills
Functionalist view
Durkheim
Education teaches individuals the specialist knowledge and skills that they need to play their part in the social division of labour
Functionalist- Parsons.
What is meritocracy?
Meritocracy is when everyone is given an equal opportunity, and individuals achieve rewards through their own efforts.
How does Parsons view school?
Functionalist view
Parson sees school as acting as a bridge between the family and wider society. This bridge is needed because family and society operate on different principles. Children need to be able to cope with the wider world
How is a child judged in the family?
Functionalist view- Parsons
In the family, the child is judged by particularistic standards. This is when rules apply only to that particular child.
In the family, what is a child’s status?
Functionalist view- Parsons
In the family, the child has an ascribed status. This means their status is fixed by birth, they are born with their status.
In school and wider society, how are people judged?
Functionalist view- Parsons
In school and wider society, people are judged by universalistic standards. This is when the same rules/laws apply to everyone.
In school and wider society, what is a person’s status?
Functionalist view- Parsons
In school and wider society, a person’s status is achieved. This means their status is achieved through their own personal efforts, such as job promotions and university qualifications.
What is role allocation?
Davis and Moore- functionalists
Selecting and allocating pupils to their future work roles. Schools help to match them to the job they are best suited to.
What do Davis and Moore believe?
Functionalists
They believe that inequality is necessary to ensure that the most important roles in society are filled by the most talented people. School encourages people to compete for those more important jobs by completing examinations.
What is human capital?
Paul Blau - functionalist
The economy’s worker’s skills
How does meritocratic society use its human capital?
Paul Blau- functionalist
It enables each person to be allocated to the job best suited to their abilities. This makes the most efficient use of their talents and maximises their productivity.
New right perspective on education (similar to functionalists)
Believe some people are naturally more talented than others, system is run on meritocratic principles, preparing young people for work, instill national identity and shared values
New Right main perspective on education
That the education system is not achieving their goals (eg: to prepare students for work), because it is run by the state. They believe state school are unresponsive and inefficient
What is New Right’s solution?
Marketisation of education- brings about competition between schools, which will lead to more consumer choice, and enable the schools to meet the needs of pupils, parents and employers, and bring out greater diversity
Consumer Choice- Chubb and Moe
Why do they believe the state system has failed?
They believe state schools have not created equal opportunity, failed the disadvantaged groups and failed to teach students skills for the economy. They think private schools are more answerable, and provide higher quality education
Introduction to the market system- Chubb and Moe
Consumer Choice
Puts control in the consumer’s hands to allow them to shape schools to meet their own needs and this would improve quality and efficiency
Consumer Choice- Chubb and Moe
By giving each family a voucher to spend on buying education from a school of their choice, this forces schools to be more responsive regarding parent wishes, because the vouchers would be the school’s main source of income. Schools would have to attract new customers by improving their ‘product’.
Two roles of the state
Althusser
1) impose framework within schools which they have to compete (ofsted inspections, league table of exam results)- helps parents make a more informed choice of school
2) transmit a shared culture
New Right perspective of the roles of the state
They think the state should affirm the national identity
Critiques of New Right-
(Marxists critic)
Marxists say that education does not impose a shared culture, instead it imposes a culture of the dominant minority ruling class, devaluing the culture of the working class
Critiques of New Right
what is the real reason for low educational standards?
Critics argue that the real cause of low educational standards is due to social inequality and inadequate funding for state schools
Critiques of New Right
Gewirtz and Ball
Gewirtz and Ball argue that the competition between schools only benefits the middle class, who use cultural and economic advantages to access more desirable schools
Critics of the Functionalist perspective
New right critic
New right critic argues that the educational system fails to prepare young people for work.
Critics of functionalists
Marxist
Marxists criticise functionalists as they believe that education only implements the ideology of the ruling class, not society as a whole
Marxist perspective of education
They believe that education is functioning to prevent revolution and maintain capitalist- preventing the proletariat from rebelling against the bourgeoisie.
Althusser- Marxist
Believes the state consists of 2 elements, to provide the bourgeoisie with power
Repressive state apparatus
Ideological state apparatus
What is the repressive state apparatus?
Althusser
Bourgeoisie maintain control through power or the threat of it (police, army, courts)
What is the ideological state apparatus?
Althusser
Bourgeoisie maintain power by controlling people’s ideas, values and beliefs (brainwashing)
What does the educational system perform?
Althusser
Education reproduces class inequality, by transmitting it from generation to generation
Education legitimates class inequality by producing ideologies- brainwashing workers to accept that inequality is inevitable and they deserve their subordinate position. If they accept these ideas, they are less likely to challenge capitalism
Bowels and Gintis
They argue that capitalism needs a workforce that includes alienated and exploited workers, willing to accept hard work, low pay and orders. Education must reproduce obedient workers that accept inequality