DL Arbitration and Mediation Flashcards
What is the UDRP?
The Uniform Domain Name Dispute Resolution Process was adopted by ICANN in 1999 on
the basis of recommendations made by WIPO in the First WIPO Internet Domain Name
Process.
Usually cases of:
- bad-faith
- abusive registration
- use of domain names
- cybersquatting
How many cases have been processed?
35000 UDRP cases have been processed
APPLICABILITY OF THE UDRP
The UDRP applies to registrations in generic top-level domains (gTLDs), such as .com, .net
and .org
RIGHTS ACTIONABLE UNDER THE UDRP
The UDRP requires a complainant to have rights in a trade or service mark
-
Personal names, descriptive terms
and geographical identifiers (though not actionable as such) may be actionable to the extent
that they have acquired secondary meaning (through appropriately evidenced use) as a
mark.
How it works?
- the rights-holding complainant submits its electronic complaint to the provider, (which has 5 days to conclude an administrative compliance review of the complaint.)
Typically, this will
include registrar verification of relevant registrant name and contact information, along with a request for confirmation that the
disputed domain name has been locked pending resolution of the dispute. In the event that any
administrative deficiencies are identified in the complaint, the Complainant has five days within which to correct these. On
successful conclusion of the
administrative compliance check, the provider proceeds to formally
commence the proceedings by forwarding a copy of the Complaint (including any Annexes) to the Respondent by email. The provider
also sends written notice of the dispute to the Respondent to any
available postal address and/or fax number.
The respondent has 20 days to file a response from the date the Provider notifies the respondent of a filed complaint. The Provider then appoints an independent
single- or three-member panel to decide the case.
A reasoned decision is taken within two weeks by the panel. If the panel orders the transfer or cancellation of the domain name (these are the sole remedies available, with monetary damages, in particular, being excluded), the registrar is obliged to implement the decision, except if the losing domain name registrant files a case concerning the disputed domain name in a competent court against the complainant within 10 business days of notification of the panel decision. The UDRP Provider posts notice of the filing of a case and the full text of decisions on its website.
UDRP SUBSTANTIVE ELEMENTS
the complainant must establish that the following three
cumulative criteria are met:
(i) the domain name is identical or confusingly similar to a trademark or service mark in
which the complainant has rights; and
(ii) the registrant of the domain name has no rights or legitimate interests in respect of
the domain name; and
(iii) the domain name has been registered and is being used in bad faith.
Identity or Confusing Similarity under the UDRP
this element is a standing requirement. he threshold test for confusing similarity under the UDRP to
involve a direct comparison between the trademark and the alphanumeric string of the
domain name at issue to assess likelihood of Internet-user confusion. The test is usually
applied without regard to website content, or to the relevant gTLD
to satisfy the UDRP test:
- the addition of common
- dictionary
- descriptive
- negative terms
What is pejorative term in a domain name ?
{trademark}sucks.com and will be considered confusingly similar to the complainant’s trademark.
the lack of Rights and Legitimate Interests when there are no: ?
- the domain name in connection with a bona fide offering of goods or services,
- legitimate non-commercial use
- fair use
On who falls burden of proof under UDRP ?
on the Complainant,
where a Complainant makes an initial prima facie case that
the Respondent lacks rights or legitimate interests in a disputed domain name, the burden of
production on this element generally passes to the Respondent.
How to defined the rights and legitimate interests ?
in order to find rights or legitimate interests in a domain name
based on the generic or dictionary meaning of a word or phrase contained therein, the
domain name would need to be genuinely used or at least demonstrably intended for such
use in connection with the relied-upon meaning (and not, for example, to trade off third-party
rights in such word or phrase). (e.g. a respondent may well have a right to a domain name
“apple” if it uses it for a genuine site for apples, but not if the site is aimed at selling
computers or MP3 players, for example, or an inappropriate other purpose).
Bad faith for UDRP is ?
The requirement under the UDRP for registration and use in bad faith has, for the most part,
been interpreted by Panels as imposing a cumulative (or conjunctive) requirement.
Examples of the bad faith?
indications that the
domain name has been registered for the purpose of selling it to the complaining trademark
owner or their competitor, or used for attracting visitors to the registrant’s site for commercial
gain by creating a likelihood of confusion with complainant’s trademark.
Precedent?
The UDRP does not use a doctrine of precedent, but still consider decisions with similar fact situations.
Appeals and Refilings
The UDRP does not include an appeals process as such - parties who wish to do so may pursue a matter de novo in court.
What is objectives and the main areas of activity of WIPO?
WIPO’s principal objective is to promote the protection of intellectual property throughout
the world through cooperation among States, and, where appropriate, in collaboration
with other international organizations.
What kind of ADR procedures offered by the WIPO AnM center?
§
What is the advantages of ADR procedures ?
§
What kind of disputes may be submitted to ADR by WIPO AnM Center?
§
What is WIPO?
is an independent, intergovernmental organization established by a Convention signed in Stockholm on 14 July, 1967 and entered into force in 1970. it forms part of the
United Nations system of organizations and has its headquarters in Geneva,
Switzerland. WIPO comprises 188 Member States. The executive head of WIPO is the Director
General, who is elected by WIPO’s Member States. The secretariat of WIPO is the
International Bureau comprising over 1,000 staff members.
What WIPO promotes ?
- innovation and creativity throughout protection IP rights. protection is means to encourage creative activity, industrialization, investment and honest trade. They support and encourages technological innovation and artistic creativity.
What is the main areas of activity of WIPO?
- promote the protection of IPR
- encourages the conclusion of new international treaties and the modernization of national statutes.
- provides technical assistance to developing countries, assembles and disseminates information, and maintains services that facilitate the obtaining of protection for inventions, trademarks and industrial designs.
- promotes other administrative cooperation among Member States
How much WIPO administrate of treaties ?
more than 20 treaties and conventions, e.g Paris, Bern, Madrid, PCT treaties.
What is WIPOs cooperation for development ?
- promoting the protection of creative intellectual activity
- facilitating the transfer of technology related to industrial property to the developing countries in order to accelerate their economic, social and cultural development, and organizing easier access to the scientific and technological information contained in millions of patent documents around the word
Who funds WIPO?
- WIPO provides its services to its Members States and to individuals and enterprises who are constituents of those States
What are the main objectives and areas of activity of WIPO?
- providing protection to IPR worldwide through cooperation among States and with other International organization.
- administering more than 20 international treaties
- provides technical assistance to developing countries
- assembles and disseminates IP information
- maintains services that facilitate the obtaining of protection for inventions, trademarks and industrial designs
- provides alternative dispute resolution services AnM Center
What kind of procedure WIPO Center offers?
- Meditation
- Arbitration
- Expedited Arbitration
- Mediation followed by arbitration
- Expert Determination ??
what is Mediation?
is a consensual process in which a neutral person facilitates discussion and negotiation between the parties so that the parties themselves can solve their problem. The
parties design both the process and the terms and conditions of their solution to their
problem. In contrast to adversarial procedures, such as litigation or arbitration, a mediator
cannot impose a settlement on the parties. Also, any party can abandon the mediation at
virtually any time before signing a settlement agreement.
What is Arbitration ?
Arbitration is a consensual procedure in which a neutral person or persons impose a
binding decision on the parties. Whereas the parties may design the procedure, the
arbitrator designs the terms and conditions of the decision. Also, after a party has agreed to
arbitrate, the party cannot unilaterally withdraw from the arbitration process without risking
an adverse decision on substantive issues.
What is Expedited arbitration?
Expedited arbitration is a consensual procedure in which the rendering of a decision by
the arbitrator is accelerated. In the WIPO expedited arbitration model, only one
arbitrator serves. Also, time periods are shortened, and evidentiary hearings are
condensed.
What is Mediation followed by arbitration ?
In mediation followed by arbitration (sometimes known as “med-arb”) mediation is
undertaken first. If the dispute is not entirely settled by way of mediation, arbitration
ensues to resolve remaining issues.
What is Expert determination?
Expert determination is a consensual procedure in which a technical, scientific or related
business issue between the parties is submitted, by agreement of the parties, to an expert
who makes a determination on the matter referred to it. The determination is binding,
unless the parties agreed otherwise.
Which dispute resolution procedures are offered by the Center?
The alternative dispute resolution (ADR) procedures offered by the Center are mediation,
arbitration, expedited arbitration, mediation followed by (expedited) arbitration and expert
determination.
1. Mediation is a non-binding procedure in which a neutral intermediary, the mediator,
assists the parties in reaching a mutually satisfactory settlement of the dispute.
2. Arbitration is a neutral procedure in which the dispute is submitted to one or more
arbitrators who make a binding decision (an “award”) on the dispute.
3. Expedited arbitration is a form of arbitration that is carried out in a short time and at
reduced cost.
4. Mediation followed by (expedited) arbitration is a procedure that combines mediation
and, where the dispute is not settled through the mediation within a period of time agreed
by the parties, (expedited) arbitration.
5. Expert determination is a consensual procedure in which a technical, scientific or
related business issue between the parties is submitted, by agreement of the parties, to an
expert who makes a determination on the matter referred to it. The determination is
binding, unless the parties agreed otherwise.
What is Good offices ?
the Center will provide its “good offices” whereby it will endeavor to act as intermediary in convening discussions between the parties to a dispute to submit their dispute to a WIPO DRP.
How and with what WIPO Center facilitate the administration of cases?
- assisting parties to select mediators, arbitrators, and experts from the Centre database
- advising on the application of the relevant rules,
- setting the neutral’s fees
- administering the financial aspects of the proceedings,
- coordinating case communications,
providing free meeting rooms when the proceedings take place in Geneva or arranging meeting rooms when they place elsewhere - ensuring that procedures are conducted efficiently
What is the WIPOs List of Neutrals ?
it is the generalist where contains highly specialized practitioners and experts, covering the entire legal and technical spectrum of intellectual property. 1500 independent WIPO arbitrators and mediators from a hundreds countries.
What is Tailor-made procedures?
The Center is involved in the development and implementation of various tailor-made
procedures. Such procedures, which may be based on or be different from arbitration
and mediation, are designed for particular categories of intellectual property disputes. e.g UDRP - (certain abusive practices in the domain name system)
List the services provided by the Center
The Center provides the following services:
- Drafting of contract clauses
- “Good Offices”
- Administration of cases
- WIPO List of Neutrals
- Tailor-made procedures
- Conferences and training
- Publications
In the absence of a prior contractual clause which refers future disputes to the WIPO
Rules, can parties submit an existing dispute to WIPO Mediation, WIPO Arbitration
or WIPO Expedited Arbitration?
Yes, for existing disputes, parties may conclude a submission agreement providing for the
referral of the dispute to one of the WIPO dispute resolution procedures. The Center
provides recommended submission agreements (for existing disputes), in addition to
recommended contract clauses (for future disputes). See the Center’s web site at
http://www.wipo.int/amc/en/clauses/index.html.
Advantages of Dispute Resolution Procedures Offered by the Center ?
- Cost saving
- Flexibility
- Confidentiality
- Expertise
- Single forum
Types of Disputes that May be Submitted to Arbitration or Mediation ?
contractual disputes (e.g. patent licensing
agreements, trademark co-existence agreements, software licences, distribution agreements
for pharmaceutical products and research and development agreements) and noncontractual
disputes (e.g. patent infringement).
Can the dispute resolution procedures administered by the Center be used when the
dispute relates to issues other than intellectual property?
The Rules governing the WIPO dispute resolution procedures contain features that are
especially suitable for disputes involving intellectual property, such as licensing
agreements or other forms of transaction relating to patents, trademarks, copyright or
know-how. However, the WIPO procedures can be used for the resolution of any type of
commercial disputes, including those not involving intellectual property.
Who May Refer Disputes to the Center?
The dispute resolution procedures and resources of the Center are open to all persons
and entities regardless of national affiliation. A submitting party (or parties) need not be
connected in any way with a Member State or a State that is a party to any treaty or convention administered by WIPO.
Private entities
Individuals, enterprises, and other entities having a recognized legal personality may
submit disputes to the procedures administered by the Center. Also, they may seek the
good offices services of the Center.
States
When a State enters into a contract, it may be a party to a dispute subject to a procedure
administered by the Center if the State has validly expressed its consent in writing to
refer any dispute arising from that contract to the procedure.
Can a State be party to a procedure administered by the Center?
The WIPO dispute resolution procedures are open to any person or entity, regardless of
nationality or domicile. Normally, WIPO dispute clauses are included by corporations in
their intellectual property contracts. However, a State may also be a party to a WIPO
arbitration or mediation procedure, if that State has validly expressed its consent in
writing to refer the dispute to such WIPO procedure.
Summary of module 1
WIPO provides dispute resolution services through its Arbitration and
Mediation Center.
· The Center administers alternatives to court litigation for the resolution
of commercial disputes between private parties with a focus on
intellectual property.
· The dispute resolution procedures offered by the Center are mediation,
arbitration, expedited arbitration, mediation followed by arbitration,
expert determination and variations on these procedures.
· Parties can draw upon the Center’s list of arbitrators and mediators
specialized in intellectual property.
· Benefits of WIPO arbitration and mediation procedures over court
litigation include: the possibility of resolving multiple disputes in a
single forum, flexibility and confidentiality of the proceedings, the
possibility to appoint an expert neutral and the opportunity for cost
savings.
What is the main features of mediation ?
§
List the main steps in a WIPO mediation ?
§
What is the role of mediation ?
§
What is the role of the WIPO AnM Center in a mediation ?
§
Is Mediation is consensual ?
so Mediation is process, agreed to by the parties, in which a neutral mediator facilitates communication, negotiation and dispute resolution by the parties themselves.
What is the parties process?
- the parties design the process
- choose the mediator
- define the problem
- select the issues
- consider each other’s real interests and needs
- explore and evaluate options
- find a solution to their problem
it is not constrained by pleadings, rigid rules, selected items of evidence, lawyers eloquence or limited forms of relief.
is it mediation is a binding processes ?
no it is not. the mediator cannot impose a solution on the parties. the only binding aspect consists in the terms and conditions of the ultimate settlement agreement. The settlement agreement is as binding as any other contract.
Who is the participants in the process of the mediation ?
mediation is the parties process, all parties participate - not merely their lawyers.
individual parties and senior representatives of organizations who are parties participate. e.g: insurers, indemnities, principal investors, controlling shareholders, principal lenders, licensors, principal vendors and principal customers.
What is mediation?
Mediation is a one of the several process in alternative dispute resolution provided by WIPO AnM Centre. In mediation process you have a mediator who helps to solve the issue between the parties through guiding them to find the best solution. Decision of the mediator is not biding but the settlement agreement between parties is equally binding as contract.
What is mediation?
Mediation is a non-binding procedure in which a neutral intermediary, the mediator, assists
the parties in reaching a settlement of the dispute. This means that, even though parties have
agreed to submit a dispute to mediation, they are not obliged to continue with the mediation
process after the first meeting. The non-binding nature of mediation means also that a
decision will not be imposed on the parties. In order for any settlement to be concluded, the
parties must voluntarily agree to accept it. By comparison to other more formal dispute
resolution procedures, mediation offers parties the option to reach an interest-based settlement
that will help to preserve future relationships.
Who should participate in the mediation? Should the business representatives of the
parties attend the mediation sessions? If so, why?
of course the mediation is a parties process all relevant players should participate in the mediation. Participation by, in particular, senior business representatives who are authorized
to settle and bind their respective companies, often facilitates reaching a settlement. It is
frequently the person-to-person meetings of business people that are key to the resolution of
difficult issues.
What is the benefits of Mediation ?
- Creating value
- Bringing parties together
- Intellectual property disputes
- International disputes
How mediation creates a value ?
- jointly control the process and the substantive resolution of their problem
- explicitly address their real interests and needs, not merely their factual and legal positions
- jointly explore creating or repairing various relationships
- deal together with related disagreements and other complexities
How mediation bring parties together ?
the proceedings polarize parties to become more like a partners rather than protagonists