Diversity, Difference and Mental Health Flashcards
What do we mean by valuing diversity and difference in mental health?
List 4 points
- Being sensitive to diversity
- Understanding diversity
- Personalising practice
- Improving services
- Being sensitive to diversity
- Understanding diversity
- Personalising practice
- Improving services
These are the 4 areas of…?
Valuing diversity and difference in mental health
How can we be sensitive to diversity?
By understanding the unique experiences, beliefs, values, and perspectives of individuals from diverse backgrounds
How can we understand diversity?
Recognising that mental health challenges and their impact can differ substantially depending on cultural context, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, gender, and sexual orientation
How can we personalise practice?
Recognising and incorporating various cultural, social, and individual preferences in mental health services
Recognising / respecting
diversity in mental health care leads to…?
List 3 points
- Increased help-seeking among underserved groups
- More accurate assessment
- Better engagement in intervention, therapeutic alliance, and outcomes (positive therapeutic change)
- Increased help-seeking among underserved groups
- More accurate assessment
- Better engagement in intervention, therapeutic alliance, and outcomes (positive therapeutic change)
These are the 3 advantages of…?
Recognising / respecting
diversity in mental health care
Describe the UK Equality Act 2010
- Individuals are afforded protection against discrimination, harassment and victimisation
- To help achieve equal opportunities across all aspects of society based on nine protected characteristics
What are the 9 protected characteristics included in the Equality Act 2010?
- Race
- Disability
- Religion or belief
- Gender
- Sexual orientation
- Sex
- Age
- Maternity and pregnancy
- Marriage
What is the aim of the UK Equality Act 2010?
Promote equality to groups of people who may be disadvantaged or under-represented or have particular needs
What are the 2 important implications of the UK Equality Act 2010?
- Discrimination based on mental health is an offence
- Consideration of protected characteristics and equal treatment within mental health services is a legal duty as well as good practice
What were the 2 main themes found in a systematic review of 14 studies by Rees et al. (2020) of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender communities’ MH experiences?
- Experienced stigma and discrimination when accessing MH care
- Professionals’ lack knowledge and understanding of LGBT people’s needs
List 5 ways lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender communities experience stigma and discrimination when accessing MH care
- Being positioned as different through use of heteronormative language etc.
- Felt ignored / mistreated due to sexuality or gender identification
- Often felt pathologized for their sexuality/gender identity and under-treated for primary mental health problems
- Or vulnerable if sexual orientation/gender were not acknowledged
- Some felt questions were over-intrusive
List 2 ways professionals’ lack knowledge and understanding of LGBT people’s needs
- A need for MH care that promotes equity, respect for diversity, & self-acceptance
- A need for culturally sensitive and LGBTQ+ friendly therapists that do not pathologise sexuality or assume that MH difficulties are due to sexual identity
What % of gay young people (who have not been bullied) are depressed?
a. 20%
b. 35%
c. 46%
d. 18%
b. 35%
The risk of suicide among gay men is ____ times the general population
2-4 times
The risk of suicide among _____ is 2-4 times the general population
Gay men
What contributes towards worse mental health among LGBTQ+ individuals?
List 5 factors
- Discrimination
- Social status
- Concealment
- Stigma
- Internalised homophobias
Common MH difficulties have steadily increased for ___
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
b. Women
Common MH difficulties have remained steady for ____
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
What are the 2 common MH difficulties faced by women?
- Depression
- Anxiety
Women are ___ times as likely to be diagnosed with anxiety
2 times
____ are 2x times as likely to be diagnosed with anxiety
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
b. Women
Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) and phobias more common among ____
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
b. Women
Post-traumatic stress disorder are more common among ____
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
b. Women
Post-traumatic stress disorder are more common among women
Why?
Majority of cases are due to sexual assault, which causes the trauma
What are the 2 mental health difficulties women experience due to their reproductive cycle?
- Prenatal depression
- Menopause (anxiety, mood)
_____ as many men as women die by suicide (linked to depression & adverse life events)
3x
3x as many ____ as women die by suicide (linked to depression & adverse life events)
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
___ % of referrals to psychological therapies in the NHS come from men
36%
36% of referrals to psychological therapies in the NHS come from men
What does this suggest?
Gender stereotypes contribute to low help seeking
_____ ______ contribute to low help seeking
Gender stereotypes
36% of referrals to psychological therapies in the NHS come from ____
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
___ are underrepresented in mental health services
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
Men are underrepresented in mental health services
Why?
Gender stereotypes
Men are expected by society to not show emotions and to cope with their difficulties alone
3x as likely to become alcohol dependent and frequently use drugs
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
Men are ____ times as likely to become alcohol dependent and frequently use drugs
3 times
More likely compulsorily detained under the Mental Health Act
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
Describe Women’s MH difficulties
List 5
- Common MH difficulties have steadily increased for women but remain steady for men
- 2x as likely diagnosed with anxiety
- Obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) and phobias more common
- Post-traumatic stress disorder (20.4% vs 8.1% for men)
- Reproductive cycle: Perinatal depression, menopause (anxiety, mood)
Describe Men’s MH difficulties
List 4
- 3x as many men as women die by suicide (linked to depression & adverse life events)
- 36% of referrals to psychological therapies in the NHS come from men – gender stereotypes contribute to low help-seeking
- 3x as likely to become alcohol dependent and frequently use drugs
- More likely compulsorily detained under the Mental Health Act
True or False?
Many minorities have worse mental health compared with White British groups
True
______ individuals, esp men, are more likely to be diagnosed with psychosis (e.g. 6-9x more risk of
schizophrenia) and compulsorily admitted to hospital
a. Black
b. White
c. Asian
d. Hispanic
a. Black
____ individuals, esp men, are 6-9x more at risk of
schizophrenia
a. Black
b. White
c. Asian
d. Hispanic
a. Black
Black individuals, esp men, are 6-9x more at risk of
_____
Schizophrenia
Black individuals, esp men, are more likely to be diagnosed with ____ and compulsorily admitted to hospital
Psychosis
Children from most ethnic minority backgrounds showed more MH difficulties from ____ years
3-14
Compared to White British Individuals, which group is higher in common MH difficulties?
a. Black Men
b. Asian Men
c. Black Women
d. Asian Women
c. Black Women
What 3 minority groups reported higher mental wellbeing than other minority groups?
- Indian
- Pakistani
- African-Caribbean
What do these 3 minority groups have in common?
- Indian
- Pakistani
- African-Caribbean
They are minorities that reported higher mental wellbeing than other minority groups
What affects MH among individuals from ethnic minorities?
List 3 factors
- Racial discrimination
- Social and economic disadvantage
- Mental health stigma
How does Mental Health Stigma affect MH among individuals from ethnic minorities?
In certain cultures, people don’t believe in mental health difficulties and discourage seeking help
simply = When mental health is little recognised or shameful to discuss
What 3 factors leads to further isolation and deterioration in MH among minority groups?
- A worse MH care experience
- Poorer treatment outcomes
- Disengagement from mainstream services
What do these 3 factors lead to?
- A worse MH care experience
- Poorer treatment outcomes
- Disengagement from mainstream services
Further isolation and deterioration in MH among minority groups
When mental health is little recognised or shameful to discuss, what does this impact?
Minority groups’ ability and willingness to care for themselves and seek MH care
One of the goals of ____ treatment was more equitable access to therapy
IAPT
One of the goals of IAPT was …?
More equitable access to therapy
One of the goals of IAPT was more equitable access to therapy
What can help achieve this?
Allowing self-referral
(rather than being referred to by a GP)
Allowing self-referral may improve access for ethnic minorities, if access is affected by …?
Organizational discrimination
Allowing _____ may improve access for ethnic minorities, if access is affected by organizational discrimination
Self-referral
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, Black African, Asian and Mixed groups were less likely to …?
Self-refer to IAPT services
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, ____, ____ and ____ were less likely to self-refer to IAPT services
Black African, Asian and Mixed groups
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, Black Caribbean, Black Other & White Other were more likely to be…?
Referred by community services
(e.g. employment agency, voluntary organisations, criminal justice system)
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, ___, ____ and ____ were more likely to be referred by community services
(e.g. employment agency, voluntary organisations, criminal justice system)
Black Caribbean, Black Other & White Other
Black Caribbean, Black Other & White Other were more likely to be referred by community services
(e.g. employment agency, voluntary organisations, criminal justice system)
What are the implications of this?
MH difficulties may be severe by the time they are seen
MH difficulties may be severe by the time they are seen for Black Caribbean, Black Other & White Other
Why?
Because these groups are more likely to be referred by community services
(e.g. employment agency, voluntary organisations, criminal justice system)
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, all or almost all minority groups were …?
Less likely to receive an assessment and treated
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, ___ were less likely to receive an assessment and treated
All or almost all minority groups
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, recovery rates rose by 6% among ____ and _____ groups
Black and Asian groups
According to Harwood et al (2021), compared with the White British group, recovery rates rose by ____% among Black and Asian groups
6%
According to Bhavsar et al. (2021), compared to non-migrants, migrants residing in UK <10 years were less likely to use _____ treatment
IAPT psychological treatment
According to Bhavsar et al. (2021), compared to non-migrants, migrants residing in UK <10 years were less likely to use IAPT psychological treatment, and this was not explained by ___, ____ and ____
List 3 factors
- English proficiency
- Sociodemographic factors
- Migrating for asylum reasons
According to Bhavsar et al. (2021), compared to non-migrants, migrants residing in UK <10 years were less likely to use IAPT psychological treatment
What 3 factors can help explain these findings?
- Lack of information and effective communication about services
- Stigma within the community and wider society
- Mistrust trust of professionals
Among the lowest fifth of household income compared to the highest fifth, the risk of ____ is 9x higher
Psychotic disorders
Among the lowest fifth of household income compared to the highest fifth, the risk of psychotic disorders is ___ times higher
9 times
Among the lowest fifth of household income compared to the highest fifth, _____ is doubled
Common mental health problems
Among the lowest fifth of household income compared to the highest fifth, common mental health problems is ____
Doubled
True or False?
There is a complex relationship between Socioeconomic disadvantage and MH
True
List 2 reasons why there is a complex relationship between Socioeconomic disadvantage and MH
- MH can lead to difficulties gaining employment, substance abuse, poor handling of personal finances etc.
- Socioeconomic deprivation creates conditions of MH risk due to lack of resources, but also low social trust in area / high perceived crime
Socioeconomic deprivation creates conditions of MH risk due to …?
List 3 factors
- Lack of resources
- Low social trust in area
- High perceived crime in area
In IAPT, more socioeconomically disadvantaged individuals are less likely to…?
List 2 points
- Be referred for treatment
- Receive or complete treatment
Therapy may also be less effective for those from low socioeconomic backgrounds
Why?
Because of the multiple factors that might be affecting engagement in the process and/or one’s MH
e.g. someone who works 2 jobs have multiple stressors in their life, not enough time to get adequate MH care
Multiple factors that might be affecting engagement in the process and/or one’s MH
e.g. someone who works 2 jobs have multiple stressors in their life, not enough time to get adequate MH care
What is the result of this?
Therapy is likely to be less effective for those from low socioeconomic backgrounds
According to Alvarez-Galvez & Rojas-Garcia (2019), those belonging to more minoritised ‘categories’ have more depressive symptoms
This effect is stronger in which countries?
Eastern and Southern European countries
Those belonging to more minoritised ‘categories’ have more _____ symptoms, an effect that is stronger in Eastern and Southern European countries
Depressive
In the UK, men are less likely to seek / complete treatment for …?
Common MH difficulties
In the UK, ____ are less likely to seek / complete treatment for common MH difficulties
a. Men
b. Women
c. Non-binary
d. Children
a. Men
In the UK, men are less likely to seek / complete treatment for common MH difficulties
This is especially true if they are from …?
List 4 groups
- From minoritised ethnic background
- Of Muslim faith
- Unemployed
- Living in deprived neighbourhood
Various biological, social and cultural categories that are linked with social disadvantage/oppression often intersect or overlap
What does this suggest?
Disadvantage (or oppression) often comes from multiple
sources, not just one
Define cultural competence
The ability to understand the beliefs, backgrounds, and values of the client that may differ from our own
The ability to understand the beliefs, backgrounds, and values of the client that may differ from our own
This is known as…?
Cultural competence
Define Cultural Humility
An ongoing process of self- exploration and self-critique combined with a willingness to learn from others
An ongoing process of self- exploration and self-critique combined with a willingness to learn from others
This is known as…?
Cultural humility
List 3 ways we can practice cultural competence in MH
- Consider client’s lived experiences and their social and cultural contexts: culture, race, ethnicity, SES, and sexuality
- ‘Seeing’ all aspects of the client and taking into account the things that they value
- Being sensitive to the role of culture without stereotyping
List 3 ways we can practice cultural humility in MH
- Entering a relationship with the intention of honouring their beliefs, customs, and values
- Understand own beliefs, background and values as reflecting a specific cultural lens
- Understanding that culture influences help-seeking or care pathways; may bias the process of assessment and choice of management of MH care
Entering a relationship with the intention of honouring their beliefs, customs, and values
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
a. Cultural humility
Considers client’s lived experiences and their social and cultural contexts: culture, race, ethnicity, SES, and sexuality
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
b. Cultural competence
‘Seeing’ all aspects of the client and taking into account the things that they value
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
b. Cultural competence
Understand own beliefs, background and values as reflecting a specific cultural lens
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
a. Cultural humility
Understanding that culture influences help-seeking or care pathways; may bias the process of assessment and choice of management of MH care
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
a. Cultural humility
Being sensitive to the role of culture without stereotyping
What does this statement apply to?
a. Cultural humility
b. Cultural competence
c. Neither
d. Both
b. Cultural competence
Define culturally-adapted interventions
The systematic modification of a mental health programme or treatment that considers language, culture etc. in ways that are compatible with the client’s values, cognitions etc.
The systematic modification of a mental health programme or treatment that considers language, culture etc. in ways that are compatible with the client’s values, cognitions etc.
This is known as…?
Culturally-adapted interventions
People experiencing poverty, homelessness, intersecting oppressions (based e.g. on ethnicity, gender, sexuality, disability or class), and other forms of marginalisation remain highly under-represented in..?
List 2 types of research
- Mental health research
- Qualitative research on lived experiences, such as
experiences of recovery
Which 3 minority groups are highly under-represented in mental health research and qualitative research on lived experiences, such as
experiences of recovery?
- Poverty
- Homelessness
- Intersecting oppressions (based e.g. on ethnicity, gender, sexuality, disability or class)
What research informs policy and practice?
List 2
- Mental health research
- Qualitative research on lived experiences, such as
experiences of recovery
- Mental health research
- Qualitative research on lived experiences, such as
experiences of recovery
These researches inform ___ and ____
- Policy
- Practice
True or False?
An individual’s identity and their mental health are intrinsically tied
True
An individual’s identity and their mental health are intrinsically tied
What 3 points support this claim?
- Higher rates of mental health difficulties in particular groups
- Different life experiences, including discrimination and internalisation of stigma
- Mental health tends to affect different groups in different ways
True or False?
Healthcare systems are part of a system that is designed for the minority
False
Healthcare systems are part of a system that is designed for the majority
Healthcare systems are part of a system that is designed for the majority
What 3 points support this?
- Systemic factors lead to unfair access and treatment
- Actual experiences and perceptions of MH care professionals (part of the system)
- Despite attempts to improve access, IAPT has not really succeeded in doing so for under-represented ethnic groups
True or False?
Considering diversity is not a priority to meet individual’s mental health care needs
False
Considering diversity is critical to meeting individual’s mental health care needs
Considering diversity is critical to meeting individual’s mental health care needs
How can we achieve this? List 2 ways
- Train workforce
- Tailored services
Considering diversity is critical to meeting individual’s mental health care needs
List 3 ways we can train workforces
Train them in:
- Intersectionality
- Cultural competence
- Cultural humility
Considering diversity is critical to meeting individual’s mental health care needs
List 3 types of tailored services that would be useful
- Culturally adapted interventions
- Gendered services
- LGBTQ+ services