developmental methodologies Flashcards
what are the challenges to the assessment of socio-emotional problems in children
- Rapid developmental transitions
- Lack of data integration that come from different sources and methods
- Difficulty determining the level of impairment and functioning
what factors affect children’s accurate responding
Age Interviewing techniques Response formats Phrasing or complexity of questions Factual information versus abstract concepts
Methodological issues a researcher has to decide
Presence of observer (issues with reactivity)
Type of task (structured versus unstructured)
Location of observations (laboratory or participant’s home).
Coding categories
Exhaustive- Include all the behaviours
Mutually exclusive- Behaviours can be classified as falling into only one category
Reliable- Agreement between two or more observers
Examples of questionnaires
Parenting Stress Index
10 to 15 min
3 scales.
Alabama Parenting Questionnaire
8 to 12 years
10 to 15 min
3 scales.
What are screening questionnaires
How often a behaviour occurs or how representative is
Cut-offs are used to assign a risk status
Can be biased by parents’ mood or attributions of child’s behaviour
Caution when used in different cultures.
examples of screening questionnaires
Child Behaviour Checklist 18 to 60 months Parent or caregiver 15 to 20 min 3-point scale Cut-off available.
Infant-Toddler Social and Emotional Assessment 12 to 36 months Parent or caregiver 30 min to complete 3 point scale Cut offs for age and sex.
Selected cognitive ability measures
Bayley Scales of Infant Development
1 to 42 months
Assess behaviour during testing
Mental and PsychoMotor Developmental.
Mullen Scales of Early Learning 0 to 68 months Expressive and receptive language Visual reception Fine and gross motor.
Selected attachment measures
The Strange Situation
Lab assessment
9 to 18 months.
Attachment Q-Set
Home assessment
1 to 5 years.
Manchester Child Attachment Story Task
Home assessment
4 to 8 years.
Preschool Five Minute Speech Sample
Initial Statement Warmth Emotional over-involvement Relationship Critical comments Negative comments
what is initial statement
First thought expressed by the parent which is specifically about their child Global Rating 0=Positive relationship 1=Neutral relationship 2=Negative relationship.
what is warmth
Intensity of sentiment or feeling which parent expressed about their child. This is based on tone, spontaneity, concern and empathy. Global Rating 0=High warmth 1=Moderate warmth 2= low warmth.
what is relationshop
This assesses the quality of the relationship and joint activities undertaken between parent and child. This is based on parents’ reports of the relationship and reports that the parent enjoys and values time spent with the child. Global Rating 0=Positive relationship 1=Neutral relationship 2=Negative relationship.
what is Emotional over-involvement (EOI)
This assesses the level of emotional relationship between parent and child. This is based on self sacrificing/over-protective behaviour and lack of objectivity. Global Rating 0=Low rating of EOI 1=Moderate rating of EOI 2=High rating of EOI.
what are critical comments
Frequency count of statements which criticise or find fault with the child based on tone and critical phrases
Initial statement – Coding assessment
This statement is rated independently of the remainder of the speech sample.
Don’t score if parent starts by saying “Five minutes is a long time”, “I don’t know if I can talk for five minutes”.
But any information about the child is considered as initial statement
Positive initial statement assessment
There are two types of positive initial statement:
Positive descriptions. This is a statement that expresses praise, approval or appreciation for the behaviour or personality of the child (she is bright, he is very sociable).
Positive relationships. An initial statement scored as a positive relationship indicates that the parent and child have a good relationship (e.g., “Kim and I get on really well together”).
coding warmth assessment
It is important to consider:
Tone of voice
Spontaneity
Concern and empathy.
Tone of voice
It is the most important criterion on which to base a rating. Be alert for:
Signs of enthusiasm when parent is talking about the child
Positive changes in tone when parent switches from talking about neutral subjects to talking about their child.
Monotonic speech is evidence of lack of warmth.
Consider the parent’s normal tone of voice and pitch.
Don’t interpret facial expressions or other non-verbal behaviours.
High concern and empathy assessment
The parents’ ability to demonstrate concern for the child, to see things from the child’s point of view, understand what the child is going through.
“He has difficulty concentrating, I mean it isn’t really a problem now but I do worry about how he is going to get on when he gets to school next year” (concern).
“She loves Tots TV, but she isn’t able to sit still, she is so distracted, then she gets upset when she realises that she has missed it. I can’t imagine what is must be like to want to do something but to not be able to do it”.
Three important caveats relevant to the coding of warmth
Parental depression – this information should be discounted when rating warmth. Even depressed people should be capable of expressing warmth.
Critical comments – The frequency of critical comments should not be allowed to influence ratings of warmth.
Stereotyped endearments – “pet”, “poppet” are often used by parents to describe their children in a stereotyped way and are not necessarily evidence of warmth.
codign critical comments
It is important to consider:
Tone – It is possible to score critical comments based on tone, even if the content of the statement doesn’t contain a critical content. It is important to remember to code conservatively.
Critical phrases- This is frequency count of statements that criticise or find fault with the child. Generally descriptive words of a negative trait that the child has aggression or irritability and typically stated in a negative tone.
Included in this category are also other descriptions of the child’s behaviour which are accompanied by a negative tone or indication that the parent doesn’t like or approve of the behaviour.
Do not code stereotyped descriptions of children unless they are accompanied by a negative tone (“he can be a monkey”).
High versus low Expressed Emotion assessment
More critical than positive comments.
At least one negative categorical behaviour (negative initial statement or low warmth or negative relationship).
Ethical issues in conducting research with children
The investigator should use no research procedure that may harm the child either physically or psychologically. The investigator is also obliged at all times to use the least stressful procedure whenever possible (SRCD Ethical Standards for Research with Children).