Deferred Compensation and Employee Benefits (Lesson 5) Flashcards
What are the general characteristics of a deferred compensation arrangements
- Do not have tax advantages of qualified plans
- usually deferral of income to the executives
- Employer does not receive an income tax deduction until the key employee receives the payment
- funds are subject to a substantial risk of forfeiture
Why are deferred compensation arrangements most often used
- to increase executive wage replacement ratio
- to defer the executive compensation or
- in lieu of qualified plans
What is a golden handshake plan
- severance package often designed to encourage early retirement
What is a golden parachute plan
- substantial payments made to executives being terminated due to changes in corporate ownership
What is a golden handcuff plan
- designed to keep the employee with the company
How does deferred compensation help with wage replacement ratio
- deferred compensation helps executives replace wages that are limited by the contribution limits of other plans
What is the employee tax benefit for a deferred compensation plan
- the executive generally defers the compensation to a time when he expects to be in a lower marginal tax bracket
What is the employer tax benefit for a deferred compensation plan
- the IRC places a $1 million limit on public companies deduction for compensation payable to any one of the top 5 executives of a publicly traded company
- if the executive defers any income over the $1 million limit to a year in which the executive earns less than the limit the employer would be able to deduct the total compensation over the period of deferral and subsequent payments
What is constructive receipt that is used for deferred compensation
- an income tax concept that establishes when income is includable by a taxpayer and subject to tax
When does a substantial risk of forfeiture exists
- when rights in property that are transferred are conditioned directly or indirectly, upon the future performance of substantial services by any person, or the occurrence of a condition related to a purpose of the transfer and the possibility of forfeiture is substantial if the condition is not satisfied
What is the economic benefit doctrine
- provides that an employee will be taxed on funds or property set aside for the employee if the funds or property are unrestricted and nonforfeitable even if the employee was not given a choice to receive the income currently
How is property transferred in connection with performance of services taxed under section 83
- when an employer transfers property to an employee in connection with the performance of services the employee will be taxed on the difference between the FMV of the property and the amount paid for the property
When is deferred compensation subject to payroll tax
- when it is earned
When is a employer entitled to receive an income tax deduction for contributions to a deferred compensation plan
- when the employee is required to include the payments as taxable income
What is a non qualified deferred compensation plan (NQDC)
- is a contractual arrangement between an employer and an executive whereby the employer promises to pay the executive a predetermined amount of money sometime in the future
What is the advantage of a deferred compensation plan to a employer
- cash outflows are often deferred until the future
- employer will save on payroll taxes except for the 1.45% Medicare match
- employer can discriminate and provide these benefits exclusively to a select group of key employees
What are secular trusts
- irrevocable trusts designed to hold funds and assets for the purpose of paying benefits under a non qualified deferred compensation arrangement
- assets are often subject to some other form of risk or they become taxable to the employee
What is a Rabbi Trust
- assets in a rabbi trust are for the sole purpose of providing benefits to employees and may not be accessed by the employer but they may be seized and used for the purposes of paying general creditors in the event of the liquidation of the company
- treated as unfunded due to a presence of a substantial risk of forfeiture
Are the below plans funded with assets
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: No
Rabbi Trust: Yes
Secular Trust: Yes
Are the below plans considered funded under ERISA
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: No
Rabbi Trust: No
Secular Trust: Yes
Are the below plans subject to risk of forfeiture without employer financial instability
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: Yes
Rabbi Trust: No
Secular Trust: No
For the below plans when is there taxable income to the executive
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: When actually or constructively received
Rabbi Trust: When actually or contributively received
Secular Trust: Immediately upon funding by employer or vesting
For the below plans when is the payment deductible to the employer
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: Deferred until payment is made to executive
Rabbi Trust: deferred until payment is made to executive
Secular Trust: Immediately as funded and constructively received
Do the below plans accomplish the objective of deferral of income
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: Yes
Rabbi Trust: Yes
Secular Trust: If vesting is required
Are the below plans subject to risk of forfeiture if employer is insolvent
Unfunded Promise to Pay
Rabbi Trust
Secular Trust
Unfunded Promise to Pay: Yes claim is below general creditors
Rabbi Trust: Yes claim is below general creditors
Secular Trust: no
What is a phantom stock plan
is a non qualified deferred compensation arrangement where the employer grants fictional shares of stock to a key employee that is initially valued at the time of the grant
What is a salary reduction plan for a NQDC plan
- allows employees to elect to reduce their current salary and defer it until future years generally until retirement or termination
What is a salary continuation plan for a NQDC plan
- typically provide benefits after retirement on an ongoing basis or for a predetermined period of time
What is a supplemental executive retirement plan (SERP) for a NQDC plan
- non qualified compensation arrangements designed to provide additional benefits to an executive during retirement
What is a 401k wrap plan
- are a form of salary reduction plan that enables executives who are subject to salary deferral limitations due to the nondiscrimination rules to contribute higher amounts than otherwise permitted under a 401k plan
What is a stock option
- stock option gives the employee a right to buy stock at a specified price for a specified period of time
- option agreement must be in writing and the option holder has no obligation to exercise the option
- terms of the option agreement must be stated in the agreement
What are the two standard types of stock options
- Incentive stock options (ISOs)
- Non Qualified Stock Option (NQSO)
What is a ISO
- is a right given to an employee to purchase an employers common stock at a stated exercise price
- if IRC 422 are met when the ISO is granted the employee will not recognize any taxable income at the date of grant
What happens when an ISO is granted to an employee
- If IRC 422 are met when the ISO is granted the employee will not recognize any taxable income at the date of grant
What happens when a ISO is exercised
- the employee will also not be subject to ordinary income tax on the difference between the FMV of the stock and the exercise price (bargain element)
- The bargain element though is a positive adjustment for the ALT Min tax
What happens when an employee sells the stock after the exercise of the ISO
- difference between the sales price of the stock and the original exercise price is considered LT capital gain (or holding period) and there is a negative adjustment for the alternatives minimum tax calculation
How long do you have to hold a ISO for it to be a qualified sale
- requires waiting 2 years from the date stock was granted and 1 year from the date the stock was exercised
Who can be granted an ISO
- only be granted to an employee of the corporation issuing the ISOs
Who must must approve the ISO plan
- must be approved by the stockholders of the issuing corproation
How long after the ISO plan date must ISOs be granted
- within 10 years of plan date
What is the limit of time when an ISO can be exercised
- 10 year period
- 5 years if 10%+ owners
Can an ISO be transferred
- Only at death
How long must an employee be a employee of the corporation from the date of grant and exercise of the ISO
- Executive must be an employee of the corporation continuously form the date of the grant until at least 3 months prior to the exercise
What is the requirement of the price of the ISO grants at the time the option is first exercisable
- First at the date of the ISO grant the exercise price must be greater than or equal to the FMV of the stock
- the aggregated FMV of the ISO grants at the time the option is first exercisable must be less than or equal to $100,000 based on the grant price per year per executive.
- Any excess grant over the $100,000 is treated as a NQSO
Does an employer receive a tax deduction related to the grant, exercise, or sale of an ISO if it is a qualified sale
No
When does a disqualifying disposition of an ISO occur and what is the tax treatment
- If stock acquired through ISO is disposed of before either two years form the date of the grant or one year from the date of exercise
- Any gain on the sale of the stock attributable to the difference between the exercise price and the FMV at the date of exercise will be considered ordinary income (Not subject to payroll tax or fed w/h)
- Any gain in excess of the difference between the exercise price and the FMV at the date of exercise will be ST or LT capital gain considering the holding period
What is a Cashless exercise of a ISO
- at the time of a cashless exercise a third party lender lends the executive the cash needed to exercise the option and the lender is immediately repaid with the proceeds of the almost simultaneous sale of the stock
- triggers at least a partial disqualifying disposition since the holding period requirements will not be met
What is a Non qualified stock option (NQSO)
- is an option that does not meet the requirement of an incentive stock option or it is explicitly identified as a non qualified stock option
Do NQSO qualify for favorable capital gains treatment
- do not receive favorable capital gains treatment but it is not subject to the same holding period requirements of ISOs
What is the tax effect of a NQSO at the grant date
- will not create a taxable effect assuming that there is no readily ascertainable value for the NQSO
- if the option does have an ascertainable value at the date of grant the executive will have W-2 income equal to the value and the employer will have an income tax deduction
What is the tax effect when a NQSO is exercised
- The executive will recognize W-2 income for the appreciation of the FMV of the stock over the exercise price
- Income and payroll tax withholding will apply and employer will have an income tax deduction for the same amount
- basis of the NQSO will be the stock at exercise price plus the bargain element included in the executives W-2 will be the basis of the stock
What happens when a stock is sold that is acquired through NQSO
- the executives gain or loss will be considered capital gain or loss and will receive short or long term capital gain treatment according to the elapse of time between the date of the sale and the exercise date
Can a NQSO be gifted and what are the tax consequences
- Can be gifted provided the NQSO plan permits transfer of ownership
- No immediate income tax consequence on the transfer
- Upon exercise of the NQSO by the donee the employee will have W-2 income for the difference between the exercise price and the FMV on the date of exercise
- Donee’s basis after the exercise will be equal to the FMV on the date of exercise
- If employee pays the exercise price it is an additional gift to the donee
(NQSO/ISO)
What happens at the grant date for each
NQSO: No taxable income to holder if issued at the current or greater share price
ISO: No taxable income to holder if issued at the current or greater share price
(NQSO/ISO)
What happens at the exercise date
NQSO:
- Executive gives options and exercise price to company
- company issues stock to executive to replace option
ISO:
- Executive gives options and exercise price to company
- company issues stock to executive to replace option
(NQSO/ISO)
What is the taxation event that happens at exercise of each type of option
NQSO:
- At exercise executive recognizes W-2 income to extent of difference between current stock price and exercise price
ISO:
- at exercise executive does not recognize any regular taxable income but will have an AMT adjustment for the appreciation over the exercise price
(NQSO/ISO)
What is the adjusted basis of the stock for each type of option
NQSO:
- Executive adjusted basis in the stock in equal to the FMV of the stock (Exercise price in cash plus the recognition of W-2 income)
ISO:
- Executive adjusted basis in stock is equal to the exercise price
(NQSO/ISO)
What happens when a stock is sold from each type of option
NQSO:
- capital gain or loss treatment
ISO:
- capital gain or loss treatment for a qualified disposition
What are Stock Appreciation Rights (SARs)
- are rights that grant to the holder cash in an amount equal to the excess of the FMV of the stock over the exercise price
- a way to achieve a cashless exercise
How are payments received for the stock appreciation rights treated
- includable in gross income in the year the rights are exercised
When are stock appreciation rights granted
- generally SARs are granted with NQSOs or ISOs and may be used to provide cash to the executive which is necessary to exercise the NQSO or ISO
- usually the number of NQSOs or ISOs is reduced by any exercised SARs
What is a restricted stock plan
- plan pays executives with shares of the employers stock
- executive does not pay any amount towards the allocation of the stock and is restricted by the employer from selling or transferring the stock
- restriction most often gives the employer the ability to repurchase the stock during a set period of years or prohibits the executive from selling the stock during a set number of years or until a defined occurrence of event
What happens when restricted stock is received
- executive will generally not recognize any taxable income as the restrictions generally create a substantial risk of forfeiture
- no deductible expense for the employer
What happens when the substantial risk of forfeiture is eliminated
- the executive recognizes W-2 income equal to the value of the stock at that date and the employer will have a tax deductible expense for an equal amount
- Amount recognized by the executive becomes the executives adjusted basis in the stock for purposes of any subsequent gain or loss calculation