Damages/Equity/Non-Monetary Remedies Flashcards
Measure of tort damages:
the amount necessary to keep/make P whole.
Public policy: General purpose of tort damages under GA law:
Compensation.
In K cases _____ damages are ordinarily not recoverable unless allowed by statute or by the K itself.
consequential
Compensatory damages contrast with:
punitive damages
General damages contrast with:
special damages
Liquidated damages contrast with:
unliquidated damages
Three types of compensatory damages:
- General damages
- Special damages
- Nominal damages
Tort damages are ltd by the element of:
causation. This includes both cause in fact and proximate cause.
TORT: General damages are presumed to flow from what? What is the nature of the damages?
the commission of a tortious act. Considered to be non-economic and non-pecuniary in nature.
TORT: What is the measure of the amount of the award of general damages?
The enlightened conscience of an impartial jury.
TORTS: Pain and suffering can be:
mental, physical, or both.
Physical pain and suffering is inferred from:
personal injuries
When P’s entire injury is to P’s peace, happiness, feelings, _____, ______ , or ________ ________ by D must be proved.
Intentional, willful, or wanton misconduct by D must be proved.
Mental suffering from negligent conduct must involve:
an IMPACT resulting in physical injury or aggravation of prior mental illness
Special damages:
Loss of money or something that money can buy.
P claiming special damages must plead with:
particularity
“Walking man’s friend” statute: P may recover for the value of damaged auto, settle that claim w/o prejudice to:
his personal injury claim.
Punitive damages: Evidentiary standard:
Clear and convincing
Punitive damages: Public policy pointer:
for punishment and deterrence
Punitive damages: Pleading requirements:
Must ask for them in pleadings.
Punitive damages: Trial procedure:
“bifurcated trial” - 2 verdicts, 1 jury
Punitive damages: Recovery caps: Generally
$250k per case.
Punitive damages: Recovery caps: Exceptions: 2 cases
Products liability cases and
Specific intent to cause harm.
In these cases there are no limits.
Punitive damage awards must be in ratio to:
compensatory damages, which must usually be less than 10:1
Additional conditions for products liability cases: Extraction statute:
75% of award goes to the state.
Punitive damages against the sovereign:
Never available.
When entire injury is mental ___ recovery and no ______ _____.
One recovery – no punitive damages.
The duty to mitigate applies in tort and K. P’s duty is to:
lessen the damage by exercise of ordinary care.
Failure to mitigate does not apply to:
intentional torts such as fraud, nor does it apply to the failure to wear a seatbelt.
Lost future profits are recoverable in tort cases when:
- proximately caused, and
2. reasonably certain
Collateral source rule: (Evidentiary)
Excludes evidence of payments to P of collateral sources like health insurance, sick pay, and gifts.
Collateral source rule public policy pointer:
If there’s going to be a windfall – better for P to get it b/c it encourages people to buy insurance.
Note: collateral source rule is not applied if P:
opens the door, or in K cases in general.
Economic loss rule:
When a defective product injures only itself or a system that it is a component part of the P is limited to K remedies and cannot recover consequential damages.
Damages for loss of consortium: Includes:
loss to uninjured spouse – injured the relationship.
Damages for loss of consortium: What is the measure of the amount of the award of damages:
Enlightened conscience of an impartial jury.
Damages for loss of child’s consortium:
Ltd to value of services only.
Damages for loss of parent’s consortium:
Not recognized.
Three remedies for conversion:
- Give it back if intact.
- Market price
- Rent for the time the chattel was converted.
Conversion: Measure of market value:
Highest proved value b/t time of conversion and time of trial.
Measure of tort damages for fraud:
the benefit of the bargain.
Public policy for measure of tort damage for fraud:
deterrence
It addition to recovering the benefit of the bargain, because fraud is an intentional tort, it may justify other damages: Other available damages for fraud: 3
- Punitive
- Consequential
- General
Interference w/ economic opportunities: P may recover against D who interferes with PRESENT or PROSPECTIVE business or contractual relations. Measure of damages is:
loss of profits.
Interference w/ economic opportunities: P must show that interference was:
malicious, and therefore intentional and thus punitive damages may be recovered.
Interference w/ economic opportunities: P may only recover once: A single satisfaction bars P from:
recovering his K expectations from both the D AND the party who breached
Overriding purpose of K damages:
(Expectation damages) to put the wronged party back in position as if bargain had never been created.
K: General measure of damages are limited to those arising:
directly from the breach of K and that were w/i the contemplation of the parties at the time the K was made.
Quantum Meruit: For implied Ks:
When goods/materials have been furnished by one to another or services have been rendered the law implies a promise to pay the reasonable value thereof.
Quantum meruit measure of damages is:
the reasonable value to the recipient.
When K is made fraudulently the injured party upon discovery may do one of two things:
- Affirm K and sue for breach, OR
2. Rescind and sue for fraud.
Three steps for equity and non-monetary remedy questions:
- Are gen. requirements for equitable relief satisfied?
- Are specific req’ts for particular equitable remedy you seek satisfied?
- Are there equitable defenses that would prevent otherwise equitable relief?
Two general requirements for equitable relief: 2
- Legal remedy is inadequate
2. ER must be feasible.