Critical Pass - Property Flashcards
xfAt common law, what is required for there to be a joint tenancy
the 4 unities: TTIP
1) Time - conveyance to two or more persons at same time
2) Title - same instrument
3) Interest - Identical and equal interests
4) Possession - equal possession rights
Modern law requires what in addition to the 4 unities?
an clear expression of the right of survivorship
A conveyance to 2 or more persons presumptively creates.. (at modern law)
a tenancy in common, not a joint tenancy.
Need the clear expression of right of survivorship
A joint tenancy:
Alienable?
Descendible?
Devisable?
alienable, but not devisable or descendible
If one JT dies, surviving JT’s automatically..
take equal possession of deceased JT’s share
Severance: a joint tenancy can be severed in one of four ways:
(mnemonic=G SAM):
1) by giving it away during life,
2) by signing a contract for sale,
3) by an actual judicial sale by a judgment lien creditor,
or
4) by granting a mortgage in a title theory state.
Severance by any JT creates a ..
tenancy in common
Upon transfer of a joint tenants interest, the interest becomes a …… but what is the special situation with this?
Transfer makes the interest a tenancy in common
But, the entire JT is not destroyed if two or more JTs remain!
What are the two theories for mortgages severing a JT?
lien theory (majority) vs. title theory (minority)
1) Lien theory Jx—JT can take a mortgage on her interest without severing JT (b/c no title passes to mortgagee)
2) Title theory Jx—JT is severed if any JT takes a mortgage on her interest b/c title passes to the mortgagee
An estate with multiple tenants in which each co-tenant owns a distinct, undivided interest and each has a right to possession of the whole estate
tenancy in common
Tenancy in Common:
Alienable
Devisable
Descendible?
Yes to all - freely transferable
default concurrent estate
tenancy in common
upon death of a co-tenant, her interest does not..
pass by law to remaining co-tenants
but the co-tenant can transfer her interest
can a co-tenant (TIC) rent his interest? What happens?
Yes a co-tenant can lease his individual interest, which transfers his right of possession to lessee, but co-tenants have a right to share in rents from third-party lessee
Can a co-tenant seek judicial partition? What if partition is not feasible?
a co-tenant may seek judicial partition (i.e., division of property); if not feasible, property may be sold and proceeds apportioned among co-tenants
what is tenancy by entirety?
a marital estate (between married couple)
Creation of tenancy by entirety?
created by conveyance to a married couple and requires the same four conditions as a JT (time, title, interest, possession)
Tenancy by the entirety is presumed in any conveyance made jointly to a married couple
What is the right of survivorship for tenancy by entirety?
property automatically passes to surviving spouse
What if one spouse in a tenancy by entirety tries to convey or partition their interest?
one spouse may not unilaterally convey or partition her interest; attempt to do so is invalid BUT will not destroy the tenancy
who are the only creditors that can reach a spouses’s interest in a tenancy by entirety?
only creditors of the couple (i.e., joint creditors) can reach a tenancy by the entirety
What are the three ways a tenancy by entirety can be severed? What happens upon severance?
Becomes a TIC
- Death of one co-tenant
- Issuance of a divorce decree
- Execution by a joint creditor (e.g., foreclosure)
Each co-tenant has the right to possess..
the whole property, but has no right to exclusive possession of any part
if 1 co-tenant wrongfully excludes another co-tenant from possession of the whole or any part, they have committed…
ouster (an actionable wrong)
is a co-tenant required to pay rent or reimburse the other tenants for their use?
no - but each co-tenant has the right to share in rents from third parties and profits derived from the use of land that depletes its value
a co tenant cannot acquire title to the exclusion of other co-tenants through AP unless..
the co-tenants are ousted for the statutory period
what carrying costs are co tenants liable for?
fair share of taxes, interest, etc.
can a tenant seek contribution from co-tenants for reasonable repairs?
yes but they must inform co-tenants before making repairs
co-tenants have no right to contribution from co-tenants for
improvements
what about waste and co-tenants?
they must not commit waste, if they do, tenant can bring an action for waste against co-tenants during the life of the tenancy
What are the 3 types of waste?
1) voluntary - willful waste
2) permissive - neglect
3) amerliorative - unilateral change that increases value
A joint tenant or tenant in common has a right to bring an action for..
partition
three types of partition:
- voluntary agreement,
- partition in kind (court preference)
and 3. forced sale.
what if the property cant be divided for partition?
permitted to sell and apportion the proceeds
Can co-tenants agree to not partition?
yes but only for a limited time (otherwise invalid)
what 2 types of tenancy have a right of survivorship
- joint tenancy
- tenancy by entirety
what is a leasehold?
estate in which the tenant has a present possessory property interest and the landlord has a future interest (reversion)
4 leasehold estates:
The tenancy for years
*
The periodic tenancy
*
The tenancy at will
*
The tenancy at sufferance
a leasehold estate that is fixed for a period of time
tenancy for years - need a definitive beginning and end
what happens once the term is up for a tenancy for years?
Terminates automatically at the end of the period, no needed notice
what needs to happen if a tenancy for years is for 2+ years?
needs to be in writing (more than 1year) SOF
Leaseholds: Tenancy estate that repeats until terminated (continuous for successive intervals) until either party gives notice of termination
Periodic tenancy
Leaseholds: Either party can terminate at any time without notice
Tenancy at will
Leaseholds: Tenant has possession by virtue of wrongfully remaining after termination of a lease (holdover tenant)
Tenancy at sufferance
How can a periodic tenancy be created?
- express
- implied
- by operative of law (invalid lease, holdover tenant)
when is a periodic tenancy implied?
a lease that does not specify duration, but provides for rent to be paid at set intervals
two situations where periodic tenancy created by operation of law
1) Invalid lease—if tenant takes possession despite an invalid lease (e.g., lease violates SoF), periodic tenancy arises upon landlord’s acceptance of payment
Period of the tenancy is determined by the period the payment covers
2) Holdover tenant—if landlord accepts rent from a holdover tenant, a periodic tenancy arises for the period the payment covers
how to terminate a periodic tenancy?
tenant must give proper notice, which requires:
1. Sufficient time—tenant must give notice one full period in advance; year-to-year tenancies require six-month notice under common law, one month under the modern view
2. Effective date—effective date of termination must be at the end of the period of the tenancy
this can be contracted around
Creation of tenancy at will?
need express agreement
Without an express agreement, courts will treat the lease as an implied periodic tenancy
two ways to terminate a tenancy at will:
- by will (no notice)
- operation of law:
- Death of either party
- Waste by the tenant
- Assignment by the tenant
- Transfer of title by the landlord
- Lease by the landlord to a third party
what leasehold typically arises when a tenant continues to possess property after the lease has expired?
Tenancy at sufferance (holdover tenant)
Creation of a tenancy at sufferance
tenant holds possession beyond lease expiration
The expired lease’s terms and conditions automatically carry over to the tenancy at sufferance
what are the LL’s options when there is a tenancy at sufferance?
1) Sue to evict, or
2) Impose a new periodic tenancy
if you have a tenant who will not get out after their lease is up, can the LL raise the rent?
landlord can demand higher rent for both the holdover period and any new periodic tenancy ONLY if he gave notice of the increase before the lease expired
if the LL wants to impose a new periodic tenancy on a holdover tenant, what is the limitation they must abide by? what is reasonable?
the new periodic tenancy must be reasonable
Unreasonable if:
1. Tenant only remains in possession for a few hours
2. Tenant is not at fault for delay in vacating (e.g., illness)
3. Seasonal leases (e.g., ski cabin, beach house)
tenant’s primary duties:
- repair
- pay rent
the tenant’s duty to repair can be modified by the lease, but they must…
maintain premises and make ordinary repairs
Tenant must not commit waste: what are the 3 types:
- Voluntary—overt, harmful acts (e.g., removing fixtures)
- Permissive—neglect
- Ameliorative—alterations increasing property value
what if the destruction of the premises is of no fault of the LL or tenant? How do you resolve this?
Common law—tenant held liable for any loss
Modern law—tenant can terminate lease
If a tenant is on the premises and fails to pay rent, the LL can:
- evict and
- sue for rent due
LL CANNOT ENGAGE IN SELF HELP! (changing locks, removing tenant, or removing their possessions)
what if the tenant wrongfully vacates with time left on their lease, what are the LLs options?
SIR
1) surrender
2) ignore the abandonment (do nothing and hold tenant liable for rent)
3) re-let the premises
Some majority states require LL to at least try to relet
what happens if your entire lease is taken by eminent domain?
depends on if the taking is temporary or total
If temporary: tenant is not discharged from rent, but is entitled to compensation (share of condemnation award) of taking
If total: tenant is not liable for rent
if a tenant is not moving out after their lease is up, can the LL forcibly remove tenant or their belongings?
no, LL may not engage in self help upon a tenant breach
what are the 4 implied duties a LL has to a tenant?
- duty to deliver possession
- implied covenant of quiet enjoyment
- implied warranty of habitability
- tort liability
the majority rule for LL’s duty to deliver possession requires that LL
put the tenant in actual physical possession of the premises
how can a breach of the implied covenant of quiet enjoyment arise
- Breach may occur by actual or constructive eviction
- Breach may occur by landlord’s wrongful conduct causing loss of use and enjoyment by tenant
what is actual eviction?
LL wrongfully evicts or excludes tenant from property
what is constructive eviction?
LL’s actions or inactions render the property unlivable/unusable
Elements of constructive eviction
SING
1) substantial interference
2) notice - Tenant must inform LL and give him reasonable opportunity to repair
3) Good bye - tenant must vacate within reasonable time after LL fails to repair
most idx’s imply what covenant in ONLY residential leases?
Implied warranty of habitability (ONLY RESIDENTIAL, NOT COMMERCIAL)
What constitutes a breach of the implied warranty of habitability?
Local code or case law specifies the standard for a breach
E.g., no heat in winter, no plumbing, no water, etc. are types of problems that could give rise to violation of the implied warranty of habitability
tenant’s remedies when implied warranty of habitability is breached
MR3
1) move
2) repair and deduct
3) Reduce rent or withhold all rent
4) remain in possession and sue for damages
what kinds of things can expose a LL to tort liability to a tenant?
CLAPS
1) common areas (reasonable care)
2) latent defects
3) assumption of repairs
4) public use
5) seasonal or short term lease of a furnished dwelling
what duty does a LL have for latent defects?
duty to disclose
what liability does LL have for assumption of repairs?
liable for harm caused by negligent repairs he chose to do
LL liability for defects in public use property
known defects
For a seasonal or short term lease of a dwelling, what is LL liable for
defects that cause harm to tenant
Transfer of entire remaining term of lease
Transfer of part of remaining term of lease
Assignment: Transfer of entire remaining term of lease
Sublease: Transfer of part of remaining term of lease
Under an assignment, who owes rent to the LL? What if they dont pay?
Assignee owes rent directly to landlord, but assignor remains liable for unpaid rent unless landlord expressly releases tenant (novation)
Assignor and assignee both remain….
in privity with the LL in an assignment
in a sublease situation, who remains on the hook with the LL
sublessor only (this relationship is unchanged)
Sublessee pays rent to sublessor as her tenant