Barbri lectures Crim Pro Flashcards
When does a seizure occur?
When a reasonable person would believe that they are not free to leave (totality of circumstances)
4 Automatic times when you have reasonable expectation of privacy: AUTOMATIC STANDING UNDER 4A!
- Person owned or had right to possess place searched (does not matter if she lives there)
- Place searched is person’s home
- Person is overnight guest of owner
Sometimes: the person owns the property seized.
Do the cops always need to knock and announce?
No, no announcement is needed if the police reasonably suspect that knocking and announcing would be dangerous or ruin the investigation
4 point analysis that is very important for determining whether searches and seizures are reasonable:
- is there govt conduct
- is there standing?
- is there a valid warrant? (PC/Particularily)
- If warrant is not valid: Does Officer’s good faith defense save the evidence (exceptions here)
- if no valid warrant, do exceptions to warrant req apply? (need exception to be valid, voluntary consent)
when can someone other than the defendant give consent to enter without a warrant?
parent who has general access to a room occupied by a son or daughter, then that is valid consent.
a search warrant allows the police to ___ persons, but does NOT authorize the police to…
Can detain persons, but the police cannot search persons found on the premises who were not named in the warrant.
any invasion of privacy done by ___ ____, not by the ___, would not prevent introduction of the evidence.
Any invasion of privacy done by private persons, not the state, would not prevent introduction of evidence.
EX. President of a high school = not the state/police
Can the police arrest someone and search them 5 hours later?
No, search must be contemporaneous in time and place with arrest. Too long went by.
Does it matter that what was found was different than what gave rise for the officer to search?
NO! So long as the search itself is valid, any contraband or illegal items found will be admissible.
Police may search passenger compartment incident (NOT THE TRUNK) to arrest if: GANT RULE
- Arrestee is unsecured (not in back of squad car) and may gain access to vehicle; or
- Police reasonably believe evidence of offense for which person was arrested may be found
If officer stops a car and sees something in plain view, this is NOT a
search
If the officer manipulated the defendant, is this plain feel? Ok for Terry frisk?
NO not ok! Just plain feel, no manipulation.
Generally, no right to privacy in:
- Sound of your voice
- Style of your handwriting
- Paint on outside of car
- Account records held by bank
- Location of car on public street or driveway
BUT…. GPS device on suspect’s car constitutes a search within the 4th amendment (Jones) - Anything seen across open fields
- Anything seen from flying over public airspace (low aerial photographing)
- Odors from luggage or car
- Garbage set out on the curb for collection (NEEDS TO BE ON CURB)
The police can conduct any search incident to ___, so long as there is
The police can conduct a search incident to arrest so long as there is a valid constitutional arrest. (state law does not matter)
What are the requirements for the plain view exception to warrant req?
police can make a warrantless seizure when:
1. legit on the premises
2. discover evidence, contraband, or fruits of crime
3. see evidence in plain view, and
4. have pc to believe evidence/contraband is instrument or fruit of crime
By handing an officer your phone, are you giving them permission to search your texts/photos/etc?
No - need a warrant to view contents.
what is the automobile exception to warrant req?
the police may search a vehicle without a warrant if they have probable cause to do so, and they may seize any contraband that they find.
If the police do execute an arrest warrant at the home of a third party without obtaining a search warrant for the home, the arrest is …
still valid but evidence of any crime found in the home cannot be used against the owner of the home because it is the fruit of an unconstitutional search
when can someone with apparent equal right to use/occupy property consent?
so long as the occupant gave a valid consent and co-occupant did not object
If co-occupant is removed for an unrelated reason, can the cops rely on the consent of the person there?
yes
A D who is arrested but not yet charged does NOT have a ____ to counsel but DOES have a ___ to counsel
A d who is arrested but not yet charged does not have a 6th A right to counsel but DOES have a 5th A right to counsel under Miranda
There can be no violation of the 6thA right to counsel before formal proceedings have beun
do miranda warnings need to be said verbatim,
no so long as the substance of the warnings is conveyed
What are the two req’s for Miranda Rights being read? When is miranda req’d
Need a 1) custodial; 2) interrogation
Miranda applies only to..
custodial interrogations by the police or one known to be an agent of the police
Two step process for determining custody:
1) whether reasonable person would feel free to terminate interrogation and leave
2) whether environment presents same inherently coercive pressures as station house questioning
Test for interrogation Req
Any words or conduct by police that they should know would likely elicit an incriminating response (not just questions, need incriminating response)
Miranda warnings are NOT required for ____ statements
spontaneous (just blurting out a crime you committed)
If the facts tell you that something is “blurted out” what does this mean for Miranda?
Spontaneous statement at issue, no miranda warnings are required and can be used against you
How can a detainee waive their miranda rights? what test is used to determine this?
waiver must be knowing and voluntary (look at TOC)
The invocation of right to remain silent and right to counsel must be…
unambigious
If the detainee invokes their right to counsel, all questioning must stop until…
counsel has been provided unless the detainee:
1) waives counsel, or
2) is released back to normal life and 14 days have passed since release
If a detainee invokes their right to remain silent, could the police requestion them about a different crime?
Yes - but prob after a break and if fresh warnings are administered.
If right to counsel invoked, no questioning until attorney is present.
“Maybe I should get a lawyer now” – is this an invocation of the right to counsel under Miranda?
No, must be unambiguous. This is not clear. Need “I want my lawyer.”
If you are told your Miranda rights and sit there silent for 2 hours, do you invoke your right to silence under Miranda?
No - need to speak.
what are the full miranda warnings?
must inform detainee that:
1) right to remain silent
2) anything he says can be used against him in court
3) he has the right to counsel
4) if cannot afford attorney, one will be appointed if he desires.