Criminal Law Flashcards
Crime may be prosecuted in any state where
an act that was part of the crime took place, or
the result took place
In crim case, P must prove each element of the crime (standard)
beyond a reasonable doubt
NY: for affirmative defense, D must prove by (standard)
a preponderance of the evidence
Felony def:
A crime that may be punished by death or imprisonment for more than 1 year
Misdemeanor def:
A crime punishable by a fine and/or imprisonment for no more than 1 year
Failure to act can be the basis for crim liability, if three reqs are satisfied:
- Legal duty to act
- Knowledge of the facts giving rise to the duty
- Ability to help
Failure to act for crim liability: there is a legal duty in 5 ways:
- by statute
- by K duty
- by status rel.
- by voluntary assumption of care
- by creation of the peril
Specific intent def:
when the crime requires not just the desire to do the act, but also the desire to achieve a specific result
Malice def:
where D acts intentionally or w/ reckless disregard of an obvious or known risk
General intent def:
D need only be generally aware of the factors constituting the crime; he need not intend a specific result
NY’s 5 mental states:
- Intent/purpose
- Knowledge
- Recklessness
- Negligence
- SL
Actual causation in crim liability: accelerating cause?
Accelerating cause counts as actual cause, even though it’s not literally a “but for” case
Actual causation (criminal) general rule:
D is an actual cause if the bad result would not have happened but for D’s conduct
Proximate causation (criminal) general rule:
D is a prox cause if the bad result is a natural and probable consequence of the D’s conduct
Will D be considered a prox cause if an intervening event causes the bad result?
Not if it was an unforeseeable intervening event
Concurrence principal:
Crim D must have the required mental state at the same time as he engages in the culpable act (usually comes up in larceny and burglary)
CL elements of battery (crim):
Unlawful application of force to another, resulting in either bodily injury or an offensive touching
Mental state: general intent
CL elements of assault (crim):
intentional creation other than by mere words of a reasonable apprehension in the mind of the victim of an immediate bodily harm
Mental state: specific intent
NY elements of assault:
Intentionally causing physical injury to another person
Merely causing a reasonable apprehension is not assault (it’s “menacing”)
Impossible to memorize all degrees of NY crimes. But remember these 3 factors in calculus:
- Weapons (“add a gun, add a degree”)
- Injury - how serious? Physical injury (substantial pain), or serious physical injury (permanent or life threatening?)
- Quantity (of money, drugs, etc.)
Second degree assault (NY)
Intentionally causing SERIOUS physical injury
Elements of battery (NY):
Battery doesn’t exist in NY!
Elements of CL murder:
- Causing the death
- of another person
- w/ malice aforethought
Murder - malice aforethought can be 4 mental states:
- Intent to kill
- Intent to inflit serious bodily harm
- Extreme recklessness (reckless indifference to human life)
- Intentional commission of an inherently dangerous felony (“felony murder”)
The intentional use of a deadly weapon creates inference of:
an intent to kill
Def. transferred intent:
If D intends to harm one victim, but accidentally harms a different victim instead, D’s intent will transfer from intended victim to the actual victim
Does transferred intent apply to attempts?
NO, only to crimes w/ completed harms
Felony murder def:
Any killing caused during the commission of or attempt to commit a felony
NY limits felony murder to certain felonies (“BRAKES”)
Burglary Robbery Arson Kidnapping Escape Sexual assault
Felony murder limitations:
- D must be guilty of the underlying felony
- Felony must be inherently dangerous
- Felony must be independent of the killing
- Killing must take place during the felony or during immediate flight from the felony
- Death must be foreseeable
- Victim must not be a co-felon
Once a felon reaches a place of temporary safety
felony ends. Felony murder no longer rules
Felony murder: vicarious liability and prox cause theory:
if one of the co-felons prox causes the victim’s death, ALL of the other co-felons will be guilty of felony murder, even if the actual killing is committed by a third party (e.g. bystander, cop)
NY “non-slayer” defense: NY provides a limited affirmative defense to felony murder if D can prove each of the following 4 things:
- D did not kill the victim
- D did not have a deadly weapon
- D had no reason to believe that his co-felons had deadly weapons, and
- D had no reason to believe that his co-felons intended to do anything that was likely to result in death
MBE: 1st degree murder def.
Any killing committed w/
- pre-meditation, and
- deliberation
MBE: 2nd degree murder def.
All other intentional murders, as well as depraved heart murder
NY: 1st degree murder def.
- intent to kill, and
- D is more than 18 years old, and
- at least one aggravating factor (victim is cop in official duties, murder for hire, intentional felony murder, witness intimidation, more than one victim intentionally killed)
NY: 2nd degree murder def.
- intentional killing that doesn’t qualify for 1st degree
- Highly reckless killing demonstrating depraved indifference to human life by engaging in conduct that creates a “grave risk” of death (more than 1 victim), or
- Felony murder, where victim is not a co-felon and is killed unintentionally
MBE: voluntary manslaughter def:
- an intentional killing
- committed in the heat of passion
- upon adequate provocation
4 CL requirements of voluntary manslaughter:
- provocation was objectively adequate (sudden, intense passion)
- D was actually provoked
- D didn’t have time to cool off
- D did not actually cool off b/w provocation and killing
NY: voluntary manslaughter def:
an intentional killing committed under the influence of extreme emotional disturbance
NY defense to murder: EED?
extreme emotional defense can act as an affirmative defense to 2nd degree murder, so D must prove EED by a preponderance of the evidence
MBE: involuntary manslaughter:
Killing committed w/ crim. negligence (gross deviation from standard of care), or
Killing committed during the commission of a crime to which felony murder doctrine does not apply
NY: 1st degree manslaughter
EED manslaughter, or an intent to cause serious physical injury