Criminal Law Flashcards
Vagueness of Criminal Statute is…
Unconstitutional
Criminal statute must have these elements to be constitutional
(1) Fair warning
(2) no arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement
(3) No ex post facto laws or bills of attainder
Interpretations of conflicting criminal statutes
(1) prefer more specific to general
(2) prefer more recently enacted to older
(3) crimes committed before effective date of new code are subject to prosecution under the old code
Modern Law - Merger
(1) Cannot be convicted of both solicitation and completed crime.
(2) Cannot be convicted of both attempt and completed crime.
Does Conspiracy Merge?
No - one can be convicted of both conspiracy and the criminal act.
Double jeopardy
Cannot be convicted of a lesser offense if he’s been put on trial for the greater offense.
DOES NOT APPLY to two or more statutorily defined offenses arising from same transaction.
Elements of a Crime
(1) Physical act (actus reus)
(2) Mental state (mens rea)
(3) concurrence of physical and mental.
Some crimes also require harmful result
Physical Act requirements
It’s a bodily movement.
(1) voluntary physical act, or
(2) failed to act under a legal duty
Failed to act raises to liablity when these elements satisfied
(1) Legal duty to act
(2) D has knowledge of facts giving rise to act, and
(3) reasonably possible to perform the act
How are legal duty’s to act imposed?
(1) Statute
(2) Contract
(3) D/V relationship
(4) Creation of peril
(5) Voluntary assumption of care
(6) Possession
How is possession an Act?
Only need control over it for a long enough period to have enough time to terminate the possession.
Possession need only be within “dominion and control”
Must be aware of possession, but no need to be aware of its illegality
What are the different mental states?
(1) Specific intent
(2) Malice
(3) General intent
What are the crimes that require specific intent?
(1) Solicitation
(2) Attempt
(3) Conspiracy
(4) First degree murder
(5) Assault
(6) Larceny and robbery
(7) Burglary
(8) Forgery
(9) False pretenses
(10) Embezzlement
What are the malice crimes?
Reckless disregard of an obvious or high risk that the particular harmful result will occur.
(1) murder
(2) arson
What are the general intent crimes?
Almost all crimes require general intent - awareness he is acting in a proscribed way and that attendant circumstances exist. General intent found by merely doing the act.
What are the strict liability crimes?
Intent doesn’t matter.
(1) Rape
(2) Liquor to minors
(3) Bigamy
Mens rea state of mind differences between common law and MPC
common law - it’s about specific or general intent
MPC - it’s about fault (purposely, knowingly, recklessly, negligently).
What are the four mental states under MPC?
(1) Purposely
(2) Knowingly
(3) Recklessly
(4) Negligence
MPC Mental State - Purposely
Conscious object to engage in conduct
MPC Mental State - Knowingly
Awareness that conduct is of a nature that will cause a particular result
MPC Mental State - Recklessly
Conscious disregard and unjustifiable risk
MPC Mental State - Negligence
Failure to be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk
Vicarious Liability definition
Hold third party liable for crimes of another. Limited to regulatory crimes and fines
Transferred intent applies to
(1) Homicide
(2) Battery
(3) Arson
DOES NOT APPLY TO ATTEMPT SCENARIOS
If transferred attempt applies, most likely liable for actual crime and attempt of the crime on the other person
Is motive relevant?
NO - ignore it
Parties to a crime - Common law
(1) principal in first degree (committed crime)
(2) principal in second degree (aided and was present)
(3) accessory before the fact (encouraged but not present)
(4) accessory after the fact (knowledge of felony and assisted in escape of arrest)
REQUIRES First principle conviction before any of the others can be convicted - this rule has been abandoned by most jurisdictions.
Parties to a crime - MPC
(1) Principal - liable for principal crime
(2) Accomplice - liable for principal crime if accomplice intended to aide in crime and all foreseeable results
(3) Accessory After the Fact - liable for separate, less serious crime of being an accessory after the fact.
Accompliance can be liable even if P is not!!!!!!!
Mental state for an accomplice
(1) intent principal commit the offense - mere knowledge not enough
Can be reckless or negligence if statute calls for it
Withdrawing as an accomplice limits
Withdraw must occur before crime committed
(1) Repudiate plan, or
(2) Neutralize assistance
What are the Inchaote offenses?
(1) Solicitation
(2) Conspiracy
(3) Attempt
Solicitation definition
Enticing another to commit a crime, with the intent that the solicited person commit the crime.
Withdraw NOT a defense
Merges with substantive defense
Conspiracy definition
(1) Agreement between two or more persons
(2) With intent to enter into an agreement
(3) Intent of two or more persons to achieve the objective of agreement
MPC (unilateral): Only one person needs a guilty mind (ex. undercover police officer). Common law (bilateral): Two people need guilty mind
Withdraw NOT a defense (except further crimes)
Does NOT merge with substantive offense
Attempt definition
Act done with intent to commit a crime that falls short of the crime.
MPC: act is substantial step
Common law: act is dangerously close to completion of crime
Withdraw NOT a defense
Merges with substantive offense
Insanity Defense - M’Naghten Rule
“M’ N I don’t know right from wrong or understand my actions!”
D does not know right from wrong or understand his actions