Constitutional Law Flashcards
Article III Courts have power to hear
(1) Interpret constiutiton
(2) Fed laws
(3) Treaties
(4) Admirality
(5) Maritime
(6) Disputes between states/diverse citizens/foreign citizens
Judicial Review
Review constiutionality of acts of other branches of government
Article I courts have power to hear
Tax courts
Original jurisdiction of supreme court
(1) Ambassadors
(2) Public ministers
(3) consuls
(4) suites against states
Cases come to Supreme court by
(1) Writ of Certioari - DISCRETION
(2) Appeal - must hear it
Requirements for a fed court to hear a case
(1) must be a “case or controversy”
(2) No advisory opinions
(3) Ripeness (bars claim BEFORE developed)
(4) Mootness (bars claim AFTER resolved)
(5) Standing
Components for Standing
(1) Injury
(2) Causation
(3) Redressability
Common Standing Issues
(1) Congress cannot confer standing w/o injury
(2) P has standing to enforce statute if within “zone of interest” of statute
(3) Assert rights of others
(4) Standing of organizations
(5) No citizenship standing
(6) No tax standing
Standing of organizations elemetns
(1) injury to members that would give right to sue on own behalf
(2) injury related to org’s purpose
(3) individual member participation not required
Will Supreme court exercise jurisidction if state court judgment based on adequate and independent state law grounds - even if fed issues involved?
NO - unless it is unclear that the decision was based only on state law grounds.
What’s a political question
matter that is not capable of judicial decision. Some PQ include:
(1) gerrymandering
(2) partisan leg appointment
(3) procedures for ratifying constitutional amendments
(4) President’s foreign policy
11th Amendment Bars
Fed Coruts from hearing private or foreign party’s claims against a state government.
Doctrine of sovereign immunity
bars suits against a state government in state court, even on fed claims, unless the state consents
Doesn’t bar suit against an officer whose act violates constitution or fed law, even if state has to pay, and actions against the officer personally
Congress’s Powers
(1) Necessary and Proper power (attached to another fed power)
(2) Tax Power
(3) Spending power
(4) Commerce
(5) War
(6) Investigation
(7) Property
(8) Bankruptcy
(9) Postal
(10) Citizenship
(11) Admiraility
(12) Coin money
(13) Patent/Copyright
Necessary and Proper Power
Power to make all laws necessary and proper for executing any power granted to any branch of the federal government
Tax Power
Only needs to be reasonable related to revenue production
Spending Power
Any public purpose
Commerce Power
(1) Regulate CHANNELS of interstate comerce
(2) Regulate the INSTRUMENTALITIES, or
(3) Regulate activities that have a SUBSTANTIAL EFFECT
If congress relies on commerce power to regulate interstate activities that have a substantial effect, then a court will uphold it if…
(1) Economic: rational basis that it effects interstate commerce
(2) Noneconomic: congress must show a direct substantial economic effect on interestate commerce
Property power
No limits to dispose property
Takings must be for purpose of an enumerated constitutional power
is there police power by congress?
NO - unless you’re in the terrible place known as DC
Alien rights
Alien: no rights
Resident alien: notice and hearing before deportation
Speech and Debate clause
Can say anything and not be prosecuted
Can delegate legislative power when…
Congress provides intelligible standards
Can congress veto an executive action?
NO
Appointment powers
Congress cannot appoint
Requires advice of senate unless it’s an inferior officer
Removal of appointees
President: can remove exec high level without intereference from Congress. Congress can put limits on President’s power to remove all other executives (ex. good cause only).
Congress: Can remove exec officers through impeachment only.
Pocket veto
President has 10 days to veto - if congress is not in session the bill is automatically vetoed. If congress is in session it becomes law.
Line item veto
unconstitutional - all or nothing
President’s power as chief
(1) President acts with express or implied authority of congress - likely valid
(2) President acts where congress silent - likely uheld unless it usurps the power of another branch
(3) President acts against congress - he has little authority
Treaty power
President can enter into treaties with 2/3 vote of senate
Veto requires what in congress
2/3 in each house
Executive Agreement vs. Treaty
Exec agreement do not require consent of congress - treaties do
Executive Agreement priority of authority
(1) Exec agreement trumps state law
(2) Exec agreement does not trump federal law
Impeachment requirements
Majority vote in house to invoke charges
2/3 in senate to convict and remove
Preemption
Fed law supersedes state law either expressly or implicitly
Preemption by Operation of the entire field
State law can be preempted even if there isn’t a conflict in the laws if congress intended to operate the entire field
Can US sue States?
YES
Can States sue US?
NO - unless US consents