Crime and Deviance Flashcards
how does Durkheim say crime is normal?
-socialisation:
not everyone socialised effectively, underclass have a different set of norms and values
-subcultures:
suffer from anomie and normlessness making it hard to follow collective conscience
what are Durkheim functions of crime?
-Boundary maintenance
-Adaptation and change
what is boundary maintenance?
crimes that are concerning strike a reaction and unite members in opposition
punishment reaffirms shared values and society
what is adaptation and change in relation to durkheim and crime?
all forms of social change start with an act of deviance
divorce jesus
highlight immediate need for change
rosa parks civil rights
how does Davis support Durkheim view on crime?
prostitution acts as a safety valve releasing men’s sexual frustration without threatening monotonous nuclear family
how does Polsky support Durkheim view on crime?
pornography safely channels variety of sexual desires away from alternative like adultery
how does Cohen support Durkheims view on crime?
warning that an institution isn’t functioning properly high truancy rates tell us there are issues with the education system
what are evaluations for Durkheim ?
-realists criticise idea that crime is normal, crime is an issue for victims and society
-marxist: doesn’t consider where laws and value consensus come from
-doesn’t consider why some commit crime and some don’t
what does Merton mean by strain theory?
-American dream
-wealth and material success
-strain between socially encouraged goals and socially excepted ways to achieve them
what are the origins of strain theory?
-structural factors- lower class
-cultural factors- American dream
when they don’t marry strain happens
what are the responses to strain theory?
-conformist
-ritualist
-retreatist
-rebel
-innovator
what are strengths of Merton strain theory ?
-explains patterns in official crime statistics
-lower class crime rates higher as have least opportunity to obtain wealth legitimately
What are weaknesses of Merton strain theory?
-explains utilitarian crime by those with no education ( doesn’t explain middle class)
-take statistics at face value- deterministic and over represent working class
-ignores mc power to criminalise wc through laws
-ignores role of group deviance
what does cohen mean by status frustration?
-wc boys failed at school and face anomie in the mc habitus school system
-from subcultures in response
-reverse of mainstream values
what does cohen mean by alternative status hierarchy?
-subcultures value spite, malice, hostility
-praise what society condemns, inverts values of mainstream society
-tried but failed legitimate opportunity structure
-win status from peers
what are strengths of Cohens status frustration theory?
recognised non utilitarian crime
edgework- postmodernists
what are weaknesses of Cohens status frustration?
-demonises wc boys ( marxist white collar crime and corporate crime)
-ignores possibility that wc boys never shared same goals so dont see themselves as failures
what do cloward and ohlin focus on?
not everyone turns to innovation due to blocked opportunities
there is unequal access to illegitimate opportunities too
what are the three types of subcultures according to cloward and ohlin?
criminal subcultures
conflict subcultures
retreatist subcultures
what are criminal subcultures?
Youth apprenticeship for a career and utilitarian crime
Arises in neighbourhoods with an established hierarchy of professional adult crime
What are conflict subcultures?
High levels of social disorganisation
Only illegitimate opportunities are within loosely organised gangs
Winning turf
releases young men’s frustration
What are retreatist subcultures?
double failures
not succeeded at a legitimate route so turn to illegal drug use
what is the Chicago school?
-cultural transmission theory
-differential association theory
-social disorganisation theory
what did the chicago school mean by cultural transmission?
some places develop a criminal tradition which passes through generations
what does the chicago school mean by differential association theory?
deviance learnt through social interactions with others who are deviant
what does the chicago school mean by social disorganisation theory?
changes like rapid population turn over and migration create instability disrupting family structure
unable to exercise social control
what is institutional anomie theory?
Messner and Rasenfelds
-American dream obsessed with money success which exerts pressure towards crime by encouraging an anomic cultural environment
(anything goes)
-school prepare for labour market instead of teaching values like respect
what are weaknesses of cloward and ohlin?
-Matza: drift in and out of subcultures
-reactive theories: form in reaction to failure of achievement mainstream goals not everyone shares them
-Miller: low class has own independent subculture which doesn’t value success so members are not frustrated by failure
what is Becker labelling theory in relation to deviance?
deviance is due to how people react
-masks in covid
reactions can depend on social context
-murder vs killing in war
what are moral entrepreneurs?
create laws and responsible for defining crime and deviance
how does labelling theory relate to sfp?
negative label effects self concept
(cooley-looking glass self)
-leads to deviance amplification and master status
what is Lemerts view on deviance and sfp?
primary deviance after someone commits offence
secondary deviance is the reactions of other which can lead to further offence
what do Piliavin and Briar say about labelling?
process of labelling by moral entrepreneurs were discriminatory
what do Piliavin and briar say about how reactions can effect likelihood of labelling?
-how person interacts with authorities (elaborated code of speech)
-appearance, background, personal biography
-situation and circumstances of the act
what does Cicourel say about labelling?
-agents of power label based on stereotypical typifications
-middle class don’t fit so can negotiate themselves out of the justice system
-reinforces stereotypes as they then don’t appear in official statistics
what is an study about the negotiation of justice?
Chambliss
saints and roughnecks
what do interactionists say the issue with official statistics is?
overpolicing of large groups
-leads to a dark figure of crime 7x more
-white collar criminals
what are examples of mc people getting away with crime?
Lindsay Lohan- drunk driving and drugs 1 day jail and 10 days community service)
-panama and paradise papers- leaked who isnt paying taxes including royal family
-Bullingdog boys- Cameron and Johnson
what does Lemert mean by primary deviance?
not publicly labelled or widespread. Often trivial and not an organised deviant way of life
What does Lemert mean by secondary deviance?
result of social reaction, stigmatised and humiliated
what does Lemert mean by master status?
only seen in terms of label so it become your controlling identity
wat does Lemert mean by deviant career?
secondary deviance reinforces outsider status and leads to a deviant career
what does Young mean by control culture?
police
hippies smoking marijuana in Notting hill
who did Stanely Cohen research in relation to moral panicks?
Mods and Rockers
fight in English seaside town
what does Cohen mean by folk devils?
media constructs a narrative with a clear villain
what does Cohen mean by moral panic?
any sensationalist
reaction is out of proportion
creates deviance amplification
what effect does labelling have on the criminal justice system ?
-laws are created against folk devils which pushes their deviance into secondary
-new crimes increase crime rates
-becker- marijuana tax
what types of shaming does Braithewaite identify?
-disintegrative
-reintegrative
what is disintegrative shaming?
crime and actor labelled negatively
what is reintegrative shaming?
crime and the actor are labelled differently
what type of shaming does Braithewaite believe should be used and why?
reintegrative
rehabilitation to prevent secondary deviance
-Norwegian prisons
what are evaluations of labelling?
-dark figure of crime
-abstracts theory, no solutions to the crime and its victims
-wealthy sometimes treated worse
what is criminogenic capitalism?
crime is inevitable as capitalism uses people as a means to an end whatever the cost (dog eat dog)
-capitalism encourages greed and self interest
what are examples of criminogenic capitalism?
Bernie Madoff- ponzie scheme
Deepwater horizon
how does law creation lead to crime?
law serve the interest of capitalism
Ruling class have power to prevent laws that threaten them
-Chambliss-laws that protect private property are the cornerstone of capitalist economy
-Selective enforcement of laws
What are examples of law creation leading to crime?
tax evasion is illegal, but tax avoidance is not
Presidential pardons
Crack/powdered cocaine
Regulation of businesses
how does law/crime act as an ideological function?
-occasionally laws a pet benefit working class (health and safety)
-Pearce-benefit really in class such as giving a healthy workforce
-stats show working class as criminals encouraging blaming of their class rather than capitalism
-Hi reality of crime stating it’s caused by mental illness
what are examples of the ideological functions of crime?
Minimum wage
Living wage
What are evaluations of Marxist theory?
-ignores crime caused by gender/age
-deterministic (overpredict working class crime)
-Not all societies have high crime rates
-ignores intra class crime