couples Flashcards
domestic division of labour
the way jobs and roles are shared between men and women the home
Parsons: instrumental and expressive role
instrumental role: the husband who performs paid work in the labour force/breadwinner
expressive role: the life who primary socialises children and meets family emotional needs.
summary of Parsons (func) and New right view on the dividing of labour
it is based on biological differences, women naturally suited to a more nurturing tole and men as a breadwinner.
This division is beneficial for men, women, children and wider society as it created primary socialisation for children that enables social stability and more women at home means less childcare and men at work = taxes for government.
summarise Bott joint and segregated conjugal roles
march of progress view as there’s been a shift from segregated to going conjugal roles.
segregated conjugal roles: separated gender roles (instrumental and expressive)
joint conjugal roles: couple share tasks equally
march of progress approach
society is always moving forward and improving
briefly summarise Young and Willmott (func) Bethnal Green study and idea of symmetrical family
longitudinal study found in 1950s roles were segregated and men were bread winners and women were homemakers but in 1970s when revisited they took a march of progress view as they now saw joint conjugal roles and symmetrical families.
there had been a rise in symmetrical families due to changing position of women, geographical mobility, new technology & labour saving devices, higher standards of living.
Today they argue roles are more likely to be shared and found 72% husbands did housework and women are more likely to share decision making. This is because women broke ties with their female kinship and draw their husband in more to housework/the family as women now have less children allowing them to go to work.
evaluation of Young and Willmott by Oakley ( liberal feminist)
criticised their research as it was based on one poorly designed question of if your husband helps with housework once a week meant you had a symmetrical family.
her research found only 15% men had a high level of participation on housework and 25% in childcare.
Warde and Hetherington (feminists) criticism of Young and Willmott
failed to see sex typing of domestic roles that still exists, with men cherry picking fun jobs
briefly summarise Gershuny (func) march of progress view of impact of paid work on families
found wives who work full time do less domestic work as men help out more due to increase in the new man.
supports Y&W symmetrical families
British Social Attitudes survey (2013) support for symmetrical families
found a fall in number of people thinking men should be the breadwinner and women should be homemaker
feminism criticisms of new man and BSA survey
little evidence of new man and BSA shows women do twice as much housework as men and couples continue to divide housework along traditional stereotypical gendered roles.
Ferri and Smith (1996)
- argue no symmetrical families
argue women have acquired dual burden (paid and unpaid work) so family remains patriarchal as men benefit off women’s earnings and domestic labour
Dex and Ward (2007)
- argue no symmetrical families
men take large role of playing with children (78% involvement) and only 1% tale main responsibility caring for sick child.
agree with Warde and Hetherington sex typing domestic roles
Duncombe and Marsden (2013)
- argue no symmetrical families
women perform a triple shift (paid, housework, emotional work)
Southerton (2013)
- argue no symmetrical families
women are responsible for organising family quality time