Contracts Flashcards
Contract Formation
What is needed to FORM a contract?
- mutual assent (offer + acceptance)
- consideration
Contract Formation: Offer
How is an offer CREATED?
- objective manifestation of intent––offeror has INTENT (willingness) to enter into a bargain
- definite and certain terms––offer has terms sufficient to allow a court to enforce K (e.g.,identity of parties, subject matter, price, quantity, etc.); and
- communication to an identified offeree––offeror is COMMUNICATED to offeree
Contract Formation: Offer
What is the requisite INTENT for creation of an offer?
Reasonableness standard - i.e., whether a reasonable person would believe the communication is an offer inviting acceptance
If yes –> intent met!
offeror manifests WILLINGNESS to enter into K!
Contract Formation: Offer
What are the essential terms for Ks under the COMMON LAW?
- Identity of Parties
- Description of property/service
- Quantity
- Price
- Time for Performance (duration)
Contract Formation: Offer
What are the essential terms for Ks under the UCC?
UCC allows for gap-filling –> only truly essential term is QUANTITY
* there is an assumption that there are “market prices” that can fill in the gaps –> price need not be stated
OVERARCHING PRINCPLE = K formed if
* both parties intend to K; and
* there is a reasonably certain basis for giving remedy
Contract Formation: Offer
Essential Terms for Ks under UCC: Requirements and Output Contracts
A requirements or output contract will NOT fail for lack of quantity.
* the amount sold or requested must:
(a) be in good faith and
(b) not unreasonably disproportionate to a stated estimate or prior comparable out
Contract Formation: Offer
Valid Ways to TERMINATE an offer
WAYS TO TERMINATE AN OFFER:.
1. Lapse of Time (reasonable time)
2. Rejection (expressly or counteroffer)
3. Revocation (expressly or constructively)
4. Operation of law
(a) Death/Mental Incapacity of either party
(b) Destruction/illegality of subject of offer
Contract Formation: Offer
Rejection (definition & effect)
Termination of Offer
definition
* manifestation of intent to NOT accept the offer
effect
* terminates offeree’s ability to accept offer
Formation of Contracts
Methods of REJECTING an offer
methods of rejection:
1. express rejection
2. counteroffer
3. conditional acceptance
4. acceptance with additional terms
Contract Formation: Offer
When does a REJECTION become effective?
Termination of Offer
effective when received by the offeror
* NOTE: if rejection is sent FIRST and THEN an acceptance is sent –> whichever is received FIRST is effective
Contract Formation: Offer
If a rejection is sent and then an acceptance is sent, which communication is effective?
Termination of an Offer
whichever is received FIRST by the receipient
Contract Formation: Offer
Methods of Revocation
Termination of an Offer
Methods of REVOKING an offer:
1. express revocation
2. constructive revocation
Contract Formation: Offer
UCC: When does REVOCATION become effective?
Termination of an Offer
a person receives notice of revocation when
1. it comes to that person’s attention, or
2. it is duly delivered in a reasonable form at the offeree’s place of business.
Contract Formation: Offer
What is EXPRESS revocation?
Termination of an Offer
unambiguous statement by offeror to the offeree
Contract Formation: Offer
What is CONSTRUCTIVE revocation?
Termination of an Offer
offerree becomes aware of offeror’s unambigous conduct or statement indicating an unwillingness or inability to contract
Contract Formation: Offer
Irrevocable Offers
(FOUR) categories
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
An offer can be revoked unless it falls into one of the (FOUR) categories:
1. F - Firm offer by a merchant in a signed writing under the UCC.
- O - Option contract - a promise to hold open the offer plusconsideration for that promise
- U - Unilateral K = if the offeree begins performance on a unilateral contract, the offer is held open for a reasonable time.
- R - Reasonably foreseeable detrimental reliance on the offer by the offeree
Contract Formation: Offer
UCC Firm Offer:
Requirements
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
Offer to buy/sell goods is irrevocable if:
1. the offeror is a merchant (any business person when transaction is commercial in nature)
2. there is an assurance that offer is to remain open for a stated time (or, if not stated, reasonable time up to 3 months)
3. the assurance is contained in a signed writing from the offeror
NOTE: NO CONSIDERATION REQUIRED
Contract Formation: Offer
UCC Firm Offer:
Duration of Irrevocability Period
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
DURATION: period of irrevocability = either
(i) as long as stated in the offer; or
(ii) for a reasonable period not to exceed 90 days
NOTE: If no stated duration –> reasonable period not to exceed 90 days
Contract Formation: Offer
Option Ks: Requirements for Consideration
(difference b/t COMMON LAW vs. UCC)
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
COMMON LAW
* consideration required in exchange for option
UCC:
* no consideration required
Contract Formation: Offer
UCC Firm Offer:
Writing Requirement when OFFEREE provides firm offer form to OFFEROR
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
If promise to hold offer open is on a form supplied by offeree –>
* must be separately authenticated by offeror to protect against inadvertent signing
* term of assurance must be separately signed “(e.g., by placing initials next to the sentence w/ assurance)
Contract Formation: Offer
Unilateral K + Offeree STARTS PERFORMANCE
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
start of performance makes offer irrevocable…
* for a reasonable time to complete performance
* start of performance MUST go beyond mere preparation
Contract Formation: Offer
Detrimental Reliance by Offeree
Termination of Offer: Irrevocable Offers
if offeree reasonably and detrimentally relies on offer in a foreseeable manner
–> offer may become irrevocable
Contract Formation: Offer
If offeree does not learn of offeror’s death/mental incapacity and sends what he believes to be an acceptance, WHAT RESULT?
Termination of Offer
offer is TERMINATED, even if offeree does not learn of offeror’s death until after the offeree has sent what he believes is an acceptance.
- EXCEPTION: offers for option Ks do not terminate b/c consideration was paid to keep offer open
Contract Formation: Acceptance
Terms of acceptance under COMMON LAW:
Mirror Image Rule
Terms of Acceptance
any acceptance must EXACTLY MIRROR the offer; it cannot add, omit, or change terms of the offer –>
* when the terms of the initial offer are changed
–> statement is a counteroffer, rather than an acceptance
Contract Formation: Acceptance
COMMON LAW:
Effect of acceptance with ADDITIONAL, OMITTED, or CHANGED terms?
Terms of an Acceptance
statement = COUNTEROFFER…NOT an acceptance
–> terminates OG offer and becomes new offer
NOTE: bargaining or requests for information are not counteroffers
Contract Formation: Acceptance
UCC:
Effect of acceptance with ADDITIONAL TERMS when BOTH parties are MERCHANTS
Terms of Acceptance
K is formed with additional terms UNLESS :
1. additional terms materially change offer
2. offer expressly limits acceptance to the offer’s terms, or
3. offeror objects within a reasonable time
Under majority rule, a different term is knocked out and replaced with gap fillers!
Contract Formation: Acceptance
UCC:
Effect of acceptance with ADDITIONAL TERMS when EITHER PARTY is NON-MERCHANT
Terms of Acceptance
K is formed, but without additional terms.
Contract Formation: Acceptance
COMMON LAW:
Permissible Methods of Acceptance for BILATERAL Ks
accepted by:
1. a promise to perform or
2. beginning performance - offeree must make offeror aware of acceptance
Contract Formation: Acceptance
COMMON LAW:
Permissible Methods of Acceptance for UNILATERAL Ks
can only be accepted by COMPLETE PERFORMANCE
* notice required upon completion - offeree not required to give notice upon strt of performance, but must notify offeror within a reasonable time upon completion
Contract Formation: Acceptance
Acceptance:
Definition
offeree’s clear expression of assent to terms of offor
What does it mean that offeror is the master of the offer?
that offeror controls method of acceptance and can dictate manner by which an offer is accepted
Contract Formation: Acceptance
UCC:
Acceptance by Shipment
a merchant may accept an offer to buy goods by either:
1. promise to ship goods (usually by written confirmation)
2. promptly shipping goods