Conduct rules, ethics and professional practice Flashcards
What is the central purpose of the RICS (3, To M, To P, To Be)?
- To maintain the highest standards of education and training
- To protect consumers through strict regulation of professional standards
- To be the leading source of information and independent advice on land, property, construction and associated environmental issues
How does the RICS ensure members abide by the Rules of Conduct for Members, 2007 (as amended 2013) (4 powers)?
Head of Regulation at the RICS investigates claims of misconduct. They have the power to:
- Serve a Fixed Penalty notice - used only for supply of info breaches.
- Make a Regulatory Compliance Order - low level breaches that can be easily corrected, written document stating actions to take within a specified time period.
- CPD sanctions - obligation to do some CPD req.
- Refer to a Disciplinary Panel - serious breaches, 50% are lay members (non RICS)
Member has right to appeal decision made at a Disciplinary Panel by going to an Appeal Panel
How does the RICS ensure firms abide by the Rules of Conduct for Firms, 2007 (as amended 2017) (3)?
RICS ensures firms comply by conducting audits
Firms have to provide information when:
registering with the RICS and
in an annual return
Why must a Chartered Surveyor do CPD (2 sort of)?
It is one of the Rules of Conduct for Members, 2007 (as amended 2013)
Ensures you remain up to date with relevant legislation and any changes in the industry
Why must a Chartered Surveyor main solvent (2 sort of)?
It is one of the Rules of Conduct for Members, 2007 (as amended 2013)
May impair your decision making and mean that you’re more likely to take bribes and not act in the best interest of the client
If you’re unable to manage your own finances, it does not reflect well on you being able to manage your client’s finances
What has the RICS produced to help surveyors make ethical decisions?
The RICS has created the Ethics Decision Tree, which members can refer to if they are asked to do something they are unsure about
How would you approach a conflict of interest (A, WA, M)?
Follow the guidance set out in the RICS Global Professional Statement on Conflicts of Interest, 2017:
- Conflict avoidance - decide whether the conflict is manageable and whether proceeding is in the best interest of all parties
- Written advice to both parties - disclose the nature of the conflict, explain how you will manage it and request written confirmation of informed consent (inform to seek independent advice if needed)
- Conflict management - set up an information in accordance with provisions agreed with the clients
What is money laundering?
Money laundering is legitimising the proceeds of crime.
Why does you firm have Terms of Engagement? What should be included in Terms of Engagement?
Creates a contract with the client
Sets out the proposed fee basis, payment of expenses and that a copy of of the firm’s complaints handling procedure is available upon request
How would you close down a practice (5, I,I,R,S,R)?
Inform the RICS
Inform clients and arrange for them to be handed over to a new firm
Return any clients’ money
Set-up professional indemnity run-off cover for a minimum of 6 years
Retain a copy of client files and record for a minimum of 6 years
What is the structure of the RICS (GC, who reports to, groups below GC and responsibilities)?
Governing Council (33 (now 25?) members) runs the RICS and provides management and strategic direction.
• They meet three times a year.
• New president every year.
Regulatory Board, Management Board and Audit Committee and various committees report to the Governing Council
17 specialist professional groups covering property, land and construction
Each professional group has an elected board and is responsible for outlining standards of competence and practice.
What changes have been made to the Royal Charter and Bye-Laws (GC, head position roles)?
Creating a smaller, more diverse and geographically representative Governing Council (i.e. only 6 for UK and EMEA)
Reduced size of Governing Council to a minimum of 25 seats, with 15 geographical seats
A new Chair of the Governing Council will act for up to 6 years
President will focus on ambassadorial duties and continue to be elected on an annual basis
Why would you like to be a Chartered Surveyor (5, S,R,M,K,N)?
- Status - professional credentials provide client confidence
- Recognition - promotion of your professional excellence
- Market advantage - RICS status gives you a competitive advantage
- Knowledge - International practice standards and professional guidance
- Network - access to over 140,000 members worldwide
What are the THREE benefits of regulation for firms (CPS)?
- Confidence - for client as regulated firms are monitored by RICS regulation
- Professionalism - firms have to provide clear, impartial and expert advice
- Security - firms have to have recognised CHP, access to ADR and PII cover
How many hours of CPD do you have to undertake, what are the rules, what other understanding must you maintain and how/by when must it be recorded?
Minimum of 20 hours of CPD per year, of which at least 10 hours must be formal
Member must maintain an understanding of RICS Professional and Ethical standards every 3 years
Members must record their CPD using the RICS CPD Management System on the RICS website by the 31st December
What are the Rules of Conduct for Members, 2007 (as amended 2013) (ECS CPD SIC)?
ECS CPD SIC:
Ethical behaviour Competence Service Continuing Professional Development (CPD) Solvency Information to the RICS Co-operation
What are the Part II - Conduct of Business Rules of Conduct for Firms, 2007 (as amended 2017) (PCS CPD CCI)?
PCS CPD CCI:
Professional behaviour Competence Service Continuing Professional Development (CPD) Complaints handling Clients' money Indemnity insurance
What information is required by the RICS for registration and in the annual return (6)?
- Type of business and staffing details
- Statutory regulated activities - such as for financial services
- Nature of clients
- Complaints handling procedure and records
- Professional indemnity insurance certificate
- Whether the firm hold clients’ money
Can you rely on due diligence checks undertaken by a solicitor/what document provides guidance?
Can only rely on information provided by a third party where there is an appropriate level of confidence in the quality of the information provided by that party
Guidance contained within RICS Countering bribery, corruption, money laundering and terrorist financing, 2019
If you are conflicted, can you still undertake an instruction if you’ve got informed consent?
Depends whether you would be able to act impartially, whether you believe that you undertaking the instruction would be in the best interest of all those who are or may be affected and whether its prohibited by law
What forms of conflict of interest are there (3)/what do they relate to?
Party Conflict - acting on both sides of a transaction
Own Interest Conflict - relating to a personal interest
Confidential Information Conflict - relating to work between two parties which is confidential
What would you do if you had a personal conflict of interest and how would you manage this?
Ensure that all parties were aware and provided informed consent
Would refer the instruction instruction internally and ensure that the appropriate information barriers were setup
What would you have to do if you were required to hold clients’ money?
RICS has issued a Professional Statement on Client Money Handling, 2019:
- Client account must be kept separate and clearly identifiable
- Word client is on the bank account and cheque book
- A client must be able to have their monies on demand
- Payment of interest is agreed with a client and accounts must be kept in credit
- Regular bank reconciliation
- Accurate records are kept with a running balance available
- Annual audit and reporting obligations by certified accountant employed by RICS
- If cash receipts are used to settle transactions, make sure records show all cash transactions
- Signatories must be agreed with authorised staff and two signatories should be required
- A discrete account is for a single named client account only
- RICS Regulatory Review Visits can be undertaken by RICS usually on a routine 3 yearly basis
- Firms handling client money need to display their procedure on their website
How many Principals in a firm have to be RICS members for a firm to be regulated (2 dates), and what is a Responsible Principle?
Until April 2020: a regulated firm is a practice that has 50% or more principals who are RICS members
From April 2020: if a practice provides surveying services and 50% of principals are RICS members, then it has to be regulated. If firms want to apply to be registered then they must now have more than 25% of Principals as RICS members (previously they only required one Principal to be an RICS member)
Responsible principal - firm must nominate a responsible principal who is obliged to ensure all steps are taken to ensure compliance with regulatory and RICS requirements, including reporting to the RICS
Why are the RICS requiring 25% of Principal to be members in order for firms to apply to be regulated?
Concerned that as the RICS profession and brand grows, having a single RICS qualified Principal does not provide sufficient assurance that RICS professional standards have adequate influence within the senior management of firms
What is the law associated with gift giving and receiving (2)?
Bribery Act 2010 and Proceeds of Crime Act 2002
What are the SIX principles of the Bribery Act 2010?
- Proportionality
- Top level commitment
- Risk assessment
- Due diligence
- Communication
- Monitoring and review
What are the FOUR offences under the Bribery Act 2010?
- Bribing
- Receiving a bribe
- Bribing a foreign public official
- Failing to prevent bribery
How would you define a bribe (4 actions, 3 types, 2 reasons)?
Bribe can be the giving, offering, promising or receiving of an advantage such as a payment, gift or a service for an action which is illegal or a breach of trust
What does the Ethics Decision Tree include, what does it encourage members to consider/ask, and what further assistance is available?
Framework of questions members should ask themselves
Encourages members to consider the legality of their action and the consistency with the RICS Global and Professional Ethical Standards
Ultimate question is whether members would be content to have their decisions or actions made public
RICS Regulation Confidential Hotline offers further assistance to members with any ethical issue
What is considered an appropriate margin of error (principle and 3 possibilities)?
When valuing it depends on the availability of comparable evidence and the complexity of the valuation, as to what would be an acceptable margin of error
±10% is usually considered to be a reasonable margin of error but more likely ±5% for residential property
Case of Dunfermline Building Society and CBRE (2017) assumed an acceptable margin of error of ±15%
What is the background to the RICS (founded, Charter, governance)?
Founded in 1868
RICS has a Royal Charter, granted by Privy Council in 1881
RICS Regulations and Bye-laws set out the governance of the institution
What are the FOUR levels of membership for the RICS?
- FRICS
- MRICS
- AssocRICS
- Trainee/Student
What must you do to achieve FRICS status (4)?
Provide evidence of achievement to the Fellowship assessor of FOUR Fellowship characteristics. They are grouped into the following categories:
- CHAMPION - a Member who has gained recognition by an appropriate authority.
- EXPERT - a Member who has been verified in advancing, sharing or interpreting knowledge.
- INFLUENCER - a Member who influences how professionalism is perceived.
- ROLE MODEL - a Member who exceeds standards for the advantage of clients, colleagues or the wider public.
A personal statement on current role, practices and ambitions.
What is the UK Structure of the RICS (3 levels)?
4 National Associations
10 Regional Boards
Local Associations
Who is the current CEO of the RICS?
Dr Sean Thompkins
Who is the current President of the RICS?
Kath Fontana (President elected from November 2020)
What are the FIVE Principles of RICS Regulation for Members and Firms?
PACTT:
- Proportionality: making the penalty proportional to the breach
- Accountability: to all members and the public
- Consistency: treating all members the same
- Targeting: serious breaches
- Transparency: to all members, clients and the public
What are the International Ethics Standards, 2016, and who publishes?
Ethical framework for the global property market
Published by the International Ethics Standards Coalition
What relevance do the International Ethics Standards, 2016 have for the RICS, and what may be a future prospect?
- Did not originate from the RICS but are promoted by the RICS
- RICS are currently reviewing the Global Professional and Ethical Standards, 2015 and may extend them to reflect the International Ethics Standards more closely
What are the Rules of Conduct, 2007 and how are they changing?
- Two short documents setting out the standards of professional conduct and practice expected of members and firms
- RICS announced in November 2019 that there would be a full review of the Rules of Conduct in 2020
In what circumstance will the RICS disciplinary procedure be triggered (3)?
Someone complaining to the RICS
Allegation by a client or third party
Information received or established by the RICS
What are the THREE levels of disciplinary action?
- Action by Head of Regulation
- Disciplinary panel
- Appeal panel
What are the THREE most common breaches of the Rule of Conduct for Firms, 2007 (as amended 2017)?
- Professional behaviour
- CPD
- Protecting client’s money
What FOUR actions can the Head of Regulation of the RICS impose?
- Fixed Penalty notice
- Compliance Order
- CPD Sanctions
- Refer to disciplinary panel
When would the Head of Regulation issue a Fixed Penalty notice?
Only used for breaches relating to the supply of information to the RICS by firms and members
What is a Compliance Order, and when used?
Written document which states the actions which the member or firm must take or desist from taking for a specified period of time
Used for minor breaches which can be easily corrected
When would the Head of Regulation refer the matter to a Disciplinary Panel?
Used for more serious breaches of conduct
Who forms the Disciplinary and Appeal Panels?
50% are lay members (non RICS members)
What are the FIVE penalties available to the Disciplinary Panel?
- Compliance Order
- Unlimited fine per breach (proportionate though)
- Impose conditions upon future continued RICS registration
- Expulsion from membership or remove a firm
- Publication of results (Modus, RICS website, local newspaper)
What does the Appeal Panel do in disciplinary proceeding/what power do they have?
Consider a member’s or firm’s appeal to the outcome of a disciplinary procedure
Will review the evidence previously presented and any new representations
Can allow the appeal and vary the penalty previously imposed
What is an RICS International standard?
High-level, principle-based mandatory standard developed in collaboration with other relevant organisations e.g. RICS Valuation - Global Standards, 2019
Give an example of 3 pieces of RICS Core material that you have had reference to in your work?
Conflicts of Interest, 2017
UK Commercial Real Estate Agency, 2016
Property Measurement, 2018
What is an RICS Practice Statement?
Document that provides members with mandatory requirements e.g. Surveyors Acting as Expert Witnesses, 2014
What is an RICS Guidance Note, and RICS recommendation?
Document provided by RICS to promote good practice. RICS strongly recommend that you have regard to the contents of any relevant guidance note e.g.
Comparable Evidence in Real Estate Valuation, 2019
What is an RICS Code of Practice, and status?
Document produced with other professional bodies and stakeholders to provide up-to-date research and advice to practitioners e.g. Rating Consultancy Code of Practice, 2017
Have the same status as a professional statement or a guidance note (mandatory or recommended good practice)
What should you consider during fee negotiations (2, 1 on RICS docs)?
Firms should avoid price fixing, aggressive fee cutting or collusion with competitors
Fees should be market-based and agreed on an ad-hoc basis with clients
Must consider the RICS Global Professional and Ethical Standards, 2015 and Rules of Conduct, 2007 as amended
What should you do if accepting or offering referral fees (3)?
- Must be completely transparent with your clients and consumers, so they understand you are receiving or offering a referral fee
- State in you terms of engagement if applicable
- Consider your actions in context of the Bribery Act 2010 and the RICS Global Professional and Ethical Standards, 2015
What steps should you follow when you receive instructions from a client (CIT)?
CIT:
- Competence
- Conflicts of interest check
- Terms of Engagement
What must your Terms of Engagement comply with if you’re undertaking agency work?
Section 18, Estate Agents Act 1979
Money Laundering, Terrorist Financing and Transfer of Funds (Information on the Payer) Regulations, 2017
What is the cooling off period following the establishment of Terms of Engagement?
Consumer Rights Act 2015 allows a cooling off period of 14 days from the date of the agreement
Why may it be appropriate to decline an instruction (5)?
- You are not competent to undertake the work
- You do not have sufficient facts on the issue
- Proposed client will not sign the terms of engagement or complete the AML checks
- There is a conflict of interest
- Proposed client is on the UK Government’s sanctions lists
What would you do if a family member or friend asked you for some advice on a pro bono basis?
I would be unable to give them advice as my firm’s professional indemnity insurance would not cover work carried out on a personal basis
I would refer them to another surveyor who would be able to advise them appropriately
What is a conflict of interest?
Arises when a member or firm’s independence and impartiality is threatened due to the existence of a conflict between two parties
What does RICS Conflicts of Interest, 2017 require all firms to have (2)?
Must have effective systems and controls in place appropriate to the size and complexity of their business, to ensure full compliance
Firms must keep records to show their compliance with the statement
How should your firm operate information barriers when Conflicts of Interest are being managed (4, think security and procedure)?
- “Reasonable steps” must be taken to operate an effective barrier to prevent information passing between the two parties
- Surveyors acting on the two sides must be different and be physically separated
- Information regarding the instruction should be securely stored
- Keep an audit trail of all actions taken. Firms Compliance Officer must oversee all actions