College 2 Flashcards
Power and leadership
What is leadership?
“Leadership is the process of influencing others to understand and agree about what needs to be done and how to do it, and the process of facilitating individual and collective efforts to accomplish shared objectives.”
It’s about influencing.
How can you be a leader?
- You have to stand out.
- You have to be easy to follow.
- You have to nurture your first followers and treat them as equal.
You are nothing without followers.
What is the difference between leaders and managers?
Manager
- A manager is a day-to-day problem solver.
- Managers are concerned with controlling the operations of the organization efficiently.
Leader
- A leader is focused on developing new approaches and options for the future.
- A leader has a strong vision.
- A leader inspires others to follow his or her vision for the organization.
What is the overlap between managers and leaders?
Managerial leadership: adapting to situational demands.
What are the different leadership approaches?
- Trait approach
- Behavior approach
- Situational approach
- LMX approach
- Transformational approach
- Moral approaches (ethical, authentic and servant)
The first one is the oldest and the bottom one is the newest approach. They are all still relevant today.
Trait approach
Leaders are born with talents and abilities for leadership.
- This gained popularity during WOII because they needed leaders for the divisions in the army.
Select the “right” people for leadership positions rather than train them.
Leaders exhibit special attributes that make them great leaders.
What is a criticism on the trait approach?
If you ask people with what characteristics they would describe a leader, they will come up with a lot of different characteristics.
A problem with this:
- Nobody has it all.
- It depends on the eye of the beholder.
- It doesn’t take the situation into account.
- It was difficult to predict the outcomes of good leadership.
o Because it depends on the situation and the follower.
So then they started to look at the behaviors of leaders.
Ohio State University Study
A list of leader behaviors followers came up with when asked to describe what their leaders did.
What are the categories for leader behaviors?
Initiating structure
- Focused on the task
- E.g., defining tasks, setting deadlines, focusing on goals, using standard operating procedures
Consideration
- Focused on the person, consideration for your followers
- It is more about trust, respect, making sure everyone is heard, reducing conflict, relational.
Blake mouton managerial grid
A grid with concern for results on the x-axis from low to high and on the y-axis concern for people from low to high.
What are the five management styles of the Blake mouton managerial grid?
- High concern for people and low concern for results = country club management
- Low concern for people and low concern for results = impoverished management
- High concern for people and high concern for results = team management
- Low concern for people and high concern for results = produce or perish management
- Middle concern for people and middle concern for results = middle-of-the-road management
Looking at the blake mouton managerial grid, what is the best management style?
Looking at this grid you would think team management is the best because it cares about the results and also has concerns about the people.
But this also appeared to be less predictive of the outcome. So, only focusing on the behavior does not always predict how well a team is performing.
What is the criticism on the blake mouton managerial grid?
One of the things that was missing was the situation.
What is the relationship between leadership and team performance moderated by/dependent on?
The situation or the context.
What can have a strong effect on the effectiveness of a leadership style on the team performance?
The situation or the context.
What are types of situations or context that can influence the relationship between leadership style and team performance?
- The task (e.g., boring or complex).
- The ability of the group (experts vs. amateurs).
- The urgency/time constraints.
- Competition (e.g., between leaders/teams).
Path-goal theory
A situational approach.
It is about how you can motivate your followers.
You can have a goal and a vision, but there can be certain obstacles. As a leader you can remove these obstacles by showing them a path and help them to clear the path to get to these goals.
Leaders motivate followers to accomplish goals by establishing the paths to the goals.
What are four leadership behaviors (to get to the goal)?
- Directive
- Supportive
- Participative
- Achievement-oriented
What is the directive leadership behavior (path-goal theory)?
- It’s about initiating structure
- It’s about the task
- What to expect
- Setting standards for performance
- E.g., setting clear goals, setting deadline, explaining the rules
What is the supportive leadership behavior (path-goal theory)?
- Related to consideration.
- Focused only on the person; focused more on the well-being of the people.
- E.g., showing concern for others, being friendly, being approachable.
What is the participative leadership behavior (path-goal theory)?
- You allow followers to have a voice in the decisions that affect them; that you’re open to the ideas of your followers.
- You share the information.
- About the person but also a little bit about the task.
- It’s a little bit more about the task than the supportive leadership behavior.
What is the achievement-oriented leadership behavior (path-goal theory)?
- Focused more on challenging followers to get to excellence.
- You set standards for excellence.
- Showing confidence that they will reach these goals.
True or false: in real life, according to the path-goal theory, you should only use one style depending on the type of situation.
False. In real life, according to the path-goal theory, you could use all of them depending on the type of situation, but you can also mix them a little bit, even though there is a clear distinction.
What leadership style could you use for a boring task, using the path-goal theory?
A boring task can use both a directive and supportive leadership style.
What is the criticism on the situational approach?
It doesn’t make a distinction between different types of followers. It looks at followers as a team; as a whole.
So, depending on the situation there is a different leadership style that is more effective, but this is only when you see the whole group as one.
This is why they came up with LMX, which makes a distinction between the different types of followers.
Who is a leader? Why are people following a leader?
Followership can be puzzling from an evolutionary perspective: a leader has the best sources, followers just follow.
You can be both a follower or a leader depending on the situation, e.g., in the time of gatherers and hunters you can be good in one field and bad in another field.
Exampleof the early humans: in the time of the hunters and gatherers there were egalitarian communities. So, there were leaders, but they depended on the situation, it was a rather informal role. If you were good at hunting, you would take the lead at hunting, but if you were not so good at something you would not take the lead and be more of a follower. So you can be both a follower and a leader. So it would really differ per situation and on the consensus, if everyone agreed with it.
What is important to take into account when you’re studying leadership and leadership styles?
It is really important to take into account the followership, because without followers there is no leader.
So to study leadership and leadership styles, it is important to take the role of the followers into account as well.
Leadership-member exchange model (LMX)
An approach that really focuses on the relationship between the leader and each individual member of a group.
What is the definition of a leader-member exchange (LMX)?
The quality of the working relationship that is developed with each individual follower.
What has the LMX model shown?
That in a relatively short period of time, leaders decide who is in their “in-group” and who is in their “out-group”.
Leader-Member Exchange in-group
- These are the leader’s “go to” people in a work group.
- They are dependable, trustworthy, and assist the leader in reaching his or her goals.
- They receive better performance evaluations; higher salary increases and are promoted at a rate faster than their peers.
Leader-Member Exchange out-group
- Out-group members are not poor performers.
- Out-group members perform to the specifications in their job descriptions but
o don’t go above and beyond
o don’t take on extra work
Leader-Member Exchange development
- Role taking
- They ask for more and look at who takes up this extra work - Role making
- The roles are established - Role routinization
- The leader knows where to go for what he needs
In the LMX it is not only from the side of the leader but also from the side of the follower.