cognitive explanations Flashcards
what did kholberg apply moral reasoning to?
kholberg applied moral reasoning to criminal behaviour
what did kholberg summarise?
he summarised that peoples decision to commit crime cab be summarised in the stage theory of moral development - higher the stage more sophisticated the reasoning
kholberg et al
using his own moral dilemma technique found a group of violent youths were significantly lower in their moral development than non-violent youths
what are criminal offenders likely to be classified as?
pre-conventional whereas non-criminals are classed as conventional and beyond
what is the pre-conventional level characterized as?
a need to avoid punishment and receive rewards and is associated with less mature childlike reasoning.
what do some studies suggest offenders are?
more egocentric and display poorer social perspective taking skills than non-offenders
chandler 1973
individuals who reason at higher levels tend to sympathise more with the rights of others and exhibit conventional behaviours such as honesty and generosity
cognitive distortions
errors in peoples infomation processing system researchers have linked this to the way in which criminals interpret others behaviour and justify their own actions
hostile attribution bias
evidence suggests people who commit violent crimes are associated with a tendency to misinterpret the actions of other people
minimilisation
an attempt to downplay the seriousness of the offence e.g burglars may describe themselves as doing a job as a way of minimising the seriousness of the crime.
level of moral reasoning evidence palmer and hollin
compared moral reasoning between 210 females non-offenders, 122 male non-offenders and 126 offenders using socio-moral dilemma questions.
the deliquent group showed less mature moral reasoning.
deliquant group showed less mature moral reasoning which supports kholberg
what did Gibbs 1979 do?
proposed a revised version of kholbergs theory compromising of mature and immature reasoning. these are equivalent to kholbergs pre and conventional levels
what did Gibbs argue?
argued that post conventional level should be abandoned as it is culturally biased.
understanding cognitive distortions
beneficial to treatment of criminals as it encourages offenders to face up to what they have done. reduces denial and risk of re offending
individual differences reid et al
found that individuals who committed crimes for financial gain such as robbery were more likely to show pre conventional moral reasoning